powered by Google  
  Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 

Keenum deserves Heisman but in reality, he doesn't stand a chance - NCAA Football Sports News
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Home   Fantasy     NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  More CBS College | MaxPreps | Mobile | Shop  
College Football Home | Scoreboard | Standings | Schedules | Stats | Teams | Players | Rankings | Video | SEC Live | Recruiting
 

Keenum deserves Heisman but in reality, he doesn't stand a chance

I'm trying to figure out a way for Houston's Case Keenum to win the Heisman. First, I'm trying to figure out a way for people to care enough for Case Keenum to win the Heisman.

He plays in a league where defense is considered touch football. He plays in a league that is 4-21 this season against BCS schools. He plays in a league that had a great chance to promote the best player in Conference USA's short history. Too bad there was no scheduled coaches' conference call with reporters on Monday. The league office isn't to blame so much for what this BCS world has made Conference USA -- off Broadway football.

The previous week, the last seven coaches on the conference call didn't get asked a single question by the media.

That's just a symptom of college football's arrogance. If your league doesn't end in a number (specifically 10 or 12) or with the word "conference" (preceded by "Southeastern" or "Atlantic Coast") it ain't spit. The last 15 Heisman winners have come from four leagues -- Big 12, SEC, Big Ten and Pac-10. Surprised? Don't be. Since 1990, only two players from current non-BCS schools have finished in the top three in voting.

That has to change -- now. My guy had one scholarship offer which is about 100 less than Tim Tebow or Colt McCoy. Now he's outplaying both. At his current pace, Keenum will finish 1,300 yards ahead of the nation's next most prolific passer and already has the top three passing games this season.

Should the nation's best offensive weapon win the Heisman? Yes. Can Keenum win it? No way in hell and that sucks.

In case you don't know him, and you probably don't, Keenum is the 6-2 aw-shucks automaton who has been the most lethal, consistent, productive quarterback in the country. He is the leading passer in the country by more than 900 yards, the only player averaging more than 400 yards passing per game. No quarterback has thrown more touchdown passes (28).

Unfortunately, as Keenum's star rises, it promises to be nothing more than a talking point for Prejudice Week. Look around: Boise State can't get a break, media magpies will tell you why TCU shouldn't be allowed to play for the national championship and it's worse for Keenum, who is just plain ignored.

Their shared trait is that they play below college football's Mendoza Line for non-BCS schools.

But I'm at the point where I'm ready to cash in frequent-flyer miles just to get the kid to New York -- he's that good and also that anonymous. Some of you only know Houston plays football because I just wrote that sentence. Like a lot of schools, it was marginalized when the Southwest Conference broke up in 1996.

Baylor made the cut for the Big 12, Houston didn't. It's taken another old Southwest Conference rival -- TCU -- this long to get to the brink of a BCS bowl. Since 1995 when the league broke up, Houston has had one more winning season (six) than coaches (five). In that span, it has had one outright C-USA title (2006).

But, gosh, is Keenum good. YouTube him, he's on there more often than Brandon Spikes' claws of death. He is Tebow without The Promise, McCoy without the hype machine. In the last two games, Keenum has thrown for 1,081 yards and eight touchdowns -- more TD passes than 14 teams have thrown this season.

I can hear you now: 'Yeah, but it's Conference USA, an arcade league.' This happens to be an apples to apples argument. Quarterback is the one position where you can make a somewhat equal comparison. Bad defenses? What exactly was McCoy running and throwing against last year when he was the Heisman runner-up? Those were Big 12 defenses, bad Big 12 defenses.

'Our team believes in him,' Houston coach Kevin Sumlin said of Case Keenum. (US Presswire)  
'Our team believes in him,' Houston coach Kevin Sumlin said of Case Keenum. (US Presswire)  
What's so wrong with an old-fashioned gunslinger? For the second week in a row, Keenum led the Cougars to a last-second win. The week before, he stepped back and calmly tossed the 28-yard game-winning touchdown pass to teammate Patrick Edwards with 21 seconds left against Southern Miss.

On Saturday, Houston trailed Tulsa by two with 21 seconds left. Houston recovered an onside kick and two passes later, Matt Hogan was in position to kick a career-high 51-yard field goal.

"Our team believes in him," Houston coach Kevin Sumlin said of Keenum. "Offensively, defensively, everybody does, that no matter what the score is, we're never out of the game."

Call him Comeback Keenum. He has beaten more Big 12 teams (two) than at least half the quarterbacks in that league. He has beaten more teams from BCS leagues (three) than at least 76 teams in Division I-A. He is second only to McCoy in consecutive games throwing a touchdown pass, 26-25.

In the old days we, the media, would be sent vials of Keenum saliva, toenail clippings, moldy old socks just to keep him uppermost in our minds. It was a much different (promotion) game back then. There was swag and apparel to be had with said Heisman Candidate's mug/accomplishment plastered all over then.

Then Washington State had the subversive idea of putting a leaf in hundreds of envelopes to remind the media of Ryan Leaf and less was suddenly more. That evolved into mouse pads, CDs, e-mail and Power Point presentations. Someone eventually figured out that the big-time candidates don't need squat for promotion because every game is on TV.

Mostly, Heisman voters are lazy. They don't have or need the Jim Thorpe Award race broken down for them each day. Heisman? Hook up a mass media IV and sit back in the Barcalounger. Voting for the Heisman requires almost no research -- the rules are vague.

I picked up a couple of sports sections on Sunday that had listed the obligatory "Heisman Watch." Did they even watch games? The numbers of Tebow and McCoy are down. It seemed that even Nick Saban didn't believe in Mark Ingram on Saturday, until the second half against LSU.

Poll
Does Case Keenum stand a real shot at the Heisman?

My guy Keenum wasn't listed.

Twenty years ago in a different era, Houston's Andre Ware won the Heisman piling up similar arcade numbers. The difference was that Houston mattered because it was in a major conference.

If you dig deep enough, you can find out about my guy. Keenum has his own conference call (each Tuesday) as well as Twitter and Facebook pages. It would be a heck of a thing if a barely-recruited Texas kid from Abilene could at least get the big city, bright lights trip to New York.

I've done my part. Besides, Houston probably doesn't have the budget to outfit me in a leather Case Keenum bomber jacket that I would be glad to represent in.

Comeback Keenum isn't the only one who can dream.

For the rest of the national notes read Dennis Dodd's blog Dodds and Ends.

 
 

Talk Back
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Dec 18, 2006

November 11, 2009 2:34 pm
He is the reason the Houston is doing so well.  I have been watching him and the team and am very impressed.  I also agree that other positions other than QB and RB ought to be considered.  That guy Suh is a beast and has been a one man defense.  I liked Colt for the H last year over Bradford but we saw how that went.  Texas should have been in the Championship.  And ...(more)
Reputation:88
Level:All-Star
Since:Oct 7, 2008

November 11, 2009 6:41 pm
You can make a case for Case Keenum as a candidate for Heisman, and I would agree with that, however, your case falls short by your use of misleading statistics.  If you want to compare Keenum to McCoy, then do so fairly.  You said that Keenum has beaten more Big 12 teams than half the Big 12 QB's, that half does not include McCoy-of course, because he has beaten all the Big 12 team ...(more)
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 17, 2006

November 11, 2009 1:00 pm
Keenum didnt allow Houston to win the Tulsa game.  He held onto the ball way to long on the 2point conversion try and then on the last throw to put them into FG range, he threw to a WR that had a 20 yard cushion on him...I could have made that throw.  Watch the defense that Tulsa played that game, he may have had to complete 5 passes where he didnt have a huge cushion from the DBs.
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Nov 20, 2008

November 11, 2009 11:22 am
What about the Hawaii QB's Brennan and most notably Chang.  They broke every record in the book, and weren't close to touching the Heisman.  I believe they gave Brennan a shot agaisnt Georgia in the Sugar bowl, and we saw how that ended.

Like another postd stated, howabout all of the T-Tech QB's.  They have been putting up huge numbers for years.  Do big stts mean
...(more)
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Feb 16, 2008

November 12, 2009 2:34 am
 "He is Tebow without The Promise, McCoy without the hype machine. "

Really Dodd???  I think what you meant to say was "He is Tebow without the Championships, McCoy without the expectation ...(more)
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Jan 15, 2009

November 11, 2009 7:43 pm
I haven't seen Keenum play, so I can't judge whether he should be a Heisman candidate. I don't think you can decide what players are better if you don't watch them all and watch them often. You can't just look at stats and know how they were accumulated, under what circumstances, against what competition, etc.

Having said that, I do want to caution those who look at Keenum's stats to co
...(more)
Reputation:86
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 20, 2006

November 12, 2009 10:31 am
Toby Gerhart should be the Heisman frontrunner.  He would be if he played for a big-name program.  20 QBs in the country could put up Keenum's stats if they ran that offense.  Nobody else in the country can drag multiple defenders for touchdowns like Gerhart's been doing. And he doens't a band of 5* guys blocking for him and 5* receivers taking the heat off of him.

Dodd
...(more)
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Oct 18, 2006

November 13, 2009 10:14 am
"He plays in a league where defense is considered touch football.
He plays in a league that is 4-21 this season against BCS schools."

Enough said.  I don't know who should get it this year, but it is not him.
For the record, as a gator fan, it is NOT Tebow either.  I wish the powers that be would stop talking about Tebow whent hey discuss heismann.  h
...(more)
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 30, 2006

November 11, 2009 8:46 pm
Hello, it's Mark Ingram at Alabama. While the trophy will probably go to a qb padding his stats running the spread formation against 6-8 inferior opponents, this man brings it every game and play. Total package, runs fast, runs strong, blocks as good as he runs, catches the ball, runs the wildcat on occasion and hjas thrown the ball. Barring injury, he should be the best NFL player. I pull for Tex ...(more)
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Feb 2, 2007

November 11, 2009 7:38 pm
The BCS has diminished college football to the point where all that matters is who plays in the Championship Game.  Week to week, everything revolves around the BCS Standings.    The rest of the BCS Bowls have become filler before the big game.  The other bowl games are background noise.  Hell, it is becoming that even winning a conference championship is becoming meaningl ...(more)
Reputation:76
Level:Pro
Since:Sep 28, 2006

November 12, 2009 4:01 pm
Dodds is over simplifying this thing.  Yes, Texas has a defense to help carry them, and UH does not.  However, Texas also has more of a running game.  McCoy plays in a more balanced offense.  Also, because Texas has a defense most games are over by the 3rd period.  McCoy does not have to throw for 300 yeards in the second half to help his team kick a la ...(more)
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Feb 26, 2007

November 11, 2009 9:04 pm
When was the last time it went to a lineman , linebacker, or DB (who doesn't play offense or return kicks)?
Danny Wuerffel over Orlando Pace? Seriously?

Oh, and Colt was offered by 3 schools: Kansas St., TX A&M, and Texas. Not quite 100. Nobody even thought he'd start at Texas, as he was competeing against Jevan Snead who was far more highly regarded.

Tebow was
...(more)
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 1, 2009

November 11, 2009 7:15 pm
The Heisman trophy isn't and hasn't for sometime been the award that goes to the best player in college football. It is the award that goes to the player that espn praises the most. Since when did the best player in college foootball become limited to qbs and rbs? Keenum is the best qb in the country this year hands down and should be a frontrunner for the heisman but if history shows anything it ...(more)
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 1, 2007

November 10, 2009 10:40 pm
... how would you manage to work the name Tim Tebow into it?  Can you write an article without mentioning Tim Tebow?  When you come home from work and your wife asks you how your day went do you say:  "It was a very Tim Tebow day"?  Try to go an entire day without mentioning the name.  If you start to Detox just call 9-11 and tell them your a smack head, I'm sure ...(more)
Reputation:83
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 28, 2008

November 11, 2009 9:11 pm
The Heisman is supposed to go to the best player in the country.  Not the best team, not the best conference, but to the best PLAYER!  The best football player in the country is C.J. Spiller from Clemson.  I've seen Keenum play, and he's very good.  I hesitate to put him up there with McCoy or Tebow simply b ...(more)
 
 
 
 
Dennis Dodd
Recent Columns
 
Headlines
 
 
 
CBS Sports Store
Columbia Alabama Crimson Tide All Conference Crew
Save 15% on NCAA Gear
Support your School Today Shop today
 
 
 
 
 
College Fantasy Football