• My Scores
  • NHL
  • NFL
  • NBA
Bracketology/Bowls Expert

Bracketology: Cuse loss shuffles top line; voters too high on Louisville

More Bracketology: Bubble Watch | Compare two teams | Palm Reader

The battle for the top of the bracket is interesting this year. There really isn't a dominant team. You can make a case for any of three teams as the overall No. 1. I went with undefeated Wichita State, despite playing a lesser schedule than the other contenders. There's a case for Syracuse, which only has one loss, but it came to Boston College. At home. Florida is strong too but has two losses. The Gators are hot, but they're hot against SEC teams.

Arizona is still on the top line, but they have two recent losses, both of which came after the injury to Brandon Ashley. They still merit a No. 1 seed, but aren't really contending for the overall No. 1.

I think this battle is far from over.

The other end of the bracket continues to churn, which is typical. Teams down there are inconsistent, which is why they're at the bottom of the at-large pool in the first place. Minnesota took the biggest hit this week with a home loss to Illinois, but Georgetown dropped out entirely after a second loss to Seton Hall. Oklahoma State is also falling as the losses continue to pile up.

One team that dropped without losing is Louisville. The Cards' profile just doesn't look good enough for a top-five seed. In fact, historically speaking, it doesn't look good enough for a single-digit seed. They may be loved by poll voters, but they only have three top-100 RPI wins. Before the committee took an ill-advised flier on Middle Tennessee State last year, three such wins was the bare minimum just to get an at-large bid, and it hadn't been enough since 2003. No team with just three top-100 RPI wins has ever received a seed better than No. 11. Louisville is ranked 11th in the AP poll and fifth in the coaches poll. That's a very rare dichotomy.

The next bracket will be Monday, and at that time, I'll begin doing updates daily.

Losing at home to Boston College costs Syracuse the No. 1 overall seed ... for now. (USATSI)
Losing at home to Boston College costs Syracuse the No. 1 overall seed ... for now. (USATSI)

CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre

Latest Video

December 24, 2014
3 Arizona at UNLV recap (2:51)
December 23, 2014
Georgia Tech at Dayton recap
December 20, 2014
Calipari and Cauley-Stein on dominant win over UCLA
December 20, 2014
No. 1 Kentucky vs. UCLA highlights


Most Popular

CBSSports.com Shop