Reality Check: Prioritizing those DL spots

For five days, you caught a glimpse of what could have been, your patience and foresight rewarded with enough production to shake up the standings.

Hanley Ramirez was back, and he was proving well worth the wait.

"Ha-ha!" you laughed, more in triumph than amusement. "This is what I was waiting for! This is what I knew would happen! My genius knows no bounds!"

Yes, for five glorious days, you were like a super villain whose super plan had gone all too right. But as you basked in your radiance, forces of nature were at work --forces small and secretive enough to conceal your impending downfall.

Ramirez was healthy for a full five days, and then with one tug of the hamstring, he wasn't.

Which will bring us back to doh!

On the one hand, you can't be too disappointed. Ramirez had beaten his initial timetable by about a month, so if this new injury costs him that much time, you're right back where you started. On the other hand, you've operated under the new timetable for weeks now. You've already had other villainous thoughts and enacted other villainous schemes, such as gobbling up Brandon Beachy to fill your now-vacant DL slot.

Oh yes, wicked indeed.

Or maybe you hadn't engineered something so devious since Draft Day, when you selected Curtis Granderson and Corey Hart late, anticipating their eventual returns.

It seemed like a good idea at the time, but that was before Jered Weaver broke his elbow, Zack Greinke broke his collarbone, Jose Reyes sprained his ankle and Michael Bourn cut his finger.

Playing the victim now, are we?

Maybe that maniacal laughter that accompanied Ramirez's performance wasn't in response to how good you had it, but how bad you needed it. Though stashing two or three injured players in the hope of a big payout later is typically a sinister strategy, any more than that can become burdensome. You need to have something in the way of depth.

Naturally, if you find yourself with four or five high-end DL players, which is increasingly likely with Ramirez, Roy Halladay and Andrew Bailey joining the ranks, you could try trading one of them, but you'd have to expect lowball offers in return, especially if your wicked ways are known throughout the land.

In the absence of legitimate offers, painful as it may be, prioritization is your only recourse. To that end, I've created a rank list. Of all the players on the DL, these are the 25 most worth owning in Fantasy. Ideally, they should all be owned, but at least now picking and choosing isn't so evil.

That's your thing, after all.

1. Giancarlo Stanton , OF, Marlins

Injury: Strained hamstring
Projected Return: Late May

Stanton was the highest drafted of all of these players and deserves more time to find himself, especially since the rest of the Marlins lineup has only recently come around. A couple weeks' wait is nothing for a player who could potentially be your team's best.

2. Jered Weaver , SP, Angels

Injury: Broken elbow
Projected Return: Late May

Weaver broke his non-throwing elbow, so it's not like he'll need to learn to pitch all over again. Now that the fracture has had time to heal, he should get back to being the Angels' ace within a few weeks.

3. Zack Greinke , SP, Dodgers

Injury: Broken collarbone
Projected Return: Early June

I'll stick with the initial estimate of eight weeks to differentiate between him and Weaver, but with some reports suggesting he could actually return in late May, I'm looking to buy low on Greinke wherever I can.

4. Michael Bourn , OF, Indians

Injury: Lacerated finger
Projected Return: This weekend

Bourn's return is imminent. Considering he's had the stitches out for close to a week now, he should probably already be back. He may not be as high-end as some of the players that follow, but with him so close to being useful again, you'd be crazy to part with him now.

5. Hanley Ramirez , 3B/SS, Dodgers

Injury: Strained hamstring
Projected Return: Late May

The severity of Ramirez's hamstring injury is less than clear. Ramirez thinks it's no big deal, which would suggest a two-week timetable. Manager Don Mattingly thinks it is, which would suggest more like a four-week timetable. I'll split the difference and say three weeks, but he's worth the wait either way.

6. Jason Heyward , OF, Braves

Injury: Appendectomy
Projected Return: Late May

That late-May timetable is perhaps overly cautious considering Heyward has already begun hitting. Of course, maybe the extra time will help him get his swing right. His early struggles are the only reason he's not higher.

7. Johnny Cueto , SP, Reds

Injury: Sore oblique
Projected Return: Mid-May

A sore oblique doesn't sound as bad as a strained oblique, but nobody's forcing the Reds to use precise terminology. The injury is a fresh one -- he originally went on the DL with a lat issue -- which makes Cueto's timetable less than certain. I predict he'll be back before Weaver and Greinke, though.

8. Josh Johnson , SP, Blue Jays

Injury: Triceps inflammation
Projected Return: Late May

Johnson's sudden trip to the DL last week wasn't because his triceps inflammation got worse, but because the Blue Jays opted for a more cautious approach. He isn't as reliable as a Weaver or Greinke, but he has that kind of potential.

9. Curtis Granderson , OF, Yankees

Injury: Broken forearm
Projected Return: Mid-May

Granderson, who broke his forearm early in spring training, needs about 50 at-bats before returning and has already begun getting them at extended spring training. His expected return is fairly projectable at this point. Unfortunately, his expected production is not.

10. Jose Reyes , SS, Blue Jays

Injury: Sprained ankle
Projected Return: Early July

Still in a walking boot, Reyes likely has months to go. A post-All-Star break return is more than feasible. Of course, even if you have to play short-handed for that length of time, his production at a weak position is worth it.

11. Aaron Hill , 2B, Diamondbacks

Injury: Broken hand
Projected Return: Late May

After breaking his hand in mid-April, Hill is already halfway home. Even if you don't totally buy into his 2012 numbers, you should be willing to wait and see by this point.

12. Corey Hart , 1B/OF, Brewers

Injury: Torn meniscus in knee
Projected Return: May 30

Most Fantasy owners drafted Hart anticipating a late-April return, but if nothing else, the Brewers' abundance of caution makes his projected return abundantly clear. When healthy, he's as steady as power hitters come.

13. Brett Anderson , SP, Athletics

Injury: Sprained ankle
Projected Return: Mid-May

Anderson was able to pitch 5 1/3 innings of relief on his bum ankle back on April 29, so I suspect his DL stint will be relatively short. He may not be an ace when healthy, but he's too good to stick on waviers.

14. Adam Eaton , OF, Diamondbacks

Injury: Sprained elbow
Projected Return: Late May

When a UCL sprain becomes a UCL tear, Tommy John surgery is usually the only recourse, so Eaton is on dangerous ground. He's already begun hitting and throwing, though, so I'd like to see my favorite preseason sleeper through to the end.

15. Matt Garza , SP, Cubs

Injury: Strained lat
Projected Return: Mid-May

For as close as Garza is to returning, he should be owned in more than 67 percent of leagues. His WHIP and strikeout rate were ace-caliber at the time of his injury last year, and he may need only one more rehab start.

16. Mark Teixeira , 1B, Yankees

Injury: Torn tendon sheath in wrist
Projected Return: Late May

Teixeira's place on this list might be low for some people's liking, but his injury has the makings of an eternal headache. Not only could it still cause season-ending surgery, but a lengthy -- perhaps even on-the-job -- rehab stint seems likely. Some years he needs 150 at-bats to find his timing.

17. Roy Halladay , SP, Phillies

Injury: Shoulder inflammation
Projected Return: Early June

We don't know how serious Halladay's injury is yet, but as long as it's something that will heal on its own, which is a logical assumption at this point, he's well worth stashing. Remember: He had seemingly turned the corner with three straight great starts before his shoulder started acting up.

18. Coco Crisp , OF, Athletics

Injury: Strained hamstring
Projected Return: Mid-May

Crisp was the top hitter in Fantasy at the time of his injury, but injuries are kind of the norm for him. Plus, he was clearly performing over his head power-wise. Even with the short timetable, he doesn't deserve the leeway of the legitimate high-end types.

19. Brandon Beachy , SP, Braves

Injury: Tommy John surgery
Projected Return: Mid-June

Beachy's long road back from Tommy John surgery is nearing its end, and in case you've forgotten, he was emerging as an ace at this time last year. He probably has six or seven rehab starts ahead of him, but boy, you'd like to stash him if you could.

20. Andrew Bailey , RP, Red Sox

Injury: Sore biceps
Projected Return: Late May

Bailey was looking like a top-10 closer during his time filling in for Joel Hanrahan , but now that Hanrahan is filling in for him, the Red Sox could easily go back to their original plan of Bailey in the setup role.

21. Ryan Madson , RP, Angels

Injury: Tommy John surgery
Projected Return: Late June

Late June might be a generous timetable considering Senior Baseball Columnist Scott Miller recently said on Fantasy Baseball Today that he didn't expect Madson back before the All-Star break, but the right-hander threw a successful bullpen session Saturday. He's the definitive closer when he returns.

22. Michael Pineda , SP, Yankees

Injury: Torn rotator cuff
Projected Return: Late June

This timetable is a wild guess considering not every pitcher makes any sort of comeback from a torn rotator cuff, but reports of Pineda throwing in the mid-90s in extended spring training have me cautiously optimistic.

23. Kevin Youkilis , 1B/3B, Yankees

Injury: Sore back
Projected Return: Mid-May

Relatively speaking, Youkilis' injury is no big deal, but relatively speaking, neither is he. At this stage of his career, he's a serviceable corner infielder in mixed leagues but one you shouldn't be afraid of losing to someone else if you cut him.

24. Colby Lewis , SP, Rangers

Injury: Torn flexor tendon in elbow
Projected Return: Late May

Lewis doesn't have ace potential, and his procedure doesn't assure him a full recovery. Still, if he's close to what he was when he returns in a few weeks, he'll be an asset in wins, WHIP and strikeouts.

25. Derek Jeter , SS, Yankees

Injury: Broken ankle
Projected Return: Late July

The Yankees have all but eliminated the possibility of Jeter returning in the first half. In fact, he might not even return this season. Still, if you have a DL spot to play with, you might as well take a stab at him.

Stay in touch with the most passionate Fantasy staff in the business by following us on Twitter @CBSFantasyBB or Scott White at @CBSScottWhite . You can also e-mail us at .

Senior Fantasy Writer

Raised in Atlanta by a board game-loving family during the dawn of the '90s Braves dynasty, Scott White was easy prey for the Fantasy Sports, in particular Fantasy Baseball, and has devoted his adulthood... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
CBS Sports Shop
MLB Opening Day
Our Latest Stories
    Jonah Keri Podcast