Blog Entry

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

Posted on: August 28, 2009 9:22 pm
Edited on: September 1, 2009 9:25 am
1. Peyton Manning  STATS: 95.0 Passer RTG, 4,002 YDS 27 TD's 12 INT's

Analysis: Has done it all, won 2 MVP trophy, a Superbowl, been to countless Pro Bowls, and plays well no matter who he has on the field with him. He is a pure pocket passer, with a great arm, tremendous accuarcy, and unbelieveable pocket presence.

2. Tom Brady STATS: 83.9 Passer RTG, 76 YDS O TD's 0 INT's

Analysis: Before being injured Tom Brady was looking to return to the superbowl coming off a 50 TD season. When Brady is healthy, which is all the time, with the exception of last year, he and Manning are the best in the buisness.

3. Drew Brees STATS: 96.2 Passer RTG, 5,069 YDS, 34 TD's 17 INT's

Analysis: Extremely productive quarterback. Very accurate, underrated arm strength, and is a great leader. Brees has been one of the NFL's most productive QB's since coming to the Saints.

4. Phillip Rivers STATS: 105.5 Passer RTG, 4,009 YDS, 34 TD's 11 INT's

Analysis: Just got a huge contract, and it was well deserved. With LT having two down years, Phillip Rivers has kept the Chargers offense potent. He doesn't enough credit for working without a Top 20 reciever. 

5. Aaron Rodgers STATS: 93.8 Passer RTG, 4,038 YDS, 28 TD's 13 INT's

Analysis: Has overcome the drama that comes with being associated with Favre to become a great NFL quarterback. He has a strong arm, good accuarcy, and goes through his progessions very fast for a first year starter. 

6. Donavan McNabb STATS: 86.4 Passer RTG, 3,916 YDS, 23 TD's 11 INT's

Analysis: Over the last 5 years McNabb has proven to be a true pocket quarterback. He has become more accurate and has been very productive. He has been to a Superbowl and multiple NFC Championship games. Is also a proven winner.

7. Kurt Warner STATS: 96.9 Passer RTG, 4,583 YDS, 30 TD's 14 INT's

Analysis: Has returned to the form he had with the St. Louis Rams, were he won a Superbowl and was a cast member of the greatest show on turf. He has shown that age is just a number for the quarterback position in the NFL.

8. Jay Cutler STATS: 86.0 Passer RTG, 4,526 YDS, 25 TD's 18 INT's

Analysis: He is the best up and coming QB in the leaque. Cutler has a cannon arm, good accuarcy, and is mobile. He has all the tools to be great. He just needs to be surronded a good cast in order to start winning some games.

9. Tony Romo STATS: 91.4 Passer RTG, 3,448 YDS, 26 TD's 14 INT's

Analysis: Romo is the most underrappreciated quarterback in the NFL. He had to deal with Terrell Owens for 3 years and still produced at a high level. Cowboys fans most have forgot who their QB's were after Aikman. Anthony Wright, Quincy Carter, and the list goes on. I know the Cowboys have high expectations but you have a good QB, get over it.

10. Ben Roethlisberger STATS: 80.1 Passer RTG 3,301 YDS 17 TD's 15 INT's

Analysis: Has won two Superbowl rings. The latter superbowl Roethlisberger showed great poise and made some great plays when the Steelers needed it.

Since: Oct 12, 2009
Posted on: October 12, 2009 4:33 pm

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

are you kidding?  Has Palmer or Hasselbeck won anything? Please go back to watching tennis. We're talking the NFL, and the only thing that matters in the NFL is your won-loss record, period. Stats are for losers. No one asked who your "fantasy" was, this list was the best QB's. I'll give you Peyton, Brady, Brees, Big Ben, Rivers, as top five, but Elisha Manning doesn't make the top 10.

Since: Aug 31, 2009
Posted on: September 2, 2009 12:30 am

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

My top Ten QB's.  I base this off who is a natural QB that has supported his ranking with stats and leadership abilities: 

Rivers- hasn't proven he can win the big game

and there you have it. 

Since: Aug 31, 2009
Posted on: August 31, 2009 7:08 pm

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

1) Tom Brady
2) Peyton Manning
3) Drew Brees
4) Phillip Rivers
5) Ben Roethlisberger
6) Aaron Rodgers
7) Donovan McNabb
8) Kurt Warner
9) Eli Manning
10) Matt Schaub

Since: Jan 24, 2008
Posted on: August 31, 2009 3:42 pm

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

I'm a strong believer that the value of a QB is not determined by superbowls or superbowl appearances. Drew Brees is better than Rothlisberger who has 2 Superbowl Rings and Eli Manning who has 1. In order to determine a who is the better QB you have to look at the rings, the stats, the on field performance, the defense, the system, and the talent around the QB. That said Peyton Manning won a Superbowl with a terrible defense. I am Patriots fan and I look at the throws Peyton makes and the throws Brady makes, and it is appearent that Peyton is the better OB. I am not saying that this isn't arguable, but you cant just look at Brady's ring and say he is the better QB. Is Trent Dilfer better than Dan Marino? No it's not even close.

Since: Sep 22, 2008
Posted on: August 31, 2009 8:44 am

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

also how is brady not #1 3 rings baby and i would say that is ultamate way to grade a QB.

Since: Sep 22, 2008
Posted on: August 31, 2009 8:41 am

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

if you are talking top ten "fantasy qb's" big ben aint even on this list you could easily replace him with carson palmer or hasselbeck who both have superior fantasy value and stats to back that if you just mean best qb's period then stats don't apply and you would have to put ben in the top 3,4,or five based on winning.but if you plan on leaning on ben for fantasy you are screwed.

Since: Nov 30, 2007
Posted on: August 29, 2009 3:43 pm

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

I don't see how Aaron Rodgers is at 5 after one season.  Roethlisberger is a top five QB.  Period.  Switch those two and its pretty good.

Since: May 27, 2009
Posted on: August 28, 2009 10:45 pm

Top 10 NFL Quarterbacks

for Tony Romo how is dealing with T.O. a bad thing? The man has 129 touchdowns. I cant see how that is a negative thing.
And I dont see how you can put a guy who got over 5,000 yards in 3rd. Hes obviously first right now. He's the second person do that ever, second to Dan Marino. You have McNabb too high and Roethlisberger too low.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or