Below is CBS SportsLine.com's college football All-America team voted on by staff and writers. Ohio State and Michigan tied for the most players with three. The Buckeyes placed Troy Smith, Quinn Pitcock and James Laurinaitis on the team, while the Wolverines are reprsented by Jake Long, LaMarr Woodley and Leon Hall.
| CBS SportsLine.com All-America Team | |||
| Offense | |||
| Pos | Player | Class | School |
| QB | Troy Smith | Senior | Ohio State |
| RB | Ian Johnson | Sophomore | Boise State |
| RB | Darren McFadden | Sophomore | Arkansas |
| WR | Calvin Johnson | Junior | Georgia Tech |
| WR | Steve Smith | Senior | Southern California |
| TE | Jonny Harline | Senior | BYU |
| OL | Jake Long | Senior | Michigan |
| OL | Joe Thomas | Senior | Wisconsin |
| OL | Justin Blalock | Senior | Texas |
| OL | Sam Baker | Junior | Southern California |
| C | Dan Mozes | Senior | West Virginia |
| Defense | |||
| DL | Gaines Adams | Senior | Clemson |
| DL | Glenn Dorsey | Junior | LSU |
| DL | Quinn Pitcock | Senior | Ohio State |
| DL | LaMarr Woodley | Senior | Michigan |
| LB | Rufus Alexander | Senior | Oklahoma |
| LB | James Laurinaitis | Sophomore | Ohio State |
| LB | Patrick Willis | Senior | Mississippi |
| DB | Leon Hall | Senior | Michigan |
| DB | Reggie Nelson | Junior | Florida |
| DB | Daymeion Hughes | Senior | California |
| DB | Eric Weddle | Senior | Utah |
| Special Teams | |||
| K | Justin Medlock | Senior | UCLA |
| P | Daniel Sepulveda | Senior | Baylor |
| Ret. | DeSean Jackson | Sophomore | California |
| Awards | |||
| Offensive Player of the Year: Troy Smith, Ohio State | |||
| Defensive Player of the Year: James Laurinaitis, Ohio State | |||
| Freshman of the Year: P.J. Hill, Wisconsin | |||
| Coach of the Year: Jim Grobe, Wake Forest | |||
