Eli vs. Peyton? Eli or classmate Big Ben is an even better question
Super Bowl MVPs and titles stoke Eli and Peyton Manning debates. But Clark Judge says the standout Giants quarterback is an even more intriguing comparison with 2004 draft classmate Ben Roethlisberger.

---

Big Blue Redux? History says Giants repeat highly unlikely
The Giants can win it all again. But Clark Judge says two divisional obstacles, the Eagles (4 straight closing wins) and Cowboys, plus a helping of history say Big Blue won't hoist the Lombardi Trophy next season.

---

Five plays that won XLVI for the Giants and lost it for Patriots
The Mario Manningham catch and Eli Manning throw. A tough drop, a bad penalty and a questionable decision. Clark Judge looks at five plays that turned Super Bowl XLVI.

---

Judgements: Manningham's catch review surprised him a little
Mario Manningham's sideline catch evokes David Tyree memories, a big grab keeps the winning drive alive for eventual champion Giants. But Clark Judge says the refs' review left Manningham wondering if he'd be a hero.

---

Pats need Scarnecchia to stop Giants' D, but it's easier said than done
Don't look at Rob Gronkowski for the Patriots' fate in Super Bowl XLVI. Look at O-line coach Dante Scarnecchia, who must find a way to keep the Giants off of Tom Brady. Clark Judge says this may be a puzzle he'll never get to solve.

---

Giants' Gilbride's phone doesn't ring, which is music to Coughlin's ears
There's no getting away from hearing about the Giants' big-play potential. But what about the man who calls the plays? Clark Judge says it's high time Kevin Gilbride gets another shot at running his own team.

---

Brady great, but he needs fourth title to really be compared with Montana
Tom Brady gets another chance to match his hero's Super Bowl rings. Will he go down in history as better than Joe Montana? Clark Judge starts the discussion, but says the debate shouldn't begin until Brady wins No. 4.