Below is a list of the CBSSports.com All-America Team, voted on by writers, producers and staff. Three freshman and three sophomores were named to the team, including player of the year Tim Tebow.
| 2007 CBSSports.com All-America Team | |||||
| Offense | |||||
| Pos | Player | Ht | Wt | Cl. | School |
| QB | Tim Tebow | 6-3 | 235 | Soph. | Florida |
| RB | Kevin Smith | 6-1 | 211 | Jr. | UCF |
| RB | Darren McFadden | 6-2 | 205 | Jr. | Arkansas |
| WR | Michael Crabtree | 6-2 | 222 | Fr. | Texas Tech |
| WR | Jordy Nelson | 6-3 | 217 | Sr. | Kansas State |
| TE | Martin Rucker | 6-6 | 255 | Sr. | Missouri |
| OL | Gosder Cherilus | 6-7 | 315 | Sr. | Boston College |
| OL | Anthony Collins | 6-6 | 310 | Jr. | Kansas |
| OL | Jake Long | 6-7 | 315 | Sr. | Michigan |
| OL | Steve Justice | 6-4 | 284 | Sr. | Wake Forest |
| OL | Jonathan Luigs | 6-4 | 305 | Jr. | Arkansas |
| Defense | |||||
| DL | Glenn Dorsey | 6-2 | 303 | Sr. | LSU |
| DL | George Selvie | 6-4 | 255 | Soph. | South Florida |
| DL | Chris Long | 6-4 | 279 | Sr. | Virginia |
| DL | Greg Middleton | 6-3 | 265 | Soph. | Indiana |
| LB | J Leman | 6-2 | 240 | Sr. | Illinois |
| LB | James Laurinaitis | 6-3 | 240 | Jr. | Ohio State |
| LB | Ali Highsmith | 6-1 | 223 | Jr. | LSU |
| CB | Craig Steltz | 6-2 | 209 | Sr. | LSU |
| CB | Aqib Talib | 6-2 | 205 | Jr. | Kansas |
| CB | Jamie Silva | 5-11 | 208 | Sr. | Boston College |
| CB | Antoine Cason | 6-0 | 185 | Sr. | Arizona |
| Special Teams | |||||
| K | Thomas Weber | 6-2 | 202 | Fr. | Arizona State |
| P | Louie Sakoda | 5-10 | 178 | Jr. | Utah |
| KR | Jeremy Maclin | 6-1 | 185 | Fr. | Missouri |
| PR | Kevin Robinson | 6-0 | 199 | Sr. | Utah State |
| Awards | |||||
| Offensive Player of the Year: Tim Tebow, Florida | |||||
| Defensive Player of the Year: James Laurinaitis, Ohio State | |||||
| Coach of the Year: Mark Mangino, Kansas | |||||
| Freshman of the Year: Michael Crabtree, Texas Tech | |||||
