Blog Entry

Is Talent Worth the Risk?

Posted on: February 6, 2009 10:50 am

One of the biggest headlines this offseason will surely be whether Michael Vick will be allowed to return to the NFL, and if so, where will he go.  Now I'm well aware that this is not a novel revelation; I'm sure you've heard every sports writer in the world at least mention this, and I'm going to do the same.

For the sake of writing something interesting, I am going to assume that Roger Goodell allows Vick to play in the NFL.  If not, well, then you can stop reading here. 

So Vick comes back into the NFL, and I think it's safe to say the Falcons will let him go.  He caused that franchise so much agony, I'd be surprised if they even let him within 100 miles of the team.  Besides, Matt Ryan played well enough that there shouldn't be any questions about who is playing QB for them next season.  I would also imagine Vick will be released rather than traded, due to his large contract and the fact that the Falcons probably won't get anything worth while for him.

With Vick now a free agent, I'd imagine the prospects are pretty slim.  I had  always thought that if he were going to make a comeback, it would be with the Raiders, but if Al Davis thinks JaMarcus Russell is the man (but honestly, who knows what Davis thinks these days) he won't end up in Oakland.  I'm sure Vick's highlight-reel-appeal would make Jerry Jones' eyes glimmer, but he has Tony Romo, and I think he learned his lesson with the Adam "Pacman" Jones fiasco (I will call him Pacman until he proves that the name no longer applies).

Now that the two teams that seem to gravitate towards star-potential over character are eliminated, the pickings look slim.  Vick will be 29 at the start of the season, who knows how in-shape he will be, and frankly, a QB of his playing style will need to develop as a pocket passer once he starts to lose his speed (see Randall Cunningham).  And honestly, of the teams that would be in the market for a QB (a few are Kansas City, San Francisco, and Detroit), do you really see them taking (Con)Vick? The man whose negative publicity shamed the NFL for months?  I can't imagine most teams would be willing to sacrifice their PR for the gamble that starting Vick would be.  I mean, not to dwell on the past, but weren't we harshly ciritcizing his QB play before this whole incident?

This pretty much leaves Vick as a desparation sign, or a backup.  But can you really justify signing the former NFL's Richest Man as a backup?  Especially after the aforementioned issues?  I just don't see it happening.  To me, Vick is something Pacman should be--untouchable.  Even if this is the only blip on his resumeé (and it's a big one), no team should have to explain to their fans why Mr. I-Drown-Cute-Little-Puppies is the leader of their franchise.

Sorry Mike, but I think you're done...


Since: Jan 13, 2008
Posted on: February 6, 2009 5:58 pm

Is Talent Worth the Risk?

Michael Vick is done as a QB in the NFL.  His style no longer fits.  Unless he can become a pocket passer and a great one, no team will even give him a look.  There is a bigger question, however.  Would a team give a shot at another position?

Since: Mar 24, 2008
Posted on: February 6, 2009 1:28 pm

Is Talent Worth the Risk?

Ahhhhh... quite the question...

The trouble with the NFL and all of the other sports leagues now-a-days is that winning trumps all else... many teams will look the other way as their players do one dumb thing after another... talent is the trump card... and the problem is that many teams an in turn fans just want to win...

Ironically enough you mentioned the Raiders and is their motto not 'Just Win Baby'... we all know the teams... the Cowbosy have done it... the Raiders have done it... the Ravens have done it... even the Steelers have done it... I guess the question how much is a team willing to live with... in some cases it is shootings and stabbings... in some cases it is drugs... and I would guess in some cases it will be cruelty to animals...

The pressure to win will always give players a second chance... or a third... or a fourth... if Lawrence Phillips can beat women and get another chance, I would guess Michael Vick will be wearing a uniform as soon as he can... it is a shame... but many will say 'Just Win Baby'

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or