• My Scores
  • NFL
  • NBA
  • NHL
  • Golf
College Basketball Insider

Haith, Pearl lie to NCAA, but Haith gets 5 games and Pearl show cause?

Frank Haith and Bruce Pearl essentially did the same thing -- lie to the NCAA. (USATSI)
Frank Haith and Bruce Pearl essentially did the same thing -- lie to the NCAA. (USATSI)

People love to mention, particularly on Twitter, that the NCAA hit Bruce Pearl with a three-year show cause penalty because of an improper cookout attended by recruits. It's simple and somewhat funny. So it's a line that gets repeated over and over and over again.

But it's not really true.

That's never actually been true.

Ask anybody at the NCAA or Tennessee, and they'll explain in great detail that Pearl's biggest crime wasn't holding a cookout for high school juniors in violation of NCAA bylaws. His biggest crime, they've always insisted, was misleading investigators when asked about the cookout. Simply put, Pearl lied. And the lesson the NCAA wanted to send by hammering Pearl and effectively ending his coaching career (at least until somebody hires him next year) is that lying to the NCAA is a line that should not be crossed.

So why is the message delivered Tuesday so different?

That's the question I immediately had when the NCAA announced its sanctions against Miami stemming from a lengthy and compromised investigation that, as SI.com's Pete Thamel pointed out on Twitter, probably did more damage to the NCAA than Miami. If Pearl got a three-year show-cause penalty for lying to the NCAA that's so severe that the mere anticipation of it cost him and his staff their jobs, why did former Miami coach Frank Haith -- now the head coach at Missouri -- only get a five-game suspension for allegedly lying to the NCAA about something far worse than a cookout?

You haven't read the 102-page report yet?

That's fine.

Because I have (at least the parts related to the basketball program).

And the most important thing you need to know is that the NCAA made a "factual conclusion" that Haith changed his story multiple times about why he issued unusual "advanced checks" to three assistants. According to the report, Haith initially said the checks were issued because the assistants "had personal obligations and were financially struggling" before ultimately acknowledging that he wrote the checks to create cash designed to repay former booster Nevin Shapiro in hopes of ensuring he wouldn't talk about a number of things, including an allegation that Shaprio had used money to help secure a commitment from a basketball recruit named Dequan Jones.

Now I'm not interested in debating whether Shapiro really bought Jones' commitment nor do I care to discuss whether Haith knew about it. The evidence, it should be noted, is overwhelming. But to focus on that is to miss the point entirely because the point is that, regardless of what actually happened, Haith interviewed with the NCAA three different times and changed his story drastically, meaning he lied to the NCAA just like Pearl lied to the NCAA. And yet Haith will not get a show-cause penalty, and there's no reason to think he'll lose his job at Missouri. His only real punishment for lying to the NCAA is a five-game suspension that'll be served at the beginning of this season, which means Haith's only real punishment for lying to the NCAA will consist of him missing games against Southeast Louisiana, Southern Illinois, Hawaii, Gardner Webb and IUPUI.

(Devastating, right?)

So, to summarize, Bruce Pearl got a three-year show-cause penalty for lying to the NCAA about a cookout while Frank Haith got nothing more than a mostly meaningless five-game suspension for lying to the NCAA about money the NCAA "factually concluded" was designed to keep a booster quiet about an alleged major recruiting violation. I'll let somebody else decide whether Pearl's penalty was too harsh or Haith's penalty is too light. All I know is that the penalties aren't even close to consistent with each other, and that's why most fans of college athletics -- and all fans of Tennessee athletics -- are baffled this afternoon.

Also baffled: Bruce Pearl's son, Steven Pearl.

"My biggest thing is consistency," Steven Pearl tweeted Tuesday. "What Bruce did was wrong. He admitted to his mistake. But everyone needs to be held to that same standard."

Well put, Steven.

Problem is, that's never been how the NCAA operates.

And, I'm starting to think, that'll never be how the NCAA operates.

Gary Parrish is a senior college basketball columnist for CBSSports.com and college basketball insider for the CBS Sports Network. The Mississippi native also hosts an award-winning radio show in Memphis. He lives in that area with his wife, two sons and two dogs.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre

Latest Video

November 25, 2015
November 24, 2015
Mark Turgeon on win over Illinois State
November 24, 2015
Gary Parrish On Miami Hurricanes
November 24, 2015
CBB Minute: 11/24


Most Popular

2015 NCAA Tournament
Final Four