Down on the Farm: Being frank about Franklin
The Seattle Mariners need punch on offense and they have options in the minors. But will they pull the trigger and call up someone like Nick Franklin? Scott White takes a closer look in Down on the Farm.
Homer Bailey , who hits ninth every fifth day for the Reds, is batting .250 with a .583 OPS this year. Travis Wood , who hits ninth every fifth day for the Cubs, is batting .235 with a .572 OPS.
That's not great, but it could be worse. They're pitchers, after all. For them, hitting is secondary. Outs are assumed.
Then, there's the No. 9 hitter for the Mariners, an AL team whose pitchers don't see the batter's box apart from occasional interleague games. He's batting .129 with a .332 OPS.
He's also not a favorite of manager Eric Wedge, getting benched early last year for an "accountability issue" and again early this year, presumably for a lack of production.
Yes, all signs point to Brendan Ryan being more trouble than he's worth to the Mariners, and yet because their only recourse at the major-league level is Robert Andino , a starter he remains.
True, he's arguably the best defensive shortstop in the game, and for some teams, that might be enough. But the Mariners rank 26th in runs scored this year and weren't any better off with Ryan in 2012 or 2011. For too long now, they've had to resort to an NL lineup for the sake of his glove. At some point, general manager Jack Zduriencik has to realize what Wedge already has: Enough is enough.
Nick Franklin is making it oh so easy for him.
A top prospect since putting together a 20-20 campaign for Class A Clinton in 2010, his stock had slipped along with his power numbers over the last couple years. But he made strength training a priority this offseason, adding bulk to his wiry frame with the help of a 6,500-calorie-per-day diet, and if his numbers at Triple-A Tacoma have any say in the matter, it's made all the difference.
In 109 at-bats, he's batting .339 with four homers, five steals and a .982 OPS. And though at age 22 he's one of the younger players in the Pacific Coast League, his 24 walks compared to only 16 strikeouts suggest he's hardly lacking in polish.
As much as the numbers can tell us, Franklin is ready for the next step, which is of course the last step and the only one Fantasy owners care about. The Mariners just need to decide they're ready for him.
So ... what's the holdup?
|1.||Wil Myers , OF, Rays||75|
|2.||Zack Wheeler , SP, Mets||49|
|3.||Jurickson Profar , 2B, Rangers||48|
|4.||Oscar Taveras , OF, Cardinals||47|
|5.||Yasiel Puig , OF, Dodgers||40|
|6.||Billy Hamilton , SS, Reds||36|
|7.||Trevor Bauer , SP, Indians||33|
|8.||Gerrit Cole , SP, Pirates||33|
|9.||Christian Yelich , OF, Marlins||32|
|10.||Travis d'Arnaud , C, Mets||32|
It could be another "Super Two" situation, though I get the feeling most baseball executives care less about that than we outsiders think they do. Trying to predict a magic date that won't become apparent until three years down the road is pretty much a fool's errand. Plus, if the player really ends up being the bee's knees, his general manager can buy out the extra arbitration year with a club-friendly long-term deal. Just look at the Cubs with Anthony Rizzo .
It could be a matter of the Mariners resisting another defensive downgrade after acquiring Michael Morse to man left field and moving Jesus Montero back behind the plate, but they didn't come this far to again rank near the bottom in runs scored.
It could simply be an abundance of caution. Franklin has had some ups and downs over his minor-league career, after all, and he wouldn't be the first player to overachieve in the Pacific Coast League.
But you know what I think? The Mariners don't want to commit to Franklin just yet because they're not sure he's their best option long-term. Some reports this spring suggested they actually prefer Brad Miller -- a gritty, contact-hitting, look-ma-no-batting-gloves type in the Matt Carpenter mold who's batting .305 with five home runs, four steals and an .879 OPS at Double-A Jackson. He's a level lower than Franklin, but he's 18 months older and stuck around for just about all of spring training. Yes, the Mariners wanted to get a good long look at him.
Of course, that was before Franklin went all Troy Tulowitzki on the PCL.
Hey, it's just a hunch. For all I know, each of these factors is contributing in some way to the holdup. But sooner than later, something will change here, be it someone getting hurt, someone getting traded, Franklin forcing the Mariners' hand or Ryan pushing Wedge over the edge. It may take until the All-Star break, but rest assured Franklin's power-speed combo will make him an interesting Fantasy option to close out the season.
So interesting that you should go ahead and stash him now in a standard 12-team league? Well, I can think of 12 shortstops I'd rather start than Franklin whenever he does arrive, so probably not. But chances are by that point in the season, you'll have a roster spot to play with, and his upside will make him a good fit for it.
Down in the Midwest League (Class A), scouts have been flocking to Cedar Rapids' games to no doubt catch a glimpse of Byron Buxton and Jose Berrios , who are among the Twins' top prospects. To their credit, Buxton and Berrios haven't disappointed.
Buxton -- who was the No. 2 overall pick in the 2012 draft and the consensus No. 2 prospect in Minnesota's system behind Miguel Sano -- is destroying pitching (.349/.597/1.049) in the Midwest League. Berrios -- who ranks up there with Alex Meyer , Kyle Gibson and Trevor May among the team's top pitching prospects -- hasn't lost in his first four starts (3-0) and is striking out 11.2 batters per nine innings.
But there is another name starting to grab the attention of scouts, team executives and long-term Fantasy keeper owners -- Adam Brett Walker II. It sounds more like a name that belongs at an upscale country club than in a baseball lineup, but there's no mistaking Walker can hit.
Walker's slash line (.309/.655/1.010) is equally impressive as Buxton's, and he was taken 95 picks after Buxton in the 2012 MLB draft. Walker leads the Midwest League with 44 RBI and hit his third grand slam of the season Tuesday. Baseball execs and scouts have been enamored with Walker's power potential since his college days at Jacksonville, but he slipped into the third round for multiple reasons -- most notably a high strikeout rate, a susceptibility to breaking pitches and having an average arm for an outfielder.
While Walker is slugging .555 and has belted 24 home runs in his first 93 games, he's still striking out a lot -- averaging 1.2 strikeouts per game in his career -- and scouts feel he's destined to end up as a first baseman. But there's little denying this kid can rake if he makes contact.
When talking about Walker's ceiling, Giancarlo Stanton comparisons often arise in scouting reports. A quick look at Stanton's minor-league numbers compare favorably to what Walker has done early in his career, including Stanton averaging 1.14 strikeouts per game.
While no one, not even this writer, is ready to deem Walker the second coming of Stanton, his blistering start has warranted attention. At this pace, it might not be long before Walker is talked about in the same breath as Sano and Buxton.
Now, let's move onto five other players in the minors grabbing headlines …
, SP, Royals
, SP, Rockies
, SS, Athletics
Rubby De La Rosa
, SP, Red Sox
Rob Refsnyder, 2B, Yankees