Blog Entry

2011 NY Giants WR Group

Posted on: February 16, 2011 5:13 pm

NEW YORK – The New York Giants wide receiver group is one of the bright spots on the team. Along with being one of the bright spots of the team, it could also become a headache for the team. The reason is simple and it is the same question the team must answer every single year. Which six WR’s will be on the roster at the beginning of the season. The G-Men are solid with the starters that include WR Hakeem Nicks, WR Steve Smith and WR Mario Manningham. Those three guys will be on the team for sure. The problems begin to arise after the three starters. In a pool of talented young WR’s, who the heck do you keep on the team?

I expect a lot of people to have their own opinions about this subject and I respect them all. I can only give my perspective on what the Giants will do and who deserves to remain on the teams final roster. I expect one or two will end up on the practice squad if they cannot find employment elsewhere. The one thing that is blatantly clear to me now, is the fact that the New York Giants receivers are big guys. Not one of them are below 5’11″ and the tallest guy is a whopping 6’6″. Sinorice Moss is no longer with the team and now the chatter has begun about bringing back Plaxico Burress. Burress coming back to the Giants is a possibility but highly unlikely. I wouldn’t mind seeing the team give him a league minimum contract for a year or two but I’m not sure how Coughlin wold feel about it.

Things are going to be very interesting for GM Jerry Reese this off season, that is of course assuming there will be a 2011 NFL season after the CBA talks. Recent reports say that the talks are not going very well at all. This is something that has fans ripping their hair out and wondering when the greed will end for an industry that makes about 10 billion dollars a year. But enough about that, let’s take a look at the wide receivers currently on the New York Giants roster and remember this list could change due to trades or any other transactions in the near future.

1. Hakeem Nicks, 6’1″ 215 pounds – Nicks has separated himself from the pack to become the No.1 WR for Big Blue. If not for a injury in 2010 that caused him to miss three games, he would have made the pro bowl in my opinion. Look for him to make the pro bowl this year if he can stay fully healthy for the entire season. This man is a superstar.

2. Steve Smith, 5’11″ 195 pounds – Mr. Smith ended the 2010 NFL season on the IR list and missed a total of seven games. This was a huge blow to the team and something fans do not want to experience again. The team and fans have come to depend on Smith in a big way and things were not the same without him. He is also QB Eli Manning’s favorite safety valve.

3. Mario Manningham, 5’11″ 185 pounds – Super Mario has been improving each and every year since he arrived in New York. He put together a very nice 2010 season and finished 2nd on the team for WR’s. He was forced to miss two games due to injury but who hasn’t on the Giants the past two seasons. Manningham is arguably the best No.3 WR in the NFL.

4. Ramses Barden, 6’6″ 227 pounds – Fans are hoping that Barden has grasped the Giants playbook while he was sidelined for thirteen games and finished the year on the IR list. Now all he has to do is perform on the field. This guy was praised as the replacement for Plaxico Burress when he arrived. I think it was more because of his height then his talent. That is a lot of pressure to put on a rookie and he didn’t deserve it. Still, the time has come to perform.

5. Domenik Hixon, 6’2″ 182 pounds – Hixon did not play in a single game in 2010 and was put on the IR list (seems like a trend now I bet) during training camp. This really hurt the Giants return game on special teams and also eliminated a big target WR in special passing situations. He will be back in 2011 and the fans will be thankful for that.

6. Victor Cruz, 6’1″ 200 pounds – This kid was lightning in a bottle during the preseason and had fans sitting on the edge of their seats. He is a local kid from Jersey who made the most of his opportunity and landed a roster spot. Unfortunately, he landed on season ending IR list and did not get to shine in the regular season. If the Giants were to cut him, he would be picked up by another team the very same day. He has the aura of a playmaker.

7. Derek Hagan, 6’2″ 215 pounds – After the WR group was clearly decimated by injuries, as you have been reading, the G-Men called on an old friend to come back and help the team out. Hagan did a pretty good job for the seven games he was with the team. He finished 6th on the team at WR, despite not playing for half of the season.

8. Duke Calhoun, 6’4″ 205 pounds – Calhoun played in six games for the Giants but did not get the ball thrown to him very much. Almost not at all actually. He finished with 1 reception for 4 yards in 2010.

9. Michael Clayton, 6’4″ 215 pounds – Clayton was brought in for the same reason Hagan was, the team needed depth at WR. And like Calhoun, Clayton didn’t see the ball but one time for 19 yards.

10. Devin Thomas, 6’2″ 218 pounds – Once again, Thomas is a player that was brought in for depth after the rash of injuries crushed the WR corps.

11. Todd Watkins, 6’3″ 195 pounds- This guy was added to the reserve future list and is a complete question mark.

12. Samuel Giguere, 5’11″ 215 pounds – This guy was added to the reserve future list and has seen limited playing time in the NFL.

13. Plaxico Burress, 6’5″ 230 pounds - This is clearly a wild card and something that fans have been talking about recently, now that his release date is close. Reports have come out that say Burress has been working out five days a week and looks in great shape. Will the Giants be persuaded into giving him another shot with the team? I don’t know but I think the man deserves another chance now that he has paid his debt to society.

If you had to pick only six of the above WR’s, who would you keep on the roster?


Since: Mar 3, 2009
Posted on: February 17, 2011 7:39 pm

2011 NY Giants WR Group

Hey Charlie, he did drop a few passes form what I remember but he only played in 3 games due to injury. He had 5 catches for 54 yards in those 3 games. He basically missed his entire rookie season so I would give him another shot to see what he could do. I completely agree with you about getting OL help and more specifically, a true Center.

Since: Aug 29, 2007
Posted on: February 17, 2011 2:35 pm

2011 NY Giants WR Group

I don't know, Mock U.  Didn't Barden have a lot of dropped passes in his limited opportunities?  For a guy that size, he doesn't seem to have made much of an impact?  If they don't trust him enough to play him or throw to him, what's the point in keeping him?  It's pretty obvious they don't trust him in the red zone.  I don't know.  Maybe you're seeing something I'm not.  In any case, lets hope they get these guys some O-line help this offseason.  I was hoping for some coaching changes too, but it doesn't look like that's happening. 

Since: Mar 3, 2009
Posted on: February 17, 2011 2:06 pm

2011 NY Giants WR Group

Hey Charlie, thanks for the compliment, I like your list and it almost adds up to my own. I think Nicks, Smith and Manningham are the obvious for us all but it gets more difficult from that point on. I also agree that we need to keep Cruz because the guy is a playmaker. Hixon will help with the return game, which leaves us with the final spot, the sixth player. This is where I disagree with you, I'm not sure I would take a draft pick over Ramses Barden at this point. I think the guy needs to show what he can do before he gets cut. I agree that Burress will most likely not be on the team in 2011 but I still think he deserves a 2nd chance somewhere in the NFL. I could also see one or two of the other WR's ending up on the practice squad.

Since: Aug 29, 2007
Posted on: February 17, 2011 9:22 am

2011 NY Giants WR Group

If you had to pick only six of the above WR’s, who would you keep on the roster?

Hey, Mock U.  Nice blog as usual.  If I had to pick six to keep, I would go with: 

1) Hakeem Nicks - Probowler in the making.  Lacks explosive speed, but should be one of the better receivers in the NFC for years to come. 

2) Steve Smith - Solid possession receiver, much in the mold of Amani Toomer. 

3) Mario Manningham - Explosive playmaker with a nack for making people miss.  SHOULD eventually win the #2 WR slot. 

4) Victor Cruz - Runs good routes and often plays beyond his physical skills and abilities.  A great effort player who will give 100%.  A solid option to rotate in there to give the other WR's a rest.  Could emerge as the #3 is Steve Smith is not retained. 

5) Domenick Hixon - An average WR at best, but a solid return man who is an updgrade over the people we signed in his absence. 

6) 2011 draft pick - because I really don't have any use for anyone else on the list (including Burress). 

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or