With his ball at the base of a cactus, Dubuisson took an all-or-nothing swing though the sharp needles and a TV cable and incredibly hit it to 4 feet to save par. Seemingly out of it on the next playoff hole, the 23-year-old Frenchman somehow whacked a wedge through a desert bush and rocks and onto the green for another par.
Day finally ended the madness Sunday on the 23rd hole with a pitch to 4 feet on No. 15 for birdie.
It was the first time the championship match went overtime since the inaugural year in 1999 at La Costa, when Jeff Maggert chipped on the second extra hole of a 36-hole final. That was like watching paint dry compared to the show Dubuisson put on.
"Those two shots were amazing," Dubuisson said. "I just played it like I had nothing to lose."
Day, with his first World Golf Championship, walked away with his second PGA Tour title that will take the Australian to No. 4 in the world.
This tournament might better be remembered for Dubuisson's magical escapes.
"Vic, man, he has a lot of guts," Day said. "He has a great short game -- straight out of the cactus twice. For a 23-year-old kid, he's got a lot of game. We're going to see a lot of him for years to come."
Even the great Seve Ballesteros would have saluted this performance.
Two holes down with two holes to play, Dubuisson rapped in a 15-foot birdie putt on the 17th hole and then took advantage of a rare lapse by Day, who bogeyed the 18th hole with a three-putt from 50 feet on the upper tier. The Frenchman saved par from the bunker to force extra holes.
It looked like it would be over quickly.
From the first fairway, Dubuisson went so far long that bounced hard off the back of the green and into the desert, the ball nestled at the base of a cholla. During regulation, he would have taken a penalty drop. In this case, he felt he had no choice. He stepped up to the ball and, with nothing to lose, swung away. The club got caught on a TV cable, and the ball scooted up the slope of 3-inch grass and onto the green.
It was reminiscent of the shot Bill Haas pulled off at East Lake from shallow water on the 17th hole. This was better.
And it came with an encore.
On the next extra hole, the par-5 ninth, Dubuisson tugged his shot left of the green, left of the bleachers and into a desert bush surrounded by rocks. He took another crack at it, and the shot came out perfectly through thick grass and onto the green.
Day could only laugh, though he had every reason to believe this was not his day.
"I kept shaking my head because there was a couple of time there where I thought he was absolutely dead -- the tournament was mine," Day said.
It was -- eventually.
After matching bogeys and pars on the next two holes -- this time from the green grass -- the match ended on the 333-yard 15th hole when Dubuisson's drive strayed too far right into side of a hill, leaving him an awkward pitch.
"I'm disappointed because I made some terrible shots," Dubuisson said, ignoring the two that were as close to a miracle as golf allows.
Day won $1.53 million. Lost in all the theater was that he never trailed over the final 53 holes of this fickle tournament.
Dubuisson earned $906,000, all but assuring a PGA Tour card for next year. And he all but clinched a spot on the Ryder Cup team in September, moving to the top of the points table by the equivalent of about $1.5 million.
Dubuisson only reached the championship match by rallying from 3-down after six holes against Ernie Els in the morning semifinals. The Frenchman said he couldn't sleep Saturday night, perhaps because he realized he was playing a four-time major champion.
He wound up beating Els with a par on the 18th hole to meet Day, who beat Rickie Fowler 3 and 2.
Fowler beat Els in 19 holes in the third-place match.
For all the heroics by Dubuisson over the final hour of this amazing show, Day certainly had his moments.
Dubuisson was on the back fringe in two on the par-5 11th in regulation, and it looked as though he would cut into a 3-down deficit when Day found a fairway bunker off the tee and could only blast out, leaving him 269 yards away. The 26-year-old Australian fired a 3-iron at the green, and the ball caught the ridge and burned the left edge of the cup before stopping 5 feet away. He made birdie to halve the hole.
Day also poured in a 10-foot birdie putt on the 15th in regulation to match birdies and keep a 2-up lead. But he had two putts in regulation to win, and missed both time. The first was a 20-foot birdie putt on the 17th. And on the 18th, Day left a 10-foot par putt short of the hole.
He flipped his putter in disgust as the handle struck his chest. He didn't want extra holes. He had no idea what was coming next.
But he never got flustered during Dubuisson's magic act.
"The biggest thing was, 'How much do I want to win?' I kept saying that to myself. Last night, I kept visualizing myself with the trophy," Day said. "I'm glad I could finish it off. But it was a close one."