College Football Insider

Fun with Numbers: Sizing up Ohio State vs. Auburn/Mizzou

WR Dorial Green-Beckham is a dangerous third weapon for Missouri on offense. (USATSI)
WR Dorial Green-Beckham is a dangerous third weapon for Missouri on offense. (USATSI)

Save strength of schedule debates and basic eye-test observations, it's difficult to assess whether Ohio State is truly better than a one-loss SEC champion without those two teams actually playing.

The BCS likes it this way (insert image of folks inside a BCS mothership tapping their fingers together with an evil smirk).

I tend to think Ohio State vs. Auburn or Mizzou would be a fascinating game.

These 'Fun with Numbers' below try to paint that picture for you. How do these teams stack up -- in schedule strength, yes, but also a few statistical areas beyond the obvious that might speak to the eye test?

Obviously this is an inexact science, but there are some areas that will help make an informed decision on which team is more deserving of the No. 2 spot.

Tale, say hello to tape.

Schedule

This one is easy. It's pretty clear Auburn and Mizzou played a tougher slate than Ohio State.

On the Buckeyes' schedule you'll find ...

3: Top 25 teams on Ohio State's schedule (No. 10 Michigan State, No. 16 Northwestern, No. 23 Wisconsin). ... Two of those teams finished the year unranked. Northwestern fell well out of the Top 25 with a 1-7 Big Ten record.

Now compare that to ...

6: Top 25 teams on Auburn's schedule. (No. 1 Alabama, No. 5 Missouri, No. 6 LSU, No. 7 Texas A&M, No. 24 Ole Miss, No. 25 Georgia). ... Five of those teams finished the year ranked (7-5 Ole Miss fell out).

6: Top 25 teams on Missouri's schedule (No. 3 Auburn, No. 7 Georgia, No. 20 South Carolina, No. 21 Texas A&M, No. 22 Florida, No. 24 Ole Miss). ... Four of those teams finished the regular season ranked. Florida and Ole Miss fell out.

Ohio State's games against one-win Purdue, one-win Cal, three-win FAMU and four-win Illinois lessened the opposing win total for the year. Auburn/Mizzou didn't have that problem.

6.85: Average number of wins by Auburn opponents this season, including Mizzou.

6.77: Average number of wins by Mizzou opponents this season, including Auburn.

5.84: Average number of wins by Ohio State opponents this season, including Michigan State.

But the Buckeyes can make up ground in other areas.

Quarterbacks in big games

Good quarterbacks can single-handedly win college football games. Let's see how the quarterbacks from these three teams played against opponents with eight wins or more.

287 and 2.7: Average number of total yards and touchdowns per game for Ohio State's Braxton Miller against Buffalo, Wisconsin (four touchdowns) and Iowa (324 yards).

280 and 2.5: Average number of total yards and touchdowns per game for Auburn's Nick Marshall against LSU, Texas A&M (336 and 4), Georgia (318) and Alabama.

274.5 and 2.25: Average number of total yards and touchdowns per game for Mizzou's James Franklin (Vandy, Georgia, Texas A&M) and Maty Mauk (South Carolina). Franklin had 341 and 4 against Vandy. Mauk went for 262 and 1 against South Carolina.

Playmaking depth

You can tell a lot by a team's third-best playmaker (quarterbacks excluded). If you look at a team's No. 3 guy and he's a potentially dominant player, that team is dangerous. Mizzou seems to have the edge.

10: Number of touchdowns for wide receiver Dorial Green-Beckham, arguably Mizzou's third-best playmaker. Green-Beckham might be Mizzou's top talent but tailback Henry Josey and receiver L'Damian Washington have put up slightly better numbers. Still, the 6-foot-6 Green-Beckham might be the most skilled third man out of these contending teams. Missouri has the most playmaking depth, with six receivers/tailbacks over 560 yards rushing or receiving.

585: Number of rushing yards for tailback Corey Grant, Auburn's third-best playmaker behind Tre Mason and Sammie Coates. Auburn is mostly a two-man show with Mason and Nick Marshall, so receivers and backup tailbacks might not be showcased as much as third options on other teams. Grant also has five touchdowns on the year.

644: Number of receiving yards for receiver Devin Brown, arguably Ohio State's No. 3 behind Carlos Hyde and Philly Brown. Ohio State is loaded with scorers. Including quarterback Braxton Miller, six players have at least eight rushing or receiving touchdowns.

Big boys

This is a little random but noteworthy. All three teams can line up with physical defensive lines and throw some girth around.

310.2: Average weight on Ohio State starting offensive line.

309: Average weight on Mizzou starting offensive line.

303.3: Average weight on Auburn starting offensive line.

Yards per play

7.33: Ohio State's yards per play on offense, fourth in the country.

6.94: Auburn's yards per play, 10th in country

6.68: Mizzou's yards per play, 15th in the country.

Third-down percentage

52.0: Ohio State's conversion percentage, ninth in the nation.

46.95: Mizzou's conversion percentage, 24th in the nation.

45.16: Auburn's conversion percentage, 33rd in the nation

Third downs against

34.46: Ohio State's conversion percentage, 26th in the nation.

35.23: Auburn's conversion percentage, 28th in the nation.

36.51: Mizzou's conversion percentage, 41st in the nation.

Red-zone offense

83.9: Ohio State's touchdown conversion percentage (47 of 56), fifth in the country.

71.4: Mizzou's touchdown conversion percentage (40 of 56), 16th in the country.

70.0: Auburn's touchdown conversion percentage (35 of 50), 28th in the country

Conclusion

Ohio State has the statistical edge in most areas -- against worse competition. Therein lies the problem. But let''s not act like Ohio State is an inferior team to the SEC's one-loss teams.


Jeremy Fowler is a national college football insider with CBSSports.com. Fowler joined CBS in 2012 after covering the Minnesota Vikings for the St. Paul Pioneer Press for two seasons and covering the Florida Gators for the Orlando Sentinel for two years. Fowler is also a contributor to the CBS Sports Network.
 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre

College Football Video

April 13, 2014
Jameis Winston's busy spring (2:08)
1 April 3, 2014
College Football's Top 10 offensive coaches
(4:14)
2 April 1, 2014
Sarkisian era begins at USC
(4:42)
3 March 6, 2014
Connor Cook works on his delivery
(0:28)

Latest

Most Popular

CBSSports.com Shop