Fantasy & Reality: First round frustration?
Are you fed up with your first round running back but aren't sure what course of action to take? Our Dave Richard discusses potential trade scenarios and lineup advice going forward.
A hip injury here, a twisted ankle there, a trade to Cleveland and a number of other issues have decimated what once looked like a murderer's row of Fantasy studs atop our pre-draft rank lists.
It's resulted in major frustration. Of the first 10 rushers drafted on average this summer, there are major question marks with more than half of them. Heck, four of them aren't even averaging 10 Fantasy points per game. It's made for a nightmare -- no one likes to be "that guy" who misses on a first-round pick and this year there are a lot of them.
Who should be benched? Who should be dropped? Here's a review of the Top 10 drafted running backs through seven weeks of the season.
Draft average: 1.11
Start percentage last week: 100
Top 12 finishes this year: 3 of 6 games
There's some concern over Peterson after totaling 12 Fantasy points over
his last two games against the Panthers and Giants. In that span he's
averaged 14 touches per game, an uncharacteristically low number
for him considering he had at least 22 touches in each of his first four
games. It could be because of his hamstring, which reportedly tightened
up on him at New York, or it could be because the coaches have implored
their quarterbacks to take advantage of "what the defense gives you" and
not force Peterson into eight-in-the-box situations. Coach Leslie
Frazier said Monday he plans to get the situation fixed fast, so there's
some confidence Peterson could see his workload improve. But it's a
concern: He hasn't had a two-week skid this bad since 2010 (and he
snapped it after two games).
Cut him? Never
Trade him? Only if someone offers a no-brainer. Now's the time to try and trade for Peterson.
Start him? Definitely. Expect the Vikings to utilize their best offensive weapon in their game plans moving forward.
Draft average: 4.61
Start percentage last week: 96
Top 12 finishes this year: 1 of 6 games
Martin has a torn labrum in his shoulder but there's no definitive
timetable for his return. Multiple media reports have Martin missing the
rest of the year; Bucs coach Greg Schiano won't rule him out past Week
8. But with the Bucs staring at another losing season they'd be foolish
to rush Martin back in a meaningless season. It's that kind of thinking
that should lead Fantasy owners to consider cutting Martin.
Cut him? You don't have to, but if you need someone off waivers and don't have someone else to cut, then do it.
Trade him? No one is going to give you anything for him unless keepers are involved.
Start him? Not anytime soon.
Draft average: 5.21
Start percentage last week: 99
Top 12 finishes this year: 3 of 7 games
Fantasy owners were satisfied with Foster going into last week's game.
Despite just three Top 12 finishes he also had one Top 13 finish,
another Top 20 finish and couldn't finish his Week 7 game at Kansas City
because of a hamstring injury. Coach Gary Kubiak called him "day-to-day"
which is good news, considering it took Foster a lot of time to get
healthy after offseason calf and back injuries. If Kubiak is being
honest -- which he hasn't always been when it comes to his running backs
-- then Foster should be expected back in action in Week 9. Either way,
now's the time to trade for
(who is also hurting with broken ribs but says he'll play) if you don't
have him already.
Cut him? Unless the hamstring injury that's "day-to-day" becomes "month-to-month" he should be on rosters.
Trade him? If you can get a haul in trade for Foster, including a reliable starting rusher, then go for it. There has to be some concern about Foster suffering another injury, no matter how small.
Start him? He's on bye in Week 8, but assuming all is well come Week 9 he remains a must-start.
Draft average: 5.95
Start percentage last week: 100
Top 12 finishes this year: 7 of 7 games
Charles is the engine in Andy Reid's offense, maybe even more than
was in Philadelphia. Charles already has at least 19
touches per week and at least one touchdown and over 100 total yards in
every single game! About the only helpful advice I could offer here is
to pick up his backup,
case Charles misses any playing time. Nothing suggests Charles is headed
for a downturn.
Cut him? Child please.
Trade him? No way.
Start him? Of course.
Draft average: 6.66
Start percentage last week: 58
Top 12 finishes this year: 1 of 7 games
taking on more
work than we thought he would, the Bills lived up to their promise of
giving Spiller as much work as he could handle early on as he averaged
16.5 carries and 4.0 catches per game through the first two weeks. Then
he hurt his quad against the Jets in Week 3. Everything went sour from
there as Spiller limped off the field the following week and has limped
off after decent runs each of his last two games. It's obvious he's not
close to 100 percent and the Bills have moved away from giving him a big
amount of reps. Though it's believed Spiller will regain his role once
he's healthy, there's no telling when it will happen. It probably won't
be in the Bills' next four games against staunch defenses in New
Orleans, Kansas City, Pittsburgh and the N.Y. Jets before their bye.
Owners might feel compelled to make a move involving Spiller.
Cut him? I wouldn't go that far since he could have some really nice late-season value. Plus, if he hit the waiver wire in my league I'd pick him up in a heartbeat for my bench.
Trade him? I'd deal him so long as I got a fair offer for him. Expect someone in the neighborhood of Alshon Jeffery or DeAngelo Williams . Seriously. You can't expect first-round value for a player who's delivered like a late-round pick, but you should still be able to get a decent starter for him. If you need to win now this should be the route you take.
Start him? Last week I thought he'd be healthy enough to contribute vs. Miami and then he got hurt again. The Bills would be wise to let him rest a week and let Jackson and Tashard Choice handle the game action. Whether or not that happens remains to be seen, but I wouldn't risk a starting spot on Spiller.
Draft average: 7.93
Start percentage last week: 100
Top 12 finishes this year: 4 of 7 games
Lynch remains the bully in the Seahawks backfield. He's even taken on a
little more work as a receiver, catching 14 passes through seven games
(it took him 10 games to catch 14 passes last year). Only three tough
games remain on his schedule.
Cut him? Never.
Trade him? Someone is offering you Jamaal Charles or LeSean McCoy ? Cool. Otherwise, nope.
Start him? Always.
Draft average: 9.31
Start percentage last week: 95
Top 12 finishes this year: 2 of 6 games
There's a lot to be worried about with Rice, the biggest of which being
his absolute lack of production in five of his last six games. Take away
his Week 1 success against the Broncos and his multi-score game at Miami
in Week 5 and you've got a back who has totaled 183 yards in five games.
That's brutal. He doesn't have a play good for more than 14 yards this
year and he's averaged 3.4 yards per carry or less in every game! Some
of this is because the Ravens' offensive line is in flux, but a lot of
it has to do with Rice struggling through a hip injury suffered in Week
2. Rice claims he's "looking forward to doing some damage" after the
Ravens' Week 8 bye, but the Ravens' schedule has a lot of tough
opponents ahead for Rice to deal with.
Cut him? Can't do it. And why do it when you have options?
Trade him? If you're sick of Rice then a deal is your best alternative. I wouldn't mind buying low on Rice in a deal -- others in your league might feel the same way. A trade for someone like Eric Decker or Andre Johnson should be considered fair.
Start him? On a bye in Week 8, Rice's Fantasy owners should maintain mild expectations headed into Week 9.
Draft average: 9.47
Start percentage last week: 74.
Top 12 finishes this year: 0 of 6 games
When we drafted Richardson it was with the idea that he'd work in Norv
Turner's running-back friendly offense, catching passes and plowing in
at the goal line. A blockbuster trade after Week 2 changed Richardson's
course, landing him on a Colts offense that wants to be run-friendly but
can't effectively do it. That's no excuse for Richardson's play -- he's
been downright putrid -- and as a result the Colts have been relying on
to help pick up the slack. Brown has been the better
Fantasy back in two of the Colts' last three games! Maybe Indianapolis
uses its Week 8 bye to find ways to get Richardson going (he has two
catches with the Colts compared to seven in two games with the Browns
earlier this season) but right now he's nothing more than a big name
with a big draft price tag and nothing to show for it.
Cut him? There will be owners so disgusted with Richardson that they'll punt on him. Don't be one of those owners. I might give him a chance after the bye week even though the Colts' remaining schedule features several tough run defenses, none meaner than at the Chiefs in Week 16.
Trade him? This option stinks because no person will give up something great for Richardson. You're probably looking at a depressing trade for another underachieving player, maybe straight up for someone such as Marques Colston or Cecil Shorts or even Spiller. It's enough to make you keep him.
Start him? When the Colts reconvene in Week 9 it'll be against a Texans defense that has allowed a touchdown to a back in four of its last five and will be without linebacker Brian Cushing . That might be enough to make you consider starting Richardson as a Flex, not a No. 1 or No. 2 Fantasy running back.
Draft average: 9.89
Start percentage last week: 100
Top 12 finishes this year: 5 of 7 games
It's crystal clear that Chip Kelly's offense agrees with McCoy. It's
also clear he remains effective even without the crazy workload we saw
him get in Week 1 (32 touches). Still on pace for over 320 carries,
McCoy carries a little injury risk but no one is sweating it so long as
he remains in a manageable role. There aren't many tough defenses left
for him to face this year, either.
Cut him? No! No! No!
Trade him? You might be talked into it if it means getting Peyton Manning or Jamaal Charles , but realistically McCoy shouldn't be moved.
Start him? Yes! Yes! Yes!
Draft average: 14.16
Start percentage last week: 95
Top 12 finishes this year: 2 of 6 games
Our guy Alf has been disappointing but has finished as a Top 20 running
back in all but one week this season. That's better than Spiller and
Richardson, to name two. What's missing are those games where he
decimates a defense like he did last year. Maybe they're coming -- many
of Morris' great games in 2012 came because he was used in conjunction
Robert Griffin III
zone-read offense. Washington has begun to let RG3 run more so that
could help Morris as defenses prepare for both him and Griffin.
Unfortunately for Morris, the Redskins have given some prime touches to
-- he's their passing downs and no-huddle back. It'll take
him off the field more than he was last season, though it hasn't meant a
total collapse in stats -- he's been under 70 yards rushing once this
year (Week 1).
Cut him? That would be drastic.
Trade him? You could, but because there isn't a lot of excitement about Morris you probably won't get what's fair for him. He is still considered a near-elite Fantasy rusher.
Start him? You might be squeamish doing it this week against Denver and in home matchups against San Diego, San Francisco and Kansas City, but unless you have a lot of other choices then Morris will be a regular in your lineup.
Checking in on the averages
After looking at the Top 10 running backs picked back in August, I thought the time was right to see what those guys should be scoring from week to week. Three weeks ago we took a gander at the scoring averages for each tier of player per position. If anything, it's just to get an idea of what to expect from those roster spots week in and week out.
I took the averages from the first, second and third groups of 12 players at each position based on Fantasy points scored in a standard league, then calculated their respective per-game averages. Use this data to grade how your starters have been performing and for some perspective on what to count on going forward.
|Tier||Wks 1-4||Wks 1-7||Diff.|
The takeaway: Scoring is down across the board from when we did our measurement three weeks ago -- and not just at a certain position. The drop in receiver production is especially confounding, but it goes hand-in-hand with the drop in quarterback stats. Some passers that got off to a hot start have slowed down ( Tony Romo , Philip Rivers , Sam Bradford ) while others are getting hot after a dry spell ( Aaron Rodgers , Robert Griffin III , Andy Dalton ). Also note that zeroes from the bye are taken into consideration, so that drives down the averages a bit as well. We won't check the numbers again until after the "Bye-nados" of Weeks 8 and 9.
But just for fun, I also cross-referenced the numbers between now and this time last year, with the better averages bolded.
|Tier||2012 Wks 1-7||2013 Wks 1-7||Tier||2012 Wks 1-7||2013 Wks 1-7|
|QB 1-12||21.0||22.1||WR 1-12||11.5||11.8|
|QB 13-24||15.0||15.3||WR 13-24||8.7||8.6|
|RB 1-12||12.6||13.2||WR 25-36||7.2||7.3|
|RB 13-24||8.5||7.8||TE 1-12||7.3||8.9|
|RB 25-36||5.6||6.2||TE 13-24||4.3||4.9|
So even though you might be disappointed in your team's Fantasy performance this season, most positions are still scoring more points now than they were a year ago this time.
Fantasy & Reality
Quick observations about the misconceptions (Fantasy) and truths (Reality) from around the league.
Fantasy: I'm actually nervous I didn't project Nick Foles for enough Fantasy points. That was my closing line for the analysis I wrote for him in Winning Fantasy Calls last week. Embarrassing! I watched the Eagles quarterback take apart the Bucs defense in Week 6 -- I have no idea where that guy was in Week 7. The quarterback I saw -- and started in several of my leagues -- was way off of the mark and slow to get the ball out, even though he regularly had plenty of time to throw against the Cowboys. Foles actually made the Dallas defense look better than it really is. If there's a lesson learned, it's that we all need more than six quarters of a game to be thoroughly convinced a player will be "flawless" (another word choice of mine).
Reality: Harry Douglas took my expectations and tripled them. Another player I was way off on was Douglas, who torched the Bucs last week for a career game. I even wrote a review about him on his player page, only to be completely blown away by his performance. But remember what I learned from my mistake with Foles: Don't fall in love with a player without enough of a track record to justify it. Douglas, like Foles, did very well against the Bucs. His two biggest plays involved him breaking away from coverage, which isn't something he's known for. I might still be cautious in starting him as anything more than a decent No. 2 choice at Arizona this week.
Fantasy: Hakeem Nicks is the second-best receiver in New York. If I had a choice between Nicks and Rueben Randle for this week, I'd go with Randle. The second-year wideout has been better than Nicks in Fantasy points each of the last three weeks, despite having fewer targets and catches. Randle has averaged more yards per catch and has been a regular in the end zone; Nicks hasn't scored yet this season and has had his chances. I saw Nicks struggle last year with his technique while being a step slower than I remember and here we are again seeing it. I'll track these two going forward, but I'd bet on Randle to keep beating the coverage he gets compared to what Nicks sees.
Reality: Mike James will have a chance. If you're looking for a player comparison for new Bucs starting running back Mike James , it's Pierre Thomas . Both are stocky backs without great speed but the tenacity to break tackles and lean forward to pick up a couple of extra yards. James is worth starting as a bye-week replacement or as a Doug Martin replacement with the expectation he delivers along the lines of what we've seen from Martin so far. Those kinds of numbers might be soft for a former first-round Fantasy choice, but they're solid for a guy you might have just picked up off the scrap heap.