Bracketology: Preseason top five trying to regain form

More Bracketology: 1-349 RPI |  Head-to-head comparisons |  Palm Reader 

Those teams were loaded.  Kentucky Wildcats , Louisville Cardinals , Michigan State Spartans , Duke Blue Devils and Kansas Jayhawks were expected to rule this season.  Five teams battling for four No. 1 seeds in the bracket.  It hasn't happened.

Michigan State Spartans is still there, but we'll have to see for how long.  The injury bug has bitten the Spartans.  Adrien Payne hasn't played in a couple weeks because of a foot injury, and Branden Dawson suffered a stupid, self-inflicted broken hand that will sideline him for a month.

The other four have all struggled to some degree.  It hasn't been so bad that any of them are in danger of missing the tournament, but building a top-seed level resume hasn't been easy.

Kansas is the closest to making the comeback.  The Jayhawks have played the toughest schedule by an overwheling margin.  The difference between their rating and that of and SOS No. 2 Alabama Crimson Tide is .0768, which is roughly the same as the difference between the Tide and No. 79 Wake Forest Demon Deacons .  Early on, it looked like that was too tough a road for a young team, but since a home loss to San Diego State, the Jayhawks have ripped off five wins in a row, all against likely tournament teams.

Duke and Kentucky have been hit and miss. The Blue Devils lost to Kansas and Arizona Wildcats outside the league, and picked up a win over Michigan Wolverines , which looks a lot better now than it did at the time.  In the league though, they have losses at Clemson Tigers and Notre Dame Fighting Irish .  Those aren't terrible teams, but certainly beatable for a team as talented as Duke.

Kentucky has been a home court hero, which is where they beat Louisville Cardinals .  The Wildcats' only away from home wins are over Providence Friars in New York and at Vanderbilt Commodores .  All four losses have come away from home, including most recently at Arkansas Razorbacks (the king of home court heroes).  UK has four of its next six on the road.

Defending champ Louisville spent a lot of time near the bottom of my bracket, based primarily on a low number and quality of good wins.  Before the win at Connecticut Huskies , their best wins were at home over SMU and Southern Miss Golden Eagles .  Neither of those teams are sure at-large quality, and they only had one other top 100 RPI win (Missouri State - also at home).  So, the win over the Huskies filled a couple big holes in the Cards' resume, but there's still quite a way to go before they are contending for a No. 1 seed.

CBS Sports Senior Writer

Jerry Palm started writing about sports on the Internet right after Al Gore invented it. He was the first to bring RPI out in the open and is one of the pioneers of predicting the March Madness bracket.... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
CBS Sports Shop
Wildcats 2016 Champs Locker Room Gear
Our Latest Stories