powered by Google  
  Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 

Preseason Top 25: It's exclusive at the top - NCAA Football Sports News
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Home   Fantasy     NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  More CBS College | MaxPreps | Mobile | Shop  
College Football Home | Scoreboard | Standings | Schedules | Stats | Teams | Players | Rankings | Video | SEC Live | Recruiting
 

Preseason Top 25: It's exclusive at the top

Try. We dare you. Try to make a case.

The national championship race goes three deep. Maybe four. Try to make a case for anyone else beyond the small group of super powers peering down from college football's Burj Dubai.

The consensus top three heading into the season are Florida, Texas and Oklahoma. Alabama is No. 4 on this season's CBSSports.com Preseason Top 25. Depending on your preference, that No. 4 team could be USC, maybe Penn State or Ohio State.

The point is, if you go down any further you're in danger of becoming an office joke.

"Dude, Oklahoma State. Really?"

That or either you went Hangover one night in Vegas and plunked down $20 on Ole Miss as a national title long shot. (25-1 according to our friends at Las Vegas Sports Consultants)

Sorry to be a buzz kill, but anything beyond that top three/four and you're pushing the boundaries of credulity. And you thought the BCS was exclusive? You need a ballroom to accommodate the 66 schools in the Bowl Championship Series. Even Vanderbilt and Baylor cash checks each year.

This season there is an elite, um, gentlemen's club. Boil it down and the 2009 season is reduced to the SEC champion (probably Florida) against the Big 12 champion (probably Texas or Oklahoma).

Cut and paste Florida-Oklahoma from South Florida last January? Feel free. Regardless, may the best superpower win next January in Pasadena.

  Bowl projections | Top 25 Breakdown | SI: Power Rankings | SB Nation: National preview

Get used to it. The top leagues of 2008 are the best leagues of 2009 -- and beyond. The two conferences are getting the best players, pay the best money to the game's best coaches who then produce the nation's best teams. The dominance isn't going to end anytime soon.

When CBSSports.com's preseason All-America team was released last week, it wasn't surprising to see 14 of the 25 first-team members from the SEC and Big 12. Almost a quarter (six) of the team came from Oklahoma, Texas and Florida alone.

Sam Bradford wants a rematch against Florida in Pasadena. (Getty Images)  
Sam Bradford wants a rematch against Florida in Pasadena. (Getty Images)  
And that's without Heisman Trophy winner Sam Bradford being mentioned. At all. Texas' Colt McCoy was the second-team quarterback.

  When you weren't looking, the game's first $4 Million Man, Nick Saban, got another raise.

  So did Urban Meyer, but he had to win two championships in three years to do it. Poor guy.

  With bonuses, Bob Stoops could make $5 million in two years (2011).

  That's nothing. If everything falls right. Mack Brown could make $6 million this year.

It's not hard to figure out this season's national picture. The SEC has won three consecutive national championships and four of the last six. Throw in Oklahoma (2000) and Texas (2005) and the two leagues have combined for six of the nine BCS titles this decade.

Talk about making it rain. That's a lot of money concentrated among 24 schools.

  It's hard to pick against Florida, a team so young and loaded that the NFL is going to have to wait. Unless a raft of juniors declare for the draft (which could always happen), the dominance should continue. Only six of the 22 starters are seniors.

  There is nothing more dangerous than a Longhorn scorned. Texas has lost twice since the first week of October 2007. One of those losses came with one tick on the clock at Texas Tech and probably kept the 'Horns from playing for the national championship.

  If this is being "down" then every team wants to be in the same position as Oklahoma. Bob Stoops has to replace four offensive line starters and both starting receivers, but he has been in this position previously. Six Big 12 titles are proof.

The SEC is the league of champions.

The Big 12 is the league of quarterbacks.

Don't be surprised if New York becomes the leagues' melting pot again if Tebow, Bradford and McCoy reconvene at the Heisman ceremony.

It's a completely legal monopoly. From now until 2024, every SEC game will be seen somewhere as part of its $3 billion, 15-year contract with CBS and ESPN.

There's always a chance the exclusive club could be open to other members. But already there are signs that the pretenders will stay that way. USC is starting a true freshman at quarterback and have lost three defensive starters before the opener. Although it is on its way to becoming a power again, Alabama hasn't won an SEC title since 1999.

Below the top three, the schedule is configured for attrition. There are three games involving six teams in the top 13 before Week 3 -- USC at Ohio State, Virginia Tech vs. Alabama and Georgia at Oklahoma State. Are the losers out?

History has shown that the Texas-Oklahoma loser could play for the national championship. Florida is so solidly entrenched it could afford to lose the toughest game on its schedule (Oct. 10 at LSU) and still win it all.

Try to make a case for anyone else. We dare you.

CBSSports.com Preseason Top 25

1. Florida: Well, duh. Freshman sensation Andre Debose might need surgery to repair a partially torn hamstring tendon. Someone (or some persons) should be able to replace Percy Harvin. Best-case scenario: The first undefeated season in program history. Worst-case scenario: Tim Tebow injures his throwing hand in a bar fight.

2. Texas: Vondrell McGee was named starting tailback this week. Anything to relieve pressure on McCoy is a good thing. Best-case scenario: Brown decides to start running it up with impunity to impress the BCS computers. Worst-case scenario: Oklahoma runs it up in the Red River Rivalry.

3. Oklahoma: Stoops is laying off criticizing the offensive line because he knows it's going to be great. Best-case scenario: Bradford wins a second Heisman. Worst-case scenario: Bradford gets his jersey dirty. (He was sacked only 13 times last season.)

Terrelle Pryor looks to join the ranks of elite quarterbacks this season. (Getty Images)  
Terrelle Pryor looks to join the ranks of elite quarterbacks this season. (Getty Images)  
4. Alabama: Just give the Tide a cause, they'll play for it. Defensive end Brandon Deaderick was released from the hospital after being shot this week. Next order of business: Will he play vs. Virginia Tech? Best-case scenario: Another crack at Florida in the SEC title game. Worst-case scenario: Saban goes to the Dolphins.

5. Ohio State: Buckeyes fans are being urged to welcome Navy to The Shoe. They'd be more excited about a Heisman season from Terrelle Pryor. Best-case scenario: Boom Herron makes them forget Beanie Wells. Worst-case scenario: Daryll Clark makes them remember who went to the Rose Bowl last year.

6. USC: Prospects for another Pac-10 title are looking dimmer. Cornerback Shareece Wright (academically ineligible) became the third defensive starter to be knocked out. Best-case scenario: An eighth consecutive BCS bowl. Worst-case scenario: Pete Carroll has to yo-yo quarterbacks.

7. Oklahoma State: The new Triplets -- Kendall Hunter, Dez Bryant and Zac Robinson -- could be the foundation of the Big 12's best offense. Defense is the question. Best-case scenario: The offense averages 40 a game. Worst-case scenario: So does the defense.

8. Penn State: The non-conference schedule is laughable -– Akron, Syracuse, Temple. Best-case scenario: Joe Paterno retires the all-time victories record. Worst-case scenario: Joe Paterno retires.

9. LSU: One magazine picked tailback Charles Scott as the SEC offensive player of the year. You hear that Tebow!? Best-case scenario: Russell Shepard is the new Harvin. Worst-case scenario: Jordan Jefferson is the old Jarrett Lee.

10. Virginia Tech: Watch freshman tailback Ryan Williams. He gets his chance to replace injured Darren Evans. Best-case scenario: The tailback thing works itself out. Worst-case scenario: The quarterback situation (Tyrod Taylor) doesn't.

11. Oregon: The nation's No. 2 rushing offense prepares to run all over the Pac-10. Best-case scenario: Halloween destruction of USC. Worst-case scenario: A repeat of 2008's quarterback injuries.

12. Mississippi: Jevan Snead committed to Florida, signed with Texas, now might find a championship at Ole Miss. Best-case scenario: Winning the SEC West. Worst-case scenario: Losing to Mississippi State.

13. Boise State: Lose to Oregon and we can forget about the Broncos. Every non-BCS program that has played in a BCS bowl has had an undefeated regular season. Best-case scenario: 12-0. Worst-case scenario: 11-1.

14. California: Jahvid Best is a Heisman candidate but defensive back Syd'Quan Thompson is part of an active secondary. Best-case scenario: Kevin Riley doesn't throw up on his shoes in pressure situations. Worst-case scenario: Need a couple of towels over here.

Jonathan Dwyer is in the running for best back in the nation. (Getty Images)  
Jonathan Dwyer is in the running for best back in the nation. (Getty Images)  
15. Georgia Tech: Jonathan Dwyer might be the best tailback in the country. Best-case scenario: Paul Johnson wins the ACC in his second season.Worst-case scenario: Any Georgia Tech quarterback being forced to throw 40 times in a game.

16. Georgia: Don't get too cocky, Cowboys. Mark Richt is 28-1 in non-conference road games. Best-case scenario: Multiple tailbacks are better than one. (Richard Samuel is the leader in the clubhouse going into Oklahoma State.) Worst-case scenario: Jacksonville in October ring a bell?

17. BYU: Good news for Max Hall. Since 1974, every BYU senior quarterback who has played the entire season has won a conference title. Best-case scenario: The Cougars get to the Fiesta Bowl. Worst-case scenario: The Cougars get to the Las Vegas Bowl.

18. TCU: The Frogs are trying to keep MWC title out of Utah. Since 2003, TCU is the only school not located in Utah to win the conference title. Best-case scenario: The nation's best defense remains that way. Worst-case scenario: Defensive end Jerry Hughes turns an ankle.

19. Utah: Goodbye Brian Johnson. Juco Terrance Cain is expected to start at quarterback in the opener against Utah State. Best-case scenario: The Utes don't rebuild, they reload. Worst-case scenario: They have to rebuild.

20. Kansas: Todd Reesing is ready to show that's he really 5-foot-9 but plays 5-11. Best-case scenario: A Big 12 North Division title. Worst-case scenario: A loss to Nebraska.

21. Nebraska: No, the Huskers aren't joining the Sun Belt, it just seems that way. There are non-cons against Florida Atlantic, Arkansas State and Louisiana-Lafayette. Best-case scenario: The Blackshirts return. Worst-case scenario: Ndamukong Suh is a one-man show.

22. North Carolina: "It's time for some fresh meat," said linebacker Quan Sturdivant. The Citadel is the first course on Saturday. Best-case scenario: Karma from the basketball team. Worst-case scenario: Losses at Georgia Tech and Virginia Tech.

23. Florida State: A Freedom of Information Act request resulted in the discovery that FSU could win the ACC. Are the 'Noles of old back? Best-case scenario: FSU wins 14 (12 regular-season, ACC title and bowl game). Worst-case scenario: Bobby Bowden loses 14 (victories from the NCAA).

24. Michigan State: Kirk Cousins got the quarterback job over former Sooner Keith Nichol. Best-case scenario: Greg Jones becomes the Big Ten's best defender. Worst-case scenario: The Spartans can't make up for the loss of quarterback Brian Hoyer and Javon Ringer.

25. Houston: Case Keenum is attempting to become the first quarterback to throw for 6,000 yards in a season. Best-case scenario: Coming off their first bowl win in 28 years, the Cougars win their second Conference USA title in four years. Worst-case scenario: The defense (31 points per game in '08) is even more vulnerable with the loss of conference defensive player of the year, Phillip Hunt.

 
 

Talk Back
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 29, 2006

September 2, 2009 1:26 pm
Ok, so right now, I'd be willing to bet my entire life's savings that T. Pryor doesn't even sniff the Heisman this year.  Not sure why he's even being mentioned.  I'll agree that he's a great athelete and that given more time, he could become a great quarterback.  The key word there is could.  The fact is, he's nowhere close to T ...(more)
Reputation:83
Level:All-Star
Since:Nov 13, 2008

September 3, 2009 1:51 am
The big ten is always the most overrated conference.  I have no idea how Ohio state and penn state are ranked so high.  The only reseasion could be that they play in a pathetic excuse for a conference.  I can't wait to see USC crush Ohioo St. AGAIN     This time with a freshman quaterback.       Enjoy it while it lasts big ten ...(more)
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Dec 19, 2006

September 4, 2009 3:23 pm
Penn State.  Here's why:

1. A joke schedule.  This works to thier benefit.  The goal is to be undefeated - that's it.  A team in a tough conference should only schedule joke teams out-of-conference, since thier conference schedule is usually pretty tough.  In PSU's case, we play absolutly nobody except Ohio State, and that's at home.  Ask Oregon about the w
...(more)
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Dec 19, 2006

September 2, 2009 4:21 pm
At the risk of beating a horse, Notre Dame should not be a top 25 team.  At least not yet.  With their schedule (weak) and track record over the past few years, I say let them work their way into the top 25, don't anoint them.  

Imagine my relief and (pleasant) surprise when I saw Notre Dame omitted from this preseason top 25 list.  Finally, a spor
...(more)
Reputation:83
Level:All-Star
Since:Nov 18, 2008

September 3, 2009 3:46 pm
The BCS computer won't be sure which 1 loss team to put into the championship game resulting in discust from all the college football fans.  Anaylists will love it because they can talk about it for 1 month and give us their system of a playoff.  The team that gets their 1 loss early on has the inside track, probably from a conference without a conference championship game (I'm looking @ ...(more)
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Nov 29, 2006

September 3, 2009 6:36 am
Dodd says it's not hard to picke the elite teams this year. Well, hallelujah go to the head of the class genius. It's not hard to pick the elite teams for the 2010 season, or the 2011 season, or beyond that. It's going to be the same teams. There's a simple reason. They ARE the best programs. Boo hoo hoo. This is so unfair. It all a biased conspiracy. What about all of us alumni of Idaho Polythech ...(more)
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Nov 17, 2006

September 2, 2009 5:28 pm
Coach Ferentz's bunch lost Shonn Greene, but they're still returning a really good group of players, and should be very competitve on defense.  Perhaps it's because their Big 10 schedule is brutal?  Road games at PSU, MSU, and OSU?   Ouch...

I'm also surprised that Michigan State is listed ahead of Iowa, given that MSU lost more key players than the the Hawkeyes di
...(more)
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 24, 2006

September 2, 2009 5:47 pm

One of those teams will play for the title, yes. But there are other teams that can get in the title if things come together, it is just way too closeminded to believe otherwise. Penn St., Ohio St., USC, Oklahoma St., and my homer pick Oregon all have shots to get up there if things come together. The SEC and Big 12 are entirely too tough of conferences to believe that it is impossible that 2 o ...(more)

Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Nov 17, 2007

September 6, 2009 9:16 am
Top 3? Florida, Texas and Oklahoma?

Oklahoma (3) upset by Brigham Young (29).

Yes, Florida can sweep the table, but that does not mean it will happen. Same for Texas, Alabama, USC, OSU, Penn St., and any other team one cares to list.

Any given team on any given day can beat any other team on any given field.
...(more)
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 28, 2008

September 2, 2009 2:12 pm
 The season has not even kicked off yet and here are the commentators booking the championship game.  Dodd is not the only one to be doing this, it seems like the thing to to right now so these writers can justify their own existance.  The problem is that as a result of this fans, commentators, readers, and most importantly voters will have a prejudiced bias about who they want to s ...(more)
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Sep 11, 2006

September 3, 2009 2:37 pm
Not that it really matters whatsoever, but with nothing else to do at work I have to post this question:

How the hell does Florida have a higher strength of schedule than UGA?  The two teams have 7 games in common (including a head to head matchup).  The 5 unique games are as follow:


Georgia ...(more)
Reputation:54
Level:Pro
Since:Jun 17, 2009

September 2, 2009 2:05 pm
Do you really think Kansas should be ranked higher than Texas Tech?  Even UTEP could ruin it for them early.
Reputation:81
Level:All-Star
Since:Sep 11, 2008

September 3, 2009 3:06 am
blah blah blah,
If no other team out there can be competitive, why don't we just get Florida, Texas, and Oklahoma, all together and play a round robin to see who get the National Championship. Why even have a season, if it's been predetermined who is eligible for the championship. More of a reason to have a playoff system. Hey I'm a Badger fan and I already know that if we go undefeated we w
...(more)
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 12, 2006

September 2, 2009 9:45 pm
Just LOVING it.  Heard it for years and years.  It is the "mark of death."  Just ask Georgia players from last year.

Quick, name the last team who won the national title after being picked unanimous pre-season number 1.

(You cannot, can you!)

Florida at LSU and Florida vs Georgia this year will be bloodbaths.  Not sure a
...(more)
Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Dec 6, 2006

September 3, 2009 11:22 am
I have been against pre-season polls for years. The main reason is it makes it almost impossible for teams to rise fro out of the Top 25 to pla for the NC, with say 1 loss.

BUT...my bold prediction to get away from Florida vs Oklahoma/Texas is I think Oregon plays Penn State for the National Championship. I think USC loses to Ohio St and Oregon. I think Ohio St loses to PSU. Florida wil
...(more)
 
 
 
 
Dennis Dodd
Recent Columns
 
Headlines
 
 
 
CBS Sports Store
Columbia Alabama Crimson Tide All Conference Crew
Save 15% on NCAA Gear
Support your School Today Shop today
 
 
 
 
 
College Fantasy Football