powered by Google  
  Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 

Arena Wars: The Final Showdown - NCAA Division I Mens Basketball Sports News
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Home   Fantasy     NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  More CBS College | MaxPreps | Mobile | Shop  
Coll BK Home | Scoreboard | Standings | Schedules | Stats | Teams | Players | Rankings | Video | Women
 

Arena Wars: The Final Showdown

We've completed nine weeks of Arena Wars.

Readers, you have spoken.

Rank the arenas
After reading Gary Parrish's rankings, think you know better?

Rather than simply vote for the one arena which you think is best, we want your full rundown from No. 1 to No. 9.

So place your rankings in this thread and we'll tally the results and reveal the community consensus Wed., Aug. 12.
You took Pauley Pavilion over McArthur Court. And Allen Fieldhouse over Gallagher-Iba Arena. And Indiana's Assembly Hall over Illinois' Assembly Hall. And the Breslin Center over the Kohl Center. And the Carrier Dome over Gampel Pavilion. And Memorial Gym over Williams Arena. And The Pit over The Palestra. And Rupp Arena over Freedom Hall.

And finally, last week, Cameron Indoor Stadium over the Dean Smith Center.

My only complaint: The Pit over The Palestra.

Shame on you people. But what's done is done, and that is done.

Now it's time to take all nine winners (even if I don't agree with all nine winners) and rank them. We had planned to throw them in one big poll and see which college basketball arena emerged with the most votes, but that's too easy. Plus Rupp Arena would run away the thing.

Why Rupp?

Because Kentucky plays in Rupp Arena, which means Kentucky fans would skew the results because, frankly, they just care about this kind of stuff more than the rest of you. As I've pointed out before, any online poll that includes somebody or something connected to Kentucky basketball will be won by somebody or something connected to Kentucky basketball. It never fails.

Swear to God, if you asked for the best coach in NCAA history and made the choices John Wooden, Bob Knight, Mike Krzyzewski and John Calipari, Calipari would win by at least 18 percent of the vote. Likewise, if you asked for the best Beatles album and made the choices Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, Revolver, Abbey Road and Rupp Arena, Rupp Arena would win easily, and -- case you didn't know -- there's not even a Beatles album called Rupp Arena.

But that doesn't matter.

Kentucky fans would vote Rupp Arena the best Beatles album.

They'd do it convincingly and with great pride.

I know Rupp Arena is not the country's greatest arena, but I also know that there's no way any arena except Rupp would take this thing in a straight up vote. So if Rupp is going to win Arena Wars, we're going to make Kentucky fans work a little. It's the college basketball offseason after all, you have some extra time on your hands. Without further ado, let's get started.

(Editor's note: The following is how Gary Parrish ranks the weekly winners of Arena Wars. But he implores you to remember that this is not his ranking of college basketball arenas in general, just his ranking of the college basketball arenas that readers picked as winners during nine weeks of Arena Wars. Yes, there is a difference.)

1. Cameron Indoor Stadium -- home of the Duke Blue Devils
Cameron Indoor Stadium (Getty Images)
(Getty Images)  
Parrish says: It's the perfect combination of tradition, atmosphere and high-level hoops. It's the Sgt. Pepper of college basketball buildings.

Did you know? According to most accounts, the origin of Krzyzewskiville dates to 1986, when a group of friends set up a tent outside Cameron Indoor on a Thursday in anticipation of a Saturday game against North Carolina. Other students followed and by gametime there were at least 75 tents lined up outside. The Blue Devils rewarded the campers with an 85-72 victory over the Tar Heels.


Read Cameron Indoor Stadium vs. Dean Smith Center

2. Allen Fieldhouse -- home of the Kansas Jayhawks
Allen Fieldhouse (Getty Images)
(Getty Images)  
Parrish says: That Rock Chalk Jayhawk chant is pretty freaking awesome.

Did you know? Because of a federal mandate restricting steel consumption following World War II and during the Korean War, the university wasn't in a position of strength to get an arena built in the late 1940s, early '50s. So to get final funding and begin construction, officials lobbied that the arena could be used as an armory, adding rooms for gun and weapons storage.


Read Allen Fieldhouse vs. Gallagher-Iba Arena

3. Pauley Pavilion -- home of the UCLA Bruins
Pauley Pavilion (Getty Images)
(Getty Images)  
Parrish says: There's a reason Pauley Pavilion is undergoing a massive upgrade, and the reason is because it needs it. Honestly, the place is kind of a dump on the inside. But it still has unmatched tradition, lots of banners and beautiful scenery. So there's no way I can get it out of the top three.

Did you know? A $185+ million expansion and renovation is scheduled to begin in February 2010 to be completed in the Fall of 2012. UCLA's longest winning streak in Pauley Pavilion has been 98 games (1970-76).


Read McArthur Court vs. Pauley Pavilion

4. Assembly Hall -- home of the Indiana Hoosiers
Assembly Hall (US Presswire)
(U.S. Presswire)  
Parrish says: I've only been there once, and it was right at the end of Kelvin Sampson's tenure. But what I remember most from that night is how the place seemed absolutely bananas, from 45 minutes before tip-off until the final buzzer. So I can only imagine what it'll be like when Tom Crean gets things rebuilt.

Did you know? The court is named after Branch McCracken, the coach who led the school to its first two national championships in 1940 and 1953.


Read Assembly Hall vs. Assembly Hall

5. Rupp Arena -- home of the Kentucky Wildcats
Assembly Hall (US Presswire)
(courtesy University of Kentucky)  
Parrish says: Again, it's not the best. But it's impossible to ignore a place that can draw 24,000 for a practice, just because.

Did you know? Rupp is the largest arena in the United States built specifically for basketball. It's the only off-campus basketball arena in use in the SEC.


Read Freedom Hall vs. Rupp Arena

6. Memorial Gymnasium -- home of the Vanderbilt Commodores
Memorial Gymnasium (courtesy Vanderbilt University)
(courtesy Vanderbilt University)  
Parrish says: Vandy's arena is quirky enough to be cool, weird enough to be appealing.

Did you know? Memorial Gym is the only NCAA Division I arena in which team benches are located on the baselines rather than on the sidelines.


Read Memorial Gymnasium vs. Williams Arena

7. Breslin Center -- home of the Michigan State Spartans
Breslin Center (Getty Images)
(Getty Images)  
Parrish says: They have the Izzone at Michigan State, and it's hard to argue with that.

Did you know? The arena is named for Jack Breslin, MSU alumnus, former athlete and administrator, who first began pushing for the arena as far back as 1969. Breslin was the captain and most valuable player of the 1945 football team.


Read Breslin Center vs. Kohl Center

8. Carrier Dome -- home of the Syracuse Orange
Carrier Dome (U.S. Presswire)
(U.S. Presswire)  
Parrish says: I don't like basketball in a dome. For that, the Carrier Dome is punished.

Did you know? The Carrier Dome is the largest domed stadium on any college campus and the largest domed stadium in the northeastern United States. It is also the nation's largest on-campus basketball arena.


Read Carrier Dome vs. Gampel Pavilion

9. University Arena (The Pit) -- home of the New Mexico Lobos
University Arena (courtesy University of New Mexico)
(courtesy University of New Mexico)  
Parrish says: The Pit is last here because it shouldn't even be here. It's neat, but not neater than The Palestra.

Did you know? The 1983 national championship game in which coach Jim Valvano's North Carolina State Wolfpack upset the Houston Cougars 54-52 on a last-second dunk by Lorenzo Charles was held at University Arena.


Read The Palestra vs. The Pit

 
For more from Gary Parrish, check him out on Twitter: @GaryParrishCBS
 

Talk Back
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 14, 2006

August 5, 2009 5:14 pm
After reading Gary Parrish's rankings, think you know better?

Rather than simply voting for the one arena which you think is best, we want your full rundown from No. 1 to No. 9.

So place your rankings in this thread and we'll tally the results and reveal the community consensus Wed., Aug. 5.

For your rankings to count in the community consensus:

1. Yo
...(more)
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Dec 28, 2007

August 5, 2009 6:36 pm
If memory serves me correctly UT had the 2nd or 3rd longest home court winning streak prior to this year's rough campaign. Thompson Boling is a tough atmosphere which is why they had such an impressive streak.
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Mar 13, 2008

August 5, 2009 11:42 pm
When Gary said that Cameron Indoor Stadium was the Seargent Pepper of basketball arenas he was right on the money.  But not for the reason he thought.

Pepper and Cameron are perfect parallels.  Both were groundbreaking.  Both were critically acclaimed.  Both were hyped well beyond their measurable worth. 

Every Beatle has been quoted on this subject
...(more)
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 29, 2006

August 6, 2009 10:20 am
As Gary mentioned, we Kentucky fans are a very unique breed......we are well beyond passionate about ANYTHING that has to do with Kentucky basketball. That is why, no matter how you construct this poll, no matter which arena's we are matched against, no matter how the elimination process is contructed......this poll is essentially over. The poll includes Kentucky basketball as a voting option, the ...(more)
Reputation:90
Level:All-Star
Since:Mar 24, 2008

August 6, 2009 1:56 pm
I really need to visit their gym.

Glad to see The Phog up there. I have to admit I'm biased, but it's nice to see most major-media types also enjoy our atmosphere here in Lawrence.

Also, I'm with you on the Pitt debacle, Gary. The Palestra IS college basketball. The Pitt is NEW MEXICO college basketball. No knock there towards the Lobos, but come on.
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Oct 28, 2007

August 8, 2009 3:42 pm
In regards to the Hoosier's homecourt,

I have only been there once So you obviously are the expert on great arenas and the atmoshpere at Assembly Hall.


In regards to UCLA's homecourt,Honestly, the place is kind of a dump on the inside.......... So there's no way I can get it out of the top three.
...(more)
Reputation:88
Level:All-Star
Since:Oct 5, 2008

August 5, 2009 10:18 pm
1. Rupp Arena (Simply the best college bball atmosphere in the nation)
2. Allen Fieldhouse (Rockchalk jay hawk is pretty cool)
3. Pauley Pavilion (good history, bad fans)
4. Carrier Dome (good for big games bad for other games)
5. Cameron Indoor (This may be a bit high since its just pretty much a high school gym)
6.Assembly Hall (Has lost it's luster)
7.B
...(more)
Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Mar 20, 2008

August 9, 2009 7:14 pm
This is supposed to be about the ARENA not the teams that play there. Duke, Kentucky, Kansas are always loaded with 12 McDonalds all americans and so it is cool to see games there. But in New Mexico we rarely get a McDonalds all american but the power of the pit raises the play of the kids other teams do not want. There is power in the PIT and to Gary's dismay Sports Illustrated did rank us in the ...(more)
Reputation:86
Level:All-Star
Since:Oct 10, 2008

August 6, 2009 11:49 am
The new arena opens in two years, and OH...MY...GOSH its just insane. Will be the nicest arena in the country, not just for college, but ANY arena in the country. Throw in the fact that there will now be 23,000 UofL fans in there and its not even close.

One thing about Cameron is the fact that on tv we only see the student sections, if you saw the rest of the arena you would see familie
...(more)
Reputation:44
Level:Rookie
Since:Dec 20, 2007

August 5, 2009 6:28 pm
I was at the 1990 game in Pitino's first season and they played off of the crowd that was deafeing and for a Rupp Arena first never sat down. It was a bunch of Kentucky boy's against Chris Jackson who at that time was the best Guard in the game and was draining 3's. They also had a man by the name of Shaq And anothe 7 footer named Stanley Roberts. Jackson dropped in 41 but Kentucky won 100-95. By ...(more)
Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Jun 5, 2009

August 6, 2009 7:38 pm
If The Pit was home to a mediocre Big East school it would've been top 5 on your list. You probably haven't watched a game there anyway. The Lobos have been a better than average MWC team the last five years at best and the place is still sold out for every conference game and packed for every other game. If you watched a big game there during the 80s and 90s when the Lobos were a perennial top 25 ...(more)
Reputation:71
Level:Pro
Since:Dec 29, 2008

August 6, 2009 3:11 pm
Well, it's simple. We are the best. Even when we suck, we are the best. and even when we are the best, we suck. Thats just how it goes.

And, we just love college basketball. Even to the point that I took my freshly born baby girl to games last year. Born in Oct, she went to 11 games. Including the SEC Tourney.  Just sucks that SHE needed a ticket. But we went anyway.
...(more)
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Oct 13, 2007

August 5, 2009 5:10 pm
Did i miss something or did Parrish just give props to Duke?  Surely this did not just happen.  Someone help me because my entire world perspetive has been altered and I'm not sure any repair is possible.
Reputation:65
Level:Pro
Since:Sep 7, 2008

August 6, 2009 12:47 am
One and two I can agree with even though I've never been to either place. They're smaller which makes everything more intimate and they both seem to have good atmoshere's. However, Pauley Pavilion at three? I have been there for a game and the word that comes to mind is apathy. There's no intensity, the atmosphere was mediocre at best. This was a pac-10 game v oregon. I'd go KU, Duke, then UK or I ...(more)
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 19, 2006

August 6, 2009 10:58 am
Stop being ignorant and try voting for the truth
We all know Rupp is not the best lol its basically another dean dome
We all know Kentucky fans have nothing better to do with their days than sit at a computer posting/voting anyway ...even if thats all u got in the form of winning these days
 
 
 
 
Gary Parrish
Recent Columns
 
Headlines
 
 
 
CBS Sports Store
Twins Kansas Jayhawks Franchise Hat Adult
Save 15% on NCAA Gear
Support your school today Shop now
 
 
 
 
 
Fantasy Basketball at CBSSports.com