Blog Entry

AL East Preview

Posted on: March 28, 2010 1:16 am
Edited on: March 28, 2010 12:53 pm
<!--[if gte mso 9]><xml> <w:WordDocument> <w:View>Normal</w:View> <w:Zoom>0</w:Zoom> <w:PunctuationKerning /> <w:ValidateAgainstSchemas /> <w:SaveIfXMLInvalid>false</w:SaveIfXMLInvalid> <w:IgnoreMixedContent>false</w:IgnoreMixedContent> <w:AlwaysShowPlaceholderText>false</w:AlwaysShowPlaceholderText> <w:Compatibility> <w:BreakWrappedTables /> <w:SnapToGridInCell /> <w:WrapTextWithPunct /> <w:UseAsianBreakRules /> <w:DontGrowAutofit /> </w:Compatibility> <w:BrowserLevel>MicrosoftInternetExplorer4</w:BrowserLevel> </w:WordDocument> </xml><![endif]--><!--[if gte mso 9]><xml> <w:LatentStyles DefLockedState="false" LatentStyleCount="156"> </w:LatentStyles> </xml><![endif]--><!--[if !mso]> <mce:style><! st1\:*{behavior:url(#ieooui) } --> <!--[endif]--> <!--[if gte mso 10]> <mce:style><! /* Style Definitions */ table.MsoNormalTable {mso-style-name:"Table Normal"; mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0; mso-tstyle-colband-size:0; mso-style-noshow:yes; mso-style-parent:""; mso-padding-alt:0in 5.4pt 0in 5.4pt; mso-para-margin:0in; mso-para-margin-bottom:.0001pt; mso-pagination:widow-orphan; font-size:10.0pt; font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-ansi-language:#0400; mso-fareast-language:#0400; mso-bidi-language:#0400;} --> <!--[endif]-->

Hmm, I don't know why this jargon is showing up^^. It doesn't show up when I'm writing my post and I can't get rid of it. Just ignore it. Sorry


With the start of the season only a week away, I thought I'd look at my Sox and the AL East this year.

Boston: Boston has a new look this year, with Marco Scutero the latest in the revolving door that is the Red Sox short stop position, Adrian Beltre at 3rd base and Mike Cameron in center field. The Sox don't quite have the firepower of past teams, with Manny Ramirez long gone and Jason Bay moved on. However, this team is better defensively and still capable on offense. Jacoby Ellsbury, Dustin Pedroia, Victor Martinez and Kevin Youkilis form a very nice top part of the lineup. David Ortiz, Mike Cameron, J.D. Drew, Adrian Beltre and Marco Scutero round out the lineup. 

A nice thing about this Sox team is that they have depth. The outfield has two capable backups in Jeremy Hermida and Josh Reddick, who made a name for himself last year. The Sox also acquired Bill Hall, who can play second base, third base and outfield. Also, veterans Mike Lowell and Jason Varitek can provide quality time in the field should Beltre or Martinez be injured. Also, Marco Scutero is backed up by Jed Lowrie, who has showed promise, but has struggled with consistency.

The Sox are blessed with a multitude of quality pitchers this season. John Lackey, Josh Beckett and Jon Lester as a good a threesome as there is in all the major leagues. Clay Buchholz looked very good at the end of last season, and as we all know from that no-hitter, he has a wealth of potential. Then of course, there is Japanese import Daisuke Matsuzaka, who has struggled with consistency and injuries. If either Dice-K or Buchholz encounters issues, the ever-present veteran Tim Wakefield will be around to eat innings and be a quality 5th starter. The Sox also acquired Boof Bonser, who can help out of the bullpen or start in a pinch.

This Sox team has the potential to be superb, or merely decent, depending on how several key players perform. If David Ortiz can bounce back, that would provide a big lift to the Sox. He doesn't even need to hit .300 with 40 homers, but if he could hit .270-.280 with 25-30 homers, that would be huge. Another key is Adrian Beltre. If he can regain his form of several years ago, that would be brilliant for the Sox, but if he could even get to 15 homers, that would be solid. Finally, Matsuzaka could be huge for this team. If he performs well and avoids injuries, he could pitch like a #2 starter. He has struggled with command in the past, but if he can deliver, the Sox will be in excellent shape. Overall, the Sox should be right in the mix again this year for the AL East title, and the AL pennant. If the pitching is as good as expected, and the offense can deliver, this team could be going deep into October


New York: This division will again be a two horse race between the Red Sox and – who else? – the Yankees. The Yankees have a once again potent lineup, led by Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira. The Yanks this year are in a sense the opposite of the Red Sox. They will have no trouble producing offense, with the aforementioned three, Robinson Cano, and newcomers Curtis Granderson and Nick Johnson also contributing. The lineup will be rounded up by Brett Gardner, Jorge Posada and Nick Swisher.

This is a potent lineup to say the least. Derek Jeter and Nick Johnson will be able to get on a base a lot for A-Rod and Teixeira, who should be in line for huge years. The bottom of the Yanks lineup is still very strong, with Cano, Granderson and Posada all capable hitters. And you won’t find much better options for the bottom two spots than Nick Swisher and Brett Gardner.

The pitching is less certain for the Yankees. They are led by C.C. Sabathia who should be superb as always. After that though, it gets murky. A.J. Burnett has loads of talent, but struggled with inconsistency all of last year. How he performs will be huge for the Yankees. Javier Vazquez was excellent last year for Atlanta, but can he do the same in the Big Apple against AL hitters? Andy Pettite should be solid but not spectacular, which is what you hope for in a fourth starter. Phil Hughes just recently won the fifth rotation spot, but he is a big question mark. He has great potential, but has struggled with consistency a great deal. This relegates Joba Chamberlain to the bullpen, where he, along with Mariano Rivera will anchor a good bullpen. But will the starters be able to give them leads to protect?

Overall, I think the Yankees will be in the playoffs once again this year. Their pitching is not great, but it doesn’t need to be with an offense like they have. If their pitching can remain solid, their offense should be able to get them plenty of wins. A big player to watch is A.J. Burnett. If he can consistently deliver his top stuff, that helps the Yanks in a big way, and makes them that much tougher to beat. However, isn’t it often said that pitching wins championships? Regardless, the Yankees should be playing in October again this year.


Tampa Bay: Tampa Bay will be an alright team this year, but I just can’t see them overtaking either the Sox or Yankees in the division. The Rays’ lineup is led by Evan Longoria, who, along with Carl Crawford and Carlos Pena, will be counted on to provided the offense this year. Jason Bartlett is a solid leadoff hitter, and Ben Zobrist exploded onto the scene last year. B.J. Upton had a terrible year last year and will be looking to rebound.

The lineup is rounded out by Dioner Navarro, Pat Burrell, and Matt Joyce. This offense won’t be racking up runs like the Yankees, but they will be able to put runs on the board at a decent clip. The key is Upton – if he can deliver on his potential, and have a great year, the Rays’ offense will be so much better. I will also be interested to see if Ben Zobrist can continue his success from last year. If so, that too will aid the offense greatly.

The pitching for the Rays is good, but not great. Matt Garza is a solid starter, who, along with James Shields will have to anchor the Rays’ rotation. If they don’t have good years, the Rays will be in big trouble. Jeff Niemann was solid last year for the Rays, with a 13-6 record, and an ERA under 4.00. Wade Davis is a relatively unknown commodity – last year was his first year in the big leagues, and he only started 6 games. He did however, throw a complete game shutout, and if he can find that form this year, the Rays might have a hidden gem. The big question of course, is David Price. Last year, he had a 10-7 record with an ERA of 4.42. Those aren’t bad numbers for a rookie, but frankly, if the Rays are going to challenge the Sox and Yanks this year, he needs to be better. If he can fulfill his enormous potential, the Rays might be able to push the Red Sox and Yankees at the top of the division. The Rays also acquired Rafael Soriano, who will be a much needed stabilizing presence in the bullpen.

Overall, the Rays are a decent team, but they have the misfortune to be stuck with the Red Sox and Yankees. If they were in the AL Central, maybe they could make the playoffs, but I just don’t see it happening here this year. They should be an over .500 team, but I just don’t think they’re good enough to beat Boston or New York. If the pitching is excellent, Ben Zobrist is fantastic, David Price becomes an ace and B.J. Upton regains his lost form, maybe the Rays can challenge. But for now, it looks tough for the Rays.


Baltimore: The Orioles have had a tough last couple of years, but they are showing true potential. Nick Markakis and Adam Jones are their two offensive stars, and they will hopefully be driving in Brian Roberts, who should have a great year, and Nolan Reimgold, who had 15 homers and a .279 batting average in 100 games last year. If Markakis and Jones play well, Roberts gets on base as usual, and Reimgold develops nicely, the top part of this lineup could be very good.

I, like many others, am wondering how Matt Weiters will do this season. He was decent last year in 96 games, batting .288 with 9 homers and 43 RBI, but if we are to believe the hype, he is capable of much, much more. If Weiters can deliver a .290-20-80 season, that would be very good, and anything more would be great.

The O’s lineup is rounded out by veteran Miguel Tejada, Luke Scott, recently acquired Garret Atkins and shortstop Cesar Izturis. Scott is a solid hitter, and Tejada will be looking to prove he still has more in the tank. If he could produce like last year, with a .313 average and 86 RBI, the O’s would be very pleased. Atkins showed he could really hit the ball in Colorado, and will be looking to prove he can do it in Baltimore after a touch year last year.

The Orioles’ rotation is led by Kevin Millwood, who pitched well for Texas last year, winning 13 games and posting an ERA of 3.67. He has showed great durability, starting at least 25 games every season but one since 1998. After three so-so years in Texas, he was very good last year, and will be looking to build on that. Jeremy Guthrie is next, and he will be looking to rebound from a sub par 2009 in which he lost 17 games and had an ERA of 5.04. Instead, he will be looking to regain his 2008 form, when he posted a 3.63 ERA and 6 K/9 innings. Brian Matusz, Brad Bergesen and Chris Tillman round out the O’s rotation. All three are promising young pitchers who the O’s hope will learn from Millwood and develop quickly.

The Orioles aren’t ready to challenge the Sox, Yanks, or Rays this year, but in a couple years, they might be. They are young and promising and are hoping to make some good progress this season


Toronto: Unfortunately for Toronto and Jays fans everywhere, this year looks like it’ll be pretty bleak for the Blue Jays. No Roy Halladay anymore, which means 20 fewer guaranteed wins for the Jays. The offense will be lead by Vernon Wells, Aaron Hill, and Adam Lind, who will be looked upon to provide the firepower. Jose Bautista is the leadoff man but he hit only .236 walked less than once a game – hardly a stellar leadoff hitter.

The Jays will also be looking to Edwin Encarnacion and Lyle Overbay for some hitting, although Encarnacion hit only .225 last year. For the Jays to succeed, he needs to do better. John Buck, Travis Snider and Alex Gonzalez round out the lineup, and they are hardly sluggers. If their big three can deliver, Bautista can get on base and Encarnacion can find his stroke, the Jays offense could produce some runs, but if Wells, Lind and Hill falter, and/or they get no help, it could be very tough to score this year.

The rotation is led by Shaun Marcum and Ricky Romero, both of whom are (relatively) young pitchers who show promise. Marcum is coming off a bad injury, but he was showing real potential before the injury, and if he can regain that potential – a winning record with an ERA in the low 3s – the Jays would be in much better shape. Romero looked great as a rookie last year, and the Jays will be looking for him to deliver big time this year. Brandon Morrow, Brian Tallet and Mark Repczynski round out the rotation and all three are question marks. Morrow pitched only 69 innings last year, but the Jays need to him to be a middle of the rotation starter. Tallet wasn’t great last year, with a 5-7 record and a 5.32 ERA, and the Jays will need him to be better. Repczynski started 11 games last year in his first year in the big leagues wasn’t bad at all recording almost a strikeout per inning and compiling a 3.67 ERA.

This looks like it’ll be a tough year for the Jays. They could make some noise if their young pitchers pitch extremely well, and their lineup produces some runs, but it seems that they have too many question marks, especially in the rotation to do much damage.

Final Analysis: I see the final order of finish as thus:

  1. Red Sox
  2. Yankees
  3. Rays
  4. Orioles
  5. Jays


My reasons for having the Red Sox ahead of the Yankees are twofold: 1) I believe good pitching trumps good hitting and 2) I’m a Red Sox fan and I just like them better. The Sox and Yankees will be battling it out for first spot in the division, and I fully expect that whoever comes in second will get the wild card spot. Tampa Bay will be a good team, but just not good enough to beat the Sox and Yanks. The Orioles are young and improving, but still two years away I believe. As for the Blue Jays, any progress is better than no progress – I think it’ll be a tough year for these Jays, who won’t be terrible, but will be a mediocre team stuck in a tough division and will finish either fourth or last.





Since: Sep 27, 2006
Posted on: March 29, 2010 10:23 pm

AL East Preview

Too many people are focusing on that predicted order of finish - I just added that in at the end on a whim, and partly to satisfy myself. The main point is that I think the Yankees and Red Sox will be battling for first, and the Rays will finish the third. I don't know who will actually finish first, so don't go crazy over that. The main reason I wrote this was to focus on each team and how they looked, not to predict the order of the finish.

Also, phillyrabit, I am by no means dismissing the Rays. They are a young talented team that can make some noise. I just think that they won't be quite able to keep up with the Yankees and Red Sox. Perhaps they do make a run - it would surprise me but wouldn't shock me. They have the capability to make a run in the division, I just don't think they will. Please don't think of that as a total dismissal, because it wasn't meant to be.

Since: Oct 5, 2007
Posted on: March 29, 2010 6:51 pm

AL East Preview

You dont give  the rays enough credit. Alot of things went wrong for them last year and they still won 84 games. There just as talented if not more then eather and yankee's or redsox. You can argue That the redsox are trying to be more like the rays. Focusing on pitching and fielding. Im not saying the rays will win the division because no one knows. But to completely dismiss them and say everything has to go right for them just  to compete is ignorant in my point of view.

Since: Sep 2, 2006
Posted on: March 29, 2010 2:51 pm

AL East Preview

Final Analysis: I see the final order of finish as thus:

  1. Red Sox
  2. Yankees
  3. Rays
  4. Orioles
  5. Jays


My reasons for having the Red Sox ahead of the Yankees are twofold: 1) I believe good pitching trumps good hitting and 2) I’m a Red Sox fan and I just like them better. The Sox and Yankees will be battling it out for first spot in the division, and I fully expect that whoever comes in second will get the wild card spot. Tampa Bay will be a good team, but just not good enough to beat the Sox and Yanks. The Orioles are young and improving, but still two years away I believe. As for the Blue Jays, any progress is better than no progress – I think it’ll be a tough year for these Jays, who won’t be terrible, but will be a mediocre team stuck in a tough division and will finish either fourth or last.




Coming from a Red Sox fan I'm not surprised.  As for your illogical "reasons": 1. I'd agree but if that was the case, the LA Dodgers, Oakland, San Francisco, Atlanta, St. Louis, Chicago Cubs, Seattle, Chicago Sox, Philadelphia, Cincinnati, and Colorado all had better team ERA's then the World Champion New York Yankees. Eight teams were ahead of the Yankees for innings pitched. 18 teams were ahead of the Yankees in quality starts. Twenty teams were ahead of the Yankees in shutouts and complete games. I could go on.....The Red Sox lack the offensive of power required to make it in the AL East. An aging David Ortiz off of his "Dominican shakes", no Manny Ramirez or Jason Bay, the Red Sox will struggle to get runs, putting pressure on their pitching staff. No one is scared of the 3 and 4 hitters in that Red Sox line-up.

In my humble opinion the standings will be The Wild Card will not come out of the AL East this year. There are a ton of improved teams in the AL.
1. Yankees
2. Red Sox
3. Orioles
4. Rays
5. Jays

Since: Dec 28, 2006
Posted on: March 28, 2010 9:58 pm

AL East Preview

aj burnett is inconsistent, i wont argue that. however, he has been dominant at opportune times last season, (like game 2 of the world series where he shut down the phillies, and evened up the series) or terrible at other times. the good news is that he is terrible for a month at a time, then amazing for another month. last year we got good aj for the playoffs, which is a major reason why we have #27. i think he will be injured, but you look at his overall stats, which are the medium between his two sides, either he throws a 2.00 era, or a 6.00, and that averages out to around a 4.00. 
why do you look at the last 10 games as a means of hope for buchholz, yet ignore the last ten games when reviewing beckett. if you want to talk about a melt down at inopportune times, what about josh beckett giving up alot of home runs at the end of the season? he was terrible when the sox needed him the most, and hes very injury prone (just like burnett). lackey is a fly ball hitter pitching in what would be a minor league ballpark if not for the monster. he is historically bad in fenway. vasquez was dominant in 04 before injury, and he will be more then passable for a 3rd starter. wakefield is very very old, we will see how he holds up this year. your jap sensation has had 1 good year, and been terrible at times. and the biggest difference between clay and hughes is the perfect game. i wont argue that the sox have a much better rotation, largely because of jon lester, but the yankees offense is so much better then yours that it will more then make up for it. we also have a better bullpen. i dont see how the sox are gonna keep up this year. 
and no, your offense wont be that great. you need to fit your park, and the sox dont do that. fenway is very much so a hitters park, theres a reason the sox have been a power team in the past. you dont need speed in left like some other teams do. i dont see your team as one that fits your park, and thats a serious problem, one i dont think your gonna overcome. 

Since: Sep 27, 2006
Posted on: March 28, 2010 12:51 pm

AL East Preview

Well, thank you for visiting my blog, i appreciate it. Now, about Burnett - he has excellent stuff, but since coming to the American league, his two best seasons have been 2007 when he went 10-8 with a 3.75 ERA and 2008 when he was 18-10 with a 4.07 ERA. Not bad but, but hardly the stats he is capable of. He has also had major trouble with control - he has walked 183 batters the last two seasons to Beckett's 89. I noticed - which means that Yankee fans surely must have noticed - that he tends to have meltdowns at very inopportune times. Yes, Beckett had some struggles too last  year, but 17-6, 3.86 is much better than 13-9, 4.09, especially considering how many walks Burnett allowed. That might've been ok if he was striking out batters all the time, but Beckett had more strikeouts too. So yes, Beckett struggled a bit, but it was nothing compared to Burnett's struggles. Also, when I say the Yankees pitching is a question mark, that is in relation to their offense, which seems rock solid. Obviously they have better pitching than many, probably most, other teams, but it's just not as solid as their own hitting, or the Red Sox' pitching. This is in the same manner that the Red Sox offense is still good, just not as good as their pitching.

About Buchholz versus Hughes - I'll admit, my opinion was affected slightly by just constantly seeing how good Buchholz can be, as opposed to not seeing Hughes as much. However, I did say right in the article that Hughes has great potential. And I didn't say it, but anyone who has watched Buchholz knows that he has struggled with consistency as well. However, Hughes worked almost exclusively out of the bullpen last year, meaning that starting will be something relatively new (I know he's started before, just not a whole lot). Last year, Buchholz went 6-1 in his last 10 games, allowing over 3 runs only three times in those 10 games he also had a brilliant stretch from early August until late September, where in 10 starts, he failed to reach 6 innings only once, and allowed over three runs only once. Hughes has no such track record as a starter. Hughes also blew 3 saves in 6 chances last year, indicating a possible struggle under pressure, although he did work well out of a number of pressure spots in non-save situations. My point is, Buchholz had a very promising year as a starter last year, especially in August and September, which is encouraging. Hughes was good out of the bullpen, but his play as a starter has been inconsistent

And when you say "The Yankees Starters are just as good if not better than the Sox" are you talking about pitching? I hope not. The lineup 1-9 yes, but the pitching rotation, no way in hell. Sabathia is an ace, but he's the only rock solid one. Burnett had an over 4 ERA last year and walked too many people. Vazquez was good for Atlanta, but it's tougher to pitch in the AL. If they're lucky, he'll be able to match up with Lester. Pettite is ok, but aging, and nothing special, and we have already gone over Hughes. So the only spot where the Yankees have an advantage is with Sabathia. At the beginning of the rotation, Beckett>Burnett, Lester>Vazquez. And while Lackey probably won't be as good as Sabathia, he will still be excellent. No way the Yankees pitchers are better than the Sox.

Tha Yankees are good, but no way can you say that they are running away with this division already. I think the division race will be close all season.

Since: Aug 21, 2006
Posted on: March 28, 2010 11:02 am

AL East Preview

I did what you asked, I visited your analysis.  Now I have to ask you, the inconsistent Pitching staff you speak of rolled through the playoffs and world series last year, minus last seasons NL runner up for the CY Young Award, So, why is AJ Burnett considered shakey and Josh Beckett who had just as many ooops in his starts last year considered quality?  What makes quality and a wealth of potential and Hughes who was lights out all last year setting up Mariano Rivera and who also was pitching a no hitter but was pulled out of the 7th due to injury.. a guy who in your opinion struggles with consistency?

The Yankees Starters are just as good if not better than the Sox,  the big differenc and this is where Championships formulate...  its the Bullpen and the Yankees may be going into this season with one of the best ever.

In my opinion.... its a 2 horse race for 2nd place ... between the Sox and the Rays.

Since: Dec 28, 2007
Posted on: March 28, 2010 9:06 am

AL East Preview

Great analysis.  Hope you're right about the Sox as division champs!

Since: Sep 27, 2006
Posted on: March 28, 2010 1:28 am

AL East Preview

Thoughts, comments, suggestions are welcome, whether about the article or the writing. Sorry if it got a little lengthy.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or