Geno Smith and the Heisman: Where he stands after his record day against Baylor

By Chris Huston | College Football Writer
Geno Smith threw for 656 yards and eight touchdowns against Baylor (US Presswire)

Is it time to start engraving Geno Smith's name on the Heisman?

It sure seems like a safe bet after he went 45-of-51 for 656 yards and eight touchdowns (with no interceptions) in No. 9 West Virginia's crazy 70-63 win over No. 25 Baylor on Saturday.

The numbers for Smith after four games are jaw dropping.

He has completed 141 of 169 passes (.834) for 1,728 yards, 20 touchdowns and zero picks. His passer rating is an astronomical 208.37 and well above the NCAA mark set by Russell Wilson last season. His incompletion-to-touchdown ratio is reminiscent of what Robert Griffin III did last September, when the 2011 Heisman winner had 20 incompletions and 18 touchdowns through four games (Smith has 28 incompletions and 20 touchdowns).

Projecting his stats through the whole regular season, he's on pace for 5,184 passing yards and 60 touchdown passes. If he comes anywhere close to those numbers, the Heisman is his, simple as that.

This game -- the fourth-best passing yardage performance in major college history -- was important to Smith's Heisman hopes for a couple of reasons in particular:

1. Throwing for so many yards and touchdowns against Baylor gives him some statistical wiggle room as the season progresses. Smith essentially crammed two games worth of numbers into one. It's almost like he's playing 13 regular-season games now instead of the 12 on West Virginia's schedule. He could theoretically miss a game due to injury and not suffer much when his final stats are calculated.

2. The meme surrounding his candidacy is now centered squarely on his impressive stats. Because of the shakiness of the West Virginia defense, no one really expects the Mountaineers to go undefeated. As long as they win at least nine games and his stats remain undebatably superior to the other candidates, then he should win the Heisman.

Other pitfalls remain, however.

Texas, Kansas State and Oklahoma are all ranked and have enough defensive talent to slow the Mountaineer attack. Smith needs to be careful not to fall into the same trap that Penn State's Larry Johnson fell into in 2002. The Nittany Lions running back had more than 2,000 yards that season -- normally enough to be shoo-in for the Heisman -- but was shut down in each of his team's three losses and finished third in the voting. As long as Smith plays well, he'll be in good standing with the Heisman electorate even if his team drops a couple games.

Let's also not forget that Smith is in a unique position in the race vis-a-vis the Heisman regions. To wit, his school is physically located in the Mid-Atlantic region but he plays most of his games against schools in the Southwest region. This advantage could prove decisive in a close race.

There's obviously still a long way to go in this campaign, Florida State's EJ Manuel and Kansas State's Collin Klein are still factors, as are Oregon's De'Anthony Thomas and Georgia's Aaron Murray. Any of those players could go on a tear and emerge as Smith's prime challenger.

But as long as their production pales in comparison to what Smith is doing weekly, they are going to be chasing him from behind.

 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre

College Football Video

Latest

Most Popular