Play Fantasy The Most Award Winning Fantasy game with real time scoring, top expert analysis, custom settings, and more. Play Now
  • My Scores
  • MLB
  • Golf
  • NFL
  • NCAA FB
  • Tennis

Fun with win totals: 5 over/unders we like

By Jerry Hinnen | College Football Writer
Can Braxton Miller get Ohio State to double-digit wins in Urban Meyer's first year? (Getty Images)

Earlier this summer we broke down the early over/under win totals in the SEC by division, liking Ole Miss's under and Alabama's over in the West, and Florida's over and Missouri's under in the East.

But with the first live college football action of the 2012 season now less than two weeks away, those lines aren't "early" anymore, and there's far more of them. 10 days ago we posted a set of win totals from offshore sportsbook Bovada, and earlier in August Beyond the Bets printed a set of offshore totals for every team in the country. So we thought it might be time to spread our horizons beyond the SEC, and look at a few other lines that might be worth, well, a look.

Keep in mind that these totals and prices are subject to change from week-to-week and, of course, from sportsbook to sportsbook. Lines are from Bovada when available and BtB when not.

(Also keep in mind that this is for fun, and that if you're looking for rock-solid expert gambling advice, you should get a second opinion--at the minimum. If you're a gambling novice, the "-XXX" number along each total is the "juice," i.e., how much you have to wager to earn $100. "-140" means you have to bet $140 to get $100 in return; "+140" means a $100 bet earns you $140. Oh, and all totals are for regular season wins only.)

Here we go, with teams in alphabetical order:

Navy, over 6.5 wins (-165).

This would be an expensive play, but maybe not once you get a good look at the Midshipmen schedule: home games vs. VMI, San Jose St., Indiana, FAU, and Texas St., plus entirely winnable road dates at Central Michigan, East Carolina, and Troy. There might be seven wins in those games alone, even before we get to the Commander-in-Chief's trophy games (one of which, Army, Navy hasn't lost in decade) or the trip to vulnerable Penn State.

The bottom line is that 2011 was the first season in the past nine where Navy didn't hit 7 wins, and it's difficult to see that trend continuing against a schedule this soft.

Ohio State, over 9 wins (-145).

Another juiced line, but one that seems to offer much less risk than reward with the Buckeyes needing to lose four games to lose the bet. With two of Ohio State's road games very, very likely wins at Indiana and Penn State, even an upset home loss somewhere and road defeats at Michigan State and Wisconsin wouldn't be enough to keep the Buckeyes from at least reaching a push.

The flip side is that they'd need 10 wins to win the bet, but we like their chances of getting there. Barring a major upset loss at the Horseshoe, a split between the home date vs. Nebraska and the trip to East Lansing -- entirely doable -- would send the Buckeyes into their Nov. 10 bye week at 9-1, needing only one more win (either at Camp Randall or, more likely, home to Michigan) to hit the over. With Urban Meyer and Braxton Miller handling the offense and the defense poised to rank alongside the Spartans as the best in the Big Ten, that's a win they should get.

But not all of the Eye on College Football team feels that way. Here's a second opinion from our Tom Fornelli, who feels very strongly against taking the Buckeyes at 9 wins:

"My problem with this Ohio State pick isn't that I don't think Ohio State can win 10 games. It can. My problem is that when the over/under is set at 9 wins, pretty much the only way you're going to win that bet is if the best-case scenario takes place.

Could that happen? Sure, but with a third head coach in three seasons, an offense that wasn't exactly explosive having to learn a new scheme, and a team that has nothing to play for this season. I'd say 9-3 is the most likely scenario here, and I don't see the point in risking money on a push."

He's wrong.

Stanford, over 7.5 wins (-105).

Finally, here's an over that's both highly appealing and cheap. Maybe they don't have Andrew Luck or all their behemoths from the 2011 offensive line, but the Cardinal are still stocked with Jim Harbaugh-recruited talent across the board, have one the country's best running backs in Stepfan Taylor, and one of the Pac-12's most experienced and talented defenses. It might not be the Cardinal of the last two years, but it won't be that far off, either.

And as for the schedule, it could be worse; home games vs. San Jose State, Duke, Arizona, Washington State and Oregon State should all be wins, and drawing Colorado and UCLA out of the Pac-12 South could be two more. Even a 6-1 mark in those seven games would leave the Cardinal needing just two wins from games vs. USC and at Notre Dame, Washington, Cal, and Oregon--opponents they finished 4-1 against in 2011.

Troy, over 5.5 wins (-110).

Was there a more shocking 2011 season in all of college football than Troy's cratering to a 3-9 mark and the lower reaches of the Sun Belt? We don't think so, but we also think this line may be an overreaction--this is still the same program that entered last year having won six games or more in seven of the previous eight seasons. They still have quarterback Corey Robinson, 14 other returning starters, and an experienced (and now highly motivated) coaching staff.

The Trojans' Sun Belt schedule makes things ever rosier, as projected heavyweights FIU, Western Kentucky, and Louisiana all come to Troy while the Trojans get road dates at expected also-rans South Alabama, FAU, and North Texas as well as rivals Middle Tennessee State--themselves coming off of a 1-7 Sun Belt season. Even with the Navy game and two dates against SEC opposition, there's too many chances for Troy wins not to expect them to get back to .500.

UNLV, under 4.5 (-180).

The highest-juiced line yet, but in UNLV we're talking about a team that's won a total of four games the past two seasons, lost to FCS Southern Utah 41-16 last year, and dropped its seven 2011 road games -- including one at New Mexico (!) -- by an average of 33 points. We can give the Runnin' Rebels and star running back Tim Cornett two wins out of home dates vs. Northern Arizona, New Mexico, and Wyoming, and maybe there's a third lurking out there either in a sweep of those games or a shock road upset. But five wins seems utterly out of the question.

And just for the heck of it, five more bets that also caught our eye:

Michigan, under 9 wins (-160): The reverse of the Ohio State bet, the Wolverines may be able to reach 9, but with their losses on the defensive line, grueling schedule, and fewer breaks in close games, 10 seems well out of reach.

South Florida, under 7.5 wins (+125): The Bulls have plenty of experience and were better than their 2011 record, but have a tough nonconference slate (at Nevada, vs. Florida State, at Miami) and lost talented defensive coordinator Mark Snyder. Is B.J. Daniels really up to quarterbacking this team to 8 wins?

Florida Atlantic, under 3.5 wins (-120): Big improvements aren't unheard of in the Sun Belt, but the Owls were truly dreadful last season -- 1-11 overall, 0-8 SBC, 3-9 against the spread -- and have three certain losses on the nonconference schedule. Carl Pelini getting his talent-starved team to 3-5 in conference would be quite the (unlikely) accomplishment.

UCF, over 8.5 wins (-115): Hitting this over would mean a four-win improvement for the Knights, but with arguably most talented team among C-USA contenders, no quarterback controversy, and a schedule with several winnable road games (Akron, Memphis, Marshall UTEP), it's an improvement we're expecting to happen.

Arizona, over 5.5 wins (-125): Mike Leach has gotten most of the attention among Pac-12 coaching newcomers, but we like Rich Rodriguez to post the better 2011 record when all is said and done. Matt Scott gives him the perfect fit at quarterback, Jeff Casteel is along to run the defense, and home games vs. Toledo, South Carolina State, Oregon State, Colorado and Arizona State could get the 'Cats within a win of this over on their own.

 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre

College Football Video

August 26, 2014
College football expert picks for Week 1 (4:33)
1 August 27, 2014
USC hero hoax?
(2:17)
2 August 26, 2014
Game Breakdown: 5 Ohio State at Navy
(3:25)
3 August 26, 2014
Game Breakdown: West Virginia vs. 2 Alabama
(1:48)

Latest

Most Popular

CBSSports.com Shop