2013 becoming the class of consensus


Class rankings are a bedrock of the recruiting industry and provoke the most debate from analysts, fans and even the coaches (who claim they don't look at them but really do check them out). While there is often a varied opinion about recruits -- few are "can't miss prospects" -- it seems like there's more consensus about the class of 2013 then past years.

Last week, MaxPreps released updated rankings and Rivals did the same on Tuesday. If you looked over them, you'll notice more than a handful of names that top each position. This made the Eye on Recruiting blog wonder, how much consensus has there been in the past? So we took the five major media recruiting services -- MaxPreps, Rivals, Scout, 247 and ESPN -- rankings from 2010-2013 and charted their top their top overall recruit, top recruit at each position and top player from California, Texas and Florida for every class.

The results? Indeed, it looks like there is more agreement on the top players for the upcoming class than any other the past several years. Defensive end Robert Nkemdiche is only the second consensus No. 1 overall recruit (Jadeveon Clowney in 2011 the other) and one of six spots where all five services agreed upon. Each company has different methodology but it's an interesting look at where everybody stacks up. This isn't a complete analysis we should caution and only looks at the top players.

Class of 2013
Top Position MaxPreps Rivals Scout 247 ESPN Consensus
Overall Robert Nkemdiche Nkemdiche Nkemdiche  Nkemdiche  Nkemdiche  YES
QB Max Browne (2) Browne (5) Browne (3) Browne (4) Tyrone Swoopes (9) 4/5
RB Ty Isaac (8) Derrick Green (12) Isaac (14) Kelvin Taylor (13) Taylor (22)  
WR Ahmad Fulwood (9) Ricky Seals-Jones (18) Robert Foster (10) Foster (11) Seals-Jones (7)  
TE O.J. Howard (12) Adam Breneman (27) Breneman (29) Breneman (28) Derrick Griffin (28)  
OL Laremy Tunsil (7) Tunsil (7) Tunsil (4) Tunsil (6) Tunsil (3) YES
DT Dee Liner (19) Montravius Adams (10) Adams (6) Adams (3) Liner (8)  
DE Nkemdiche (1) Nkemdiche (1) Nkemdiche (1)  Nkemdiche (1)  Nkemdiche (1)  YES
LB Reuben Foster (3) Foster (2) Foster (2)  Foster (2)  Foster (2)  YES
CB Vernon Hargreaves (29) Kendall Fuller (3) Hargreaves (13) Hargreaves (5) Hargreaves (4) 4/5
S Su'a Cravens (5) Cravens (8) Cravens (5) Cravens (8) Cravens (15) YES
ATH Ricky Seals-Jones (6) Derrick Henry (38) N/A Henry (15) Kendell Beckwith (16)  
Calif. Cravens (5) Cravens (8) Cravens (5) Cravens (8) Cravens (15) YES
Texas Tyrone Swoopes (4) Swoopes (17) Ricky Seals-Jones (12) Keith Ford (24) Seals-Jones (7)  
Fla. Tunsil (7) Tunsil (7) Tunsil (4) Hargreaves (5) Tunsil (3) 4/5

Obviously the big deal for the upcoming group is Nkemdiche, who has been regarded as the top overall prospect for the past two years (at least) and probably ranks behind only Clowney as a recruit coming out of high school the past decade. There is close to a consensus on Max Browne being the top signal-caller in the class and everybody sees Su'a Cravens as the safety you can't pass on. Laremy Tunsil and Reuben Foster are both consensus top seven recruits with every service ranking Foster in the top three. Also notable is tight end Adam Breneman, who headlines a strangely strong year for tight ends by being in the top two at his position on every list.

Class of 2012
Top Position MaxPreps Rivals Scout 247 ESPN Consensus
Overall Dorial Green-Beckham Green-Beckham Green-Beckham  Mario Edwards Edwards  
QB Gunner Kiel (2) Jameis Winston (10) Kiel (38) Kiel (24) Winston (14)  
RB Johnathan Gray (9) Gray (5) Keith Marshall (12) Gray (9) Gray (2)  4/5
WR Green-Beckham (1) Green-Beckham (1) Green-Beckham (1) Green-Beckham (2) Green-Beckham (3)  YES
TE Kent Taylor (28) Taylor (54) Taylor (73) Ricky Parks (Not top 100) Jalen Cope-Fitzpatrick (Not top 100)  
OL John Theus (7) D.J. Humphries (2) Arik Armstead (2) Humphries (5) Humphries (7)  
DT Ellis McCarthy (6) Mario Edwards (3) Malcom Brown (17) Edwards (1) Eddie Goldman (10)  
DE Noah Spence (3) Jonathan Bullard (6) Mario Edwards (4) Spence (12) Edwards (1)  
LB Vince Biegel (34) Jabari Ruffin (40) Reggie Ragland (22) Ryan Anderson (19) Josh Harvey-Clemons (17)  
CB Geno Smith (23) Tracy Howard (13) Ronald Darby (9) Darby (16) Howard (18)  
S Shaq Thompson (5) Thompson (4) Thompson (3) Landon Collins (3) Collins (6)  
ATH Nelson Agholor (13) Eddie Williams (24) N/A Arik Armstead (4) Davonte Neal (8)  
Calif. Thompson (5) Thompson (4) Armstead (2) Armstead (4) Thompson (16)  
Texas Mario Edwards (4) Edwards (3) Edwards (4) Edwards (1) Edwards (1)  YES
Fla. Theus (7) Howard (13) Theus (7) Eddie Williams (8) Williams (11)  

2012 saw wide receiver Dorial Green-Beckham come close to a consensus No. 1 overall ranking but he was nudged out by Mario Edwards after the latter's big senior year (Green-Beckham set the national receiving record so he wasn't exactly a slouch either). Though the two were the only players that everybody agreed about (with Edwards as Texas' top player), there was some positions that came close. At quarterback, Gunner Kiel and Jameis Winston were the top two players on everybody's board and if you broke them apart as dual threat/pro-style, there would indeed be a consensus reached. What is interesting to see in this class is somebody like Arik Armstead, who had a wide range of rankings and positions, from top athlete to offensive tackle. Keep in mind he headed to Oregon as a defensive tackle but wasn't the top guy at that spot in anybody's rankings.

A weak year for tight ends, Kent Taylor also came close to being the unanimous choice while Johnathan Gray just missed too. It's also interesting to note that nobody could agree on who the top player at linebacker was but, looking at overall rankings, everybody thought it was a weak year at the top.

Class of 2011
Top Position MaxPreps Rivals Scout 247 ESPN Consensus
Overall Jadeveon Clowney Clowney Clowney  Clowney  Clowney  YES
QB Braxton Miller (8) Jeff Driskel (32) Driskel (34) Driskel (13) Driskel (10) 4/5
RB Savon Huggins (5) Malcolm Brown (10) Brown (9) De'Anthony Thomas (5) Isaiah Crowell (4)  
WR George Farmer (20) Farmer (3) Trey Metoyer (21) Sammy Watkins (9) Farmer (12)  
TE Jay Rome (26) Nick O'Leary (33) Ben Koyack (25) O'Leary (16) Rome (18)  
OL Cyrus Kouandjio (3) Kounadjio (4) Kounadjio (2) Kounadjio (2) Kounadjio (3) YES
DT Anthony Johnson (12) Johnson (17) Johnson (4) Timmy Jernigan (4) Johnson (2) 4/5
DE Clowney (1) Clowney (1) Clowney (1) Clowney (1) Clowney (1) YES
LB Stephone Anthony (4) Curtis Grant (2) Trey DePriest (6) Anthony (10) Tony Steward (9)  
CB Doran Grant (32) Malcolm Mitchell (30) De'Anthony Thomas (3) Demetrious Nicholson (39) Quandre Diggs (21)  
S Karlos Williams (9) Ha Ha Clinton-Dix (7) Clinton-Dix (7) Williams (7) Williams (5)  
ATH James Wilder (2) De'Anthony Thomas (5) N/A Wilder (27) Thomas (16)  
Calif. De'Anthony Thomas (15) Farmer (3) Thomas (3) Thomas (5) Farmer (12)  
Texas Malcolm Brown (10) Brown (10) Brown (9) Steve Edmond (15) Brown (7) 4/5 
Fla. Wilder (2) Driskel (32) Clinton-Dix (7) Jernigan (4) Williams (5)  

Clowney was celebrated as the first consensus top recruit in some time and based on how he abused some offensive tackles in the SEC, it's hard to look back and disagree. It was a weak year for signal-callers but Jeff Driskel was mostly regarded as the top guy and there was complete agreement on the trenches with Cyrus Kounadjio being a consensus top three player. One interesting thing to note is how all over the map De'Anthony Thomas was.

Class of 2010
Top Position MaxPreps Rivals Scout 247 ESPN Consensus
Overall Seantrel Henderson Ronald Powell Henderson Powell Powell  
QB Blake Bell (5) Jake Heaps (63) Heaps (21) Phillip Sims (39) Sims (32)  
RB Marcus Lattimore (2) Lattimore (10) Lattimore (9) Dillon Baxter (9) Michael Dyer (5)  
WR Robert Woods (6) Kyle Prater (3) Woods (3) Woods (2) Woods (7) 4/5
TE C.J. Fiedorowicz (16) Xavier Grimble (51) Grimble (31) Grimble (18) Grimble (31) 4/5
OL Henderson (1) Henderson (2) Henderson (1) Henderson (6) Henderson (8) YES
DT Sharrif Floyd (11) Floyd (4) Floyd (6) Dominique Easley (4) Easley (3)  
DE Jackson Jeffcoat (3) Powell (1) Powell (2) Powell (1) Jeffcoat (2)  
LB Jordan Hicks (22) Hicks (16) Chris Martin (10) Hicks (5) Hicks (4) 4/5
CB Lamarcus Joyner (15) Joyner (14) Demarcus Millner (16) Josh Shaw (10) Joyner (6)  
S Matt Elam (27) Keenan Allen (5) Allen (5) Elam (15) Jonathan Dowling (10)  
ATH Anthony Barr (14) Robert Woods (6) N/A Lamarcus Joyner (14) Powell (1)  
Calif. Woods (6) Powell (1) Powell (2) Powell (1) Powell (1) 4/5
Texas Jeffcoat (3) Jeffcoat (12) Jeffcoat (7) Jeffcoat (7) Jeffcoat (2) YES
Fla. Joyner (15) Joyner (14) Christian Green (19) Joyner (14) Joyner (6) 4/5

If any class comes close to 2013 in terms of reaching a consensus, it's 2010. Everybody had Seantrel Henderson or Ronald Powell at the top and the former was everybody's top lineman. Robert Woods came close to running the table but was ironically stopped by his now-former USC teammate Kyle Prater. The only state that produced two consensus top players was Texas and Jeffcoat was half of the reason why.
Show Comments Hide Comments
CBS Sports Shop
College Football Playoff Gear
Our Latest Stories