Blog Entry

Peyton’s Health in Question, But Keeping a Health

Posted on: January 29, 2012 10:07 pm
Primetime Thoughts

Follow David S. London on Twitter

            Days away from Super Bowl XLVI, reports continue to swirl about Peyton Manning’s future with the Indianapolis Colts.  While brother Eli prepares to potentially surpass Peyton with a second Super Bowl win in Lucas Oil Stadium, the house that Peyton built, discussions remain prevalent regarding the uncertainty surrounding the future Hall of Fame quarterback.  While Manning’s health is still up in the air, the public has been lead to believe that Manning will not be returning to Indianapolis.  Colts Owner Jim Irsay has done his best to downplay this notion, tweeting on Friday, "No he hasn't been released nor was a decision reached weeks ago."

            After finishing a league-worst 2-14, Indianapolis will have the first pick in the NFL draft this April.  The Colts are expected to select Stanford quarterback Andrew Luck.  For months, it has been concluded that the Colts couldn’t draft Luck and keep Manning.  Considered to be the best prospect since John Elway, Luck is thought to be ready for the NFL, needing no time to learn from the sidelines.  Generally, the path should be cleared when a franchise player is on the way. 

            Peyton Manning is an exception to that rule.

            If Manning’s neck doesn’t heal and doctors don’t clear him for football activities, then there is no discussion; Manning retires and goes to Canton, Ohio five years from now.  If, and it’s a big if, Manning is healthy enough to resume playing, Indianapolis should not hesitate to have Luck sit and learn behind one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever play the game.  Forget that Manning has been the face of the Colts franchise since 1998; loyalty in sports is a thing of the past.  Manning, 35, has always kept himself in pristine shape while keeping the hits from defenders to a minimum over the years.  If Manning is able to return to the field, that immediately makes the Colts a Super Bowl contender next season.  That speaks volumes about Manning’s abilities when you consider how dreadful Indianapolis was without him. 

            Luck looks to be a solid quarterback in the NFL.  That being said, there’s no guarantee of success; just look at any list of all-time busts of past first round draft picks.  Luck may be able to grow on the fly like Cam Newton or Andy Dalton.  Or they may take their lumps and struggle during their first few seasons.  Either way, there is uncertainty.  Manning, when healthy, is one of, if not the best quarterback in the league.  The PR nightmare would be tough enough if Manning is healthy and then plays elsewhere next season.  If Manning were to lead that team to a Super Bowl, Irsay would never live that down. 

            Irsay will do his best to win over the public opinion, but Manning can’t lose this battle.  “I don’t want to get into some kind of fan campaign with the owner, but I think it’s well documented that I want to play in the same place my whole career,” Manning said. “It’s been a privilege to play here. I love the fans, the city.”  Manning will be an icon in Indianapolis till the end of time.  Understandably so, Irsay and the Colts are reluctant to pay Manning his 28 million dollar bonus March 8 due to health concerns. 

Manning’s health remains in question, leaving the Colts unsure.  It seems like a no-brainer that if Manning is healthy, the Colts would be foolish to let him go elsewhere.  However, it looks as if the two are headed for a split.  While Manning will have plenty of suitors looking for the final piece to their Super Bowl puzzle, the Colts will simply hope for a little bit of luck.   


Since: Feb 6, 2012
Posted on: February 6, 2012 9:45 pm

Peyton’s Health in Question, But Keeping a Health

 has been medically cleared by two doctors -- one of whom performed the most recent surgery on the  quarterback's neck -- to resume his NFL career.

On Indianapolis' front, the good news was tempered by Colts owner Jim Irsay, who tweeted that "Peyton has not passed our physical nor has he been cleared to play for The Indianapolis Colts."

The sources said Dr. Robert Watkins, who performed the procedure on Manning, examined the player recently in Los Angeles and concluded the stability in his neck would have allowed Manning to play this Sunday as long as the nerves in his arm had regenerated to a satisfactory performance level.

Watkins also instructed the quarterback to continue an aggressive rehabilitation path that provides an optimistic outlook for Manning to play in 2012. Watkins performed Manning's spinal fusion Sept. 8, and on Dec. 1 declared that the fusion had achieved "firm fixation."

Watkins, according to the sources, joined Colts neurosurgeon Dr. Hank Feuer in clearing Manning to play. One source said that Feuer recently told Manning, "If you were my own son, I'd tell [you] to go play."

A spokesman for Watkins said in a one-paragraph email sent later Thursday night that the Colts' star was cleared to play.

"Peyton Manning underwent a thorough medical re-evaluation as part of a postoperative visit with his surgeon," Watkins' statement read. "As a result of this examination, Manning is medically cleared to play professional football."

Irsay said a team statement would be forthcoming later Friday.

Commissioner Roger Goodell, speaking Friday during his annual pre-Super Bowl news conference, said he's "not troubled at all" by all of the Manning talk during Super Bowl week, and doesn't believe it has been a distraction.

Goodell said he understands why there's so much interest in Manning, given that he's such an important player to the league and the community.

In addition to Manning's optimistic words expressed in an interview Tuesday with ESPN -- in which he indicated he plans to resume his playing career -- the medical clearance by his two doctors, the sources said, will bolster his determination to play in 2012.

What remains in question is the timeline in which Manning's nerve regeneration to his triceps will improve to the point where he is throwing passes in the manner that helped him win four MVP awards during his 13-year career.

According to one source familiar with Manning's medical review, "It's not a safety issue; it's a performance issue." This source added that Manning is "making progress."

The source said Manning had a throwing session Tuesday with two of his Colts receivers -- and  -- at an undisclosed location and that Manning has spent numerous recent days throwing to at least one wide receiver, aiming to regain as much strength as possible in his arm.

However, the source said Manning still cannot pinpoint a date when his performance will reach an acceptable level to him. The source alluded that it might take to the one-year anniversary of Manning's May 23, 2011, surgery on a bulging disk in his neck.

Manning and Colts owner Jim Irsay have both said they expect to sit down after the Super Bowl to discuss his future with the team as a March 8 deadline nears in which Manning is due a $28 million option bonus that will trigger the final four years of a five-year, $90 million contract he signed before the 2011 season. The quarterback already received $26 million as part of that deal.

Manning has expressed a desire to settle his future with the Colts "sooner than later." There is widespread belief around the league that Irsay will not exercise the $28 million bonus. Irsay was not available for comment.

Yet should the Colts opt not to exercise the option, they would be forced to release Manning, who would immediately become a free agent. And so, while the NFL's free-agent signing period is set to begin with the commencement of a new league year March 13, Manning could be a free agent as early as next week.

If Manning becomes an unrestricted free agent, several teams are expected to bid for him, including the , ,  and possibly the , among others.

Teams such as Arizona already have debated the merits of pursuing Manning behind closed doors. Some people within the Cardinals organization believe Manning could do for Arizona what  once did, propelling the team into an instant playoff contender.

Manning likely would be willing to sign a contract that would tie bonuses and salary to his roster status for 2012, and sources say that he will heavily factor in a team's ability to have a roster capable of competing for a playoff spot and, consequently, a Super Bowl title.

Trading Manning no longer is an option. Irsay has said he will not trade Manning -- which means he would have to pick up the $28 million bonus to retain the quarterback's rights -- and he also will not trade the No. 1 pick in the April draft, when the Colts are expected to select Stanford quarterback  or possibly Baylor quarterback . Many NFL executives expect Luck to be the pick.

While it is well known that Manning philosophically believes a quarterback who is the first pick in the draft needs to start from day one and wants to avoid the potential controversy that could develop in that situation, the Colts also have aligned their coaching staff with Manning-friendly offensive assistants.

New Colts coach Chuck Pagano recently hired Bruce Arians as the team's offensive coordinator and retained former offensive coordinator Clyde Christensen as the quarterback coach. Arians was Manning's first quarterback coach with the Colts form 1998 to 2000, and Manning offered Pagano a strong endorsement on Arians last week when the new coach and quarterback met.

Despite the fact that some have wondered if Manning will play again, the signs have been encouraging, even dating back to December.

In December, Watkins released a statement through the Colts that said: "X-ray and CT examination of the surgical area shows that the fusion performed in September has achieved firm fixation. Peyton now will be allowed to increase the intensity and breadth of his workouts as tolerated.

"There remains every indication that his recovery will continue. There still is no timetable for Peyton's return to practice, which is one of many steps in his expected return to game action. He is working hard on a rehabilitation program outlined in conjunction with myself, Erin Barill and Peyton. His response to this plan in the future will dictate his return date."

That is what has happened. Manning has intensified his workouts and now those close to him are more optimistic than ever that he will be playing in 2012.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or