Play Fantasy Use your Fantasy skills to win Cash Prizes. Join or start a league today. Play Now
  • My Scores
  • MLB
  • Golf
  • NFL
  • Tennis

Weekly Confidence Pool: The Long Con

By Tom Fornelli | College Football Writer
Weekly confidence pool Urban Meyer
Two of us are more confident in Urban Meyer and Ohio State than the other. (USATSI)

For the last four years here at Eye On College Football I have run a weekly picks feature in which I competed against my girlfriend Lynn and my Playstation 3 in picking the week's biggest college football games. Well, with EA Sports no longer producing a college football game, Man vs. Woman vs. Machine is no longer viable.

Who would have thought my relationship would outlast a video game that sold millions of copies a year?

Which means that we needed a new format because what's the point of watching college football if you aren't in the midst of a competition in which you can lord your superiority over your friends and loved ones? So this year we're going a bit old school and starting a weekly confidence pool in which the Eye On College Football writers (Jerry Hinnen, Chip Patterson and the incredibly handsome and intelligent Tom Fornelli) will compete against one another for the right to talk a lot of smack.

If you're not familiar with the concept of a confidence pool, it's pretty simple. The three of us will pick any 10 games of our choosing each week and pick against the spread. The game we're most confident in we'll assign 10 points to, all the way down to one point for the game we have the least amount of confidence in. For each game we get correct we earn the amount of points we had assigned it.

At the end of the year the person with the most points will be crowned champion and showered with the scorn and jealousy of the two losers. I do not plan on being one of those losers.

So without further ado, let's get to our picks for the week.


Hinnen: Ohio State (-12.5) vs. Navy - No, the Buckeyes don't have Braxton Miller. They do still have Joey Bosa, Michael Bennett, Adolphus Washington, and Noah Spence -- quite possibly the best defensive line in the country, and one that should give even Navy's savvy, experienced offensive line some major fits, even if Noah Spence isn't playing. On the other side of the ball, J.T. Barrett doesn't have the on-field exposure, but he does have the usual Urban Meyer-required athleticism and Meyer's patented rushing schemes -- the ones that made the Buckeyes the nation's top rushing offense on a per-carry basis a year ago -- at his disposal. Against the Midshipmen's undersized (by Power 5 standards) front seven, that should be enough to cover a two-touchdown spread.

Bo Pelini you fired my brother prepare to die
You fired my brother, prepare to die. (USATSI)

Patterson: Nebraska (-21) vs. FAU - Bo Pelini claims that FAU's ugly split with Carl Pelini has no impact on Saturday's game, but I'll guess that biological loyalty will provide incentive to keep the gas pedal down on the Owls. FAU has been losing road games vs. P5 teams by 24-35 points, so I'll gladly take the Huskers -21 and follow @FauxPelini during the game for commentary.

Fornelli: LSU (-4.5) vs. Wisconsin - This spread is just too small. I know LSU is replacing a lot of skill players on offense, but some of the replacements (hello, Leonard Fournette) might actually be upgrades from last year. Plus the Tigers have four of five starters returning on the offensive line and it will be facing a Wisconsin defense without a single returning starter in the front seven. Oh, and Wisconsin will be starting Tanner McEvoy, who has thrown a total of zero passes in his college career. I only have to give up 4.5 points? Ok then.

Here are the rest of our picks.

Expert Picks: Confidence Pool



over Wisconsin
Ohio State
over Navy
over FAU
9Ohio State
over Navy
over Wisconsin
over Miami (Ohio)
over Hawaii
over UNLV
over SMU
7Penn State
over UCF
over Tulane
over Notre Dame
6Washington State
over Rutgers
over Miami (Fla.)
over Hawaii
over Miami (Ohio)
over W. Virginia
over California
over UNLV
Boston College
over UMass
over Wisconsin
over FAU
La. Tech
over Oklahoma
Ohio State
over Navy
over Okla. State
Penn State
over UCF
New Mexico
over UTEP
1South Carolina
over Texas A&M
over Kent State
Ole Miss
over Boise State
Total Points000

What stands out to me in our picks is that Chip has a lot of confidence in games Jerry and I won't even touch. He has 34 points on Nebraska, Florida, Marshall and Rice while Jerry and I have eight points on those four teams between us, and Jerry doesn't even touch any of them. Meanwhile Jerry and I assigned 10 points each to Ohio State and LSU respectively, while Chip only has a total of seven points on both.

So we can only assume that Chip knows something we don't, or that he's going to find himself in an early hole come next week.

Be sure to let us know how brilliant/stupid we are for our picks in the comments.

UPDATE: Chip's original eight-point game was Florida (-35.5) over Idaho. With that game being canceled due to weather, Jerry and I, being the kind, wonderful people that we are, allowed Chip to change his eight point game to Baylor (-32.5) over SMU.

CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre

College Football Video

September 21, 2014
Heisman Spotlight (9/21) (2:20)
1 September 21, 2014
Palm's playoff/bowl projections (9/21)
2 September 21, 2014
UL Lafayette at Boise State recap
3 September 20, 2014
Miami (OH) at Cincinnati recap


Most Popular Shop

Mens Baltimore Orioles Majestic Charcoal 2014 AL East Division Champions Locker Room T-Shirt

MLB Division Champs Gear
Get your team today
Shop Now