• My Scores
  • NHL
  • NFL
  • NBA
  • Golf
  • NCAA BB
  • NCAA FB
College Football Insider

Coaching Changes Daily: Ranking the top 10 coaching hires

Tom Jurich brings Bobby Petrino back to Louisville after a tumultuous run for the coach. (Getty Images)
Tom Jurich brings Bobby Petrino back to Louisville after a tumultuous run for the coach. (Getty Images)

More on CFB: 2013-14 college football coaching changes

Once James Franklin takes over at Penn State, there will have been 16 FBS-level jobs filled by my count. Below are 10 of the best jobs from that crop, ranked in order of strongest hires. Texas barely cracks the top five, while Southern Cal and Louisville are in the bottom half.

1. Chris Petersen, Washington: Detractors say Chris Petersen hasn't recruited at a BCS level, can't deal with the media or won't be dominant outside the Idaho comfort zone. But the rebuttal is this: If you needed to pick three coaches to go win one game, Petersen would be on many lists. Not many maximize talent better.

2. Bob Diaco, Connecticut: Yes, UConn. Diaco might not be a savior, but he's exactly what the Huskies need. Some non-BCS programs need a marketer/CEO as much as a good ball coach, though the latter is imperative. Diaco has the potential to do both very well. He's energetic and well-prepared.

3. James Franklin, Penn State: Assuming Franklin had no wrongdoing in the Vandy rape case -- and from what I've gathered PSU likely won't find any glaring problems -- Franklin leaves little to complain about. He's good enough with people to assuage the lingering post-Paterno tension at PSU. He's 16-4 in his past 20 games at Vandy. Please repeat that last sentence before deciding if this is a good hire.

4. Craig Bohl, Wyoming: Wyoming got Craig Bohl? That was my first question when I saw the news. This is like when Jermaine Dupri landed Janet Jackson. Probably shouldn't have happened. Bohl could have had a Big Ten job. Now he's in Laramie. Still a bit shocking.

T-5. Charlie Strong, Texas: Strong does two things Texas needs -- he acquires talent and, more importantly, he evaluates talent properly. Still needs to prove he can handle UT's political beast, though the way he massaged the Red McCombs "position coach" issue is a good start. This is a very good hire, not truly great until proven otherwise.

T-5. Dave Clawson, Wake Forest: This is right in Wake's comfort zone, an unassuming, overachieving MAC coach who has thrived on the small private-school circuit. Bowling Green's spanking of Northern Illinois in the conference title game was impressive. Could have gone Clawson or Ball State's Pete Lembo and either would have been solid.

7. Steve Sarkisian, Southern California: Sark rebuilt Washington but he never carried the Huskies to a breakout season. Eight wins was the ceiling. This should be a mild concern despite Sark's obvious recruiting prowess and a personality. Sark can thrive as long as USC is ready to play every week. No repeats of Washington's curious blowout loss to Arizona State.

8. Bryan Harsin, Boise State: Harsin was born in Boise, played at Boise, coached at Boise. He is Boise. A natural hire. He's eighth on this list only because most of these hires have been good and Harsin is relatively unproven after his 7-5 debut with Arkansas State.

9. Jeff Monken, Army: Runs the option, relatively diverse coaching background, 38-16 record at Georgia Southern including a win in The Swamp -- a good hire, overall. Not spectacular, but good. Low on this list because of the competition ahead of him.

10. Bobby Petrino, Louisville: Louisville had several chances at a great hire. Instead, it reverts to its C-USA/Big East days to rehire a coach with a track record of insincere behavior who's on his seventh job in 14 years and can't be trusted with state funds or buyout clauses. Tom Jurich garners enough clout to be trusted, but sheesh, what an unimaginative hire.

CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre

College Football Video

December 19, 2014
Gary Andersen joins Jim Rome (5:13)
December 17, 2014
P.J. Fleck joins Jim Rome
(5:15)
December 17, 2014
College Football Recruiting Update: 12/17
(5:44)
December 17, 2014
Coaching changes impacting recruiting
(4:30)

Latest

Most Popular

CBSSports.com Shop

College Bowl Bound

Free 3-Day Shipping over $100!
Use code 3DAY100
Get their favorite team
Shop Now

2014-15 College FB Playoff
College Football Playoff