Nick Florence joins illustrious line of Heisman replacements

Nick Florence has some Heisman-sized shoes to fill. How well will he? (Getty Images)

The Heisman fraternity is an elite club filled with some of the most memorable names in college football history. 

Just as elite, but far less memorable in some cases, are those players who had to replace those Heisman winners the following season.

Baylor's Nick Florence is about to become a new inductee into that group.

The senior from Garland, Texas, has the unenviable task of taking over for Robert Griffin III at quarterback for the Bears. Consequently, he is destined to be judged against the incredible standard set by the greatest player in Baylor history. His first bad throw will no doubt elicit "RG3 wouldn't have done that" comments from the Bears faithful.  

Florence has certainly shown flashes of brilliance, including a 9-for-11 half (with three total touchdowns) in relief of an injured Griffin III against Texas Tech last season. He'll benefit from Art Briles' quarterback-friendly, wide-open offense that allows him to distribute the ball to athletes in space. The guess here is that the statistical dropoff won't be huge for Baylor at the quarterback position, but that it's going to be hard to replicate the leadership and clutch play RG3 brought to the table. 

It will be up to Florence to help ensure that, years from now, RG3's accomplishments aren't viewed as anomalies. But, in the end, perhaps Florence shouldn't be measured against what Griffin III did, but against what other Heisman replacements have done.  Here's a look at the last 30 players who replaced a Heisman winner as starter and what they did in those seasons.

Some handled the pressure better than others. 

Player/Year Heisman Replaced Result

Barett Trotter/2011

Trent Richardson/2011

Cam Newton

Mark Ingram

1,184 yds, 11 TDs

1,679 yds, 21 TDs, 3rd in Heisman vote, led team to BCS title

John Brantley/2010 Tim Tebow 2,061 yds, 9 TDs
Landry Jones/2009 Sam Bradford 3,198 yds, 26 TDs
Todd Boeckman/2007 Troy Smith 2,372 yds, 25 TDs, led Buckeyes to BCS title game

Chaunce Washington/2006

J.D. Booty/2006

Reggie Bush

Matt Leinart

744 yds, 9 TDs

3,347 yds, 29 TDs

Rhett Bomar/2005 Jason White 2,018 yds, 10 TDs
Matt Leinart/2003 Carson Palmer 3,556 yds, 38 TDs, 6th in Heisman, led USC to national title
Jamaal Lord/2002 Eric Crouch 1,412 rush yds, 1,362 pass yds
Chris Rix/2001 Chris Weinke 2,734 yds, 24 TDs
Mike Bennett/2000 Ron Dayne 1,598 yds, 10 TDs
Hodges Mitchell/1999 Ricky Williams 1,343 yds, 9 TDs
James Whitley/1998 Charles Woodson 3 INTs, 8.9 PR avg.
Doug Johnson/1997 Danny Weurffel 2,023 yds, 21 TDs
Pepe Pearson/1996 Eddie George 1,484 yds, 17 TDs
Herchell Troutman/1995 Rashaan Salaam 826 yds, 5 TDs
Danny Kanell/1994 Charlie Ward 2,781 yds, 17 TDs
Frank Costa/1993 Gino Torretta 1,325 yds, 5 TDs

Derrick Alexander/1992

Ryan Hancock/1992

Des Howard

Ty Detmer

50 rec, 740 yds, 11 TDs

2,735 yds, 17 TDs

David Klingler/1990 Andre Ware 5,140 yds, 54 TDs, 5th in Heisman vote
Gerald Hudson/1989 Barry Sanders 910 rush yds
Raghib Ismail/1988 Tim Brown 12 rec, 331 yds, 2 TDs
Steve Walsh/1987 Vinny Testaverde 2,249 yds, 19 TDs, led team to national title
Brent Fullwood/1986 Bo Jackson 1,391 yds, 10 TDs. 6th in Heisman vote
Shawn Halloran/1985 Doug Flutie 2,935 yds, 12 TDs
Jeff Smith/1984 Mike Rozier 935 yds, 7 TDs
Kevin Montgomery/1983 Herschel Walker 559 yds, 7 TDs
Todd Spencer/1982 Marcus Allen 596 yds, 8 TDs
Show Comments Hide Comments
CBS Sports Shop
College Football Playoff Gear
Our Latest Stories