Blog Entry

Baseball needs Bob Costas as commissioner

Posted on: January 16, 2010 12:48 pm

The game of baseball needs direction. Bud Selig has been maligned for most of his tenure as commissioner, and while he has done some good things for the game, he is often a lame duck or a puppet for the owners. In effect, Selig has been the commissioner since 1992, even though he was only officially given that title in 1998. Selig owned a team, the Brewers, before becoming the commish. There is no basis for his election, and he has not proven to be capable of leading baseball effectively.

Under Selig's leadership the game has become a richer business, but the biggest problems that face the game today are largely swept under the rug. With the game being as popular as ever, the players are signing bigger contracts, the owners are making more and more money, and the fans are being ignored. I don't think Selig understands the common fans perception. Sure, we love to watch because we love the game itself, but it is tougher and tougher to watch and follow the game. It is tougher and tougher to bring our sons and daughters to the games, due to both cost and integrity issues. 

There are 2 major factors that are making the game more difficult to follow, and in turn pass along the enjoyment to our children.

The first factor is the steroids and drug testing. This issue has been around for the duration of Selig's tenure, and for his part in it all Selig's choice was to sweep everything he knew under the rug. Selig chose to protect the owners money, rather than protect the sanctity of the game. Witness what we have now, some of the most sacred of records in American sports are tainted and stained by drug abusers. These players probably didn't take the steroids to break records, that was simply a ancillary bonus for these guys on the road to making more money. I really don't think Bonds, Arod, McGwire or any others really thought to themselves, "Hey, if I take this stuff I could be the best player to ever play the game". I think more likely, they figured that if they took the stuff that they could put together a few great years, and hit the ultimate payday. Once it happened, the notoriety and adulation was addictive, so they couldn't stop. From there it was an epedemic, players trying to keep up with each other, and before you know it most of the players are trying something to get an edge.

The second issue is the broadening gap in the level of competition among the teams. I know Selig will say that there is a cap, with the luxury tax supposedly helping the lower revenue teams, but that is a convenient way of sweeping the issue under the rug again. Consider that 6 of the top 8 most valueable teams made the playoffs last year. The 2 that didn't were the Mets, who had the 2nd highest payroll, and the Cubs who had the 3rd highest payroll, so they sure tried.

Selig will point to isolated cases where lower income teams have made the playoffs(ie the 2008 Rays) as a means of proving that the current structure is working. In a very short period of time, teams can have young, homegrown talent come up and compete at a high level and have a short run at the playoffs, but compare that with the top revenue teams. These teams are loaded every year, consistenly competitive, and their fans are constantly engaged. The higher revenue teams will pay top dollar and take the top talent from the lower revenue teams and in a very short time, return that team to the bottom of the league for an extended period of time, where the top team stays on top. This type of activity ensures that the top 8 to 10 teams have a shot to win a championship every year, while the other 20 or so have no shot in most years.

Contrast that with the NFL where every team has as good a chance to make the playoffs as another. I am not saying that at the beginning of the season that every NFL fan thinks that their team will make the playoffs, but certainly the feeling is that the turnaround could be much quicker. The NFL has only 6 current teams that haven't made the playoffs in the last 5 years, with the longest current streak at 10 yrs(Detroit and Buffalo). MLB has 10, with 7 of those teams exceeding the longest current NFL streak, and the longest being a distant 28 years!!

The opposite argument states that the higher revenue owners are spending the money that they make, putting that money back into the team for the benefit of the fans. This is true, except for the fact that it is great for the fans of the top 8 teams, not for the game as a whole. Often this becomes a debate about the Yankees or Red Sox, and how they have the right to spend freely if they want. I agree, but I also think that the commissioner has an obligation to the fan base as a whole to put the most competitive product out there. Well run franchises will rise to the top, but then it will come down to people making franchises better, rather than the mighty dollar. The Yankees will always be able to spend more, they are worth $1.5 billion. They pull from a market that has 16 million people. I don't fault them that at all.

I fear that our younger generation will pay the price for the short sighted way the game is being run. No longer can you follow a player on your favorite team for years and years. These players are typically gone year to year. It is rarer and rarer to see a good player stick with a team for more than a few years. Secondly, you fear that your kids might actually follow and idolize a player today, when tomorrow it will be revealed that the player was using drugs, as baseball has failed to deter HGH users with blood testing to this day.

In Costas, you have an unbiased fan of the game. Costas shares many of the fans true love of the game of baseball, has the credibility with mostly everyone affiliated with the game, and seemingly would be able to make decisions in the best decision of the whole sport, not just one group. Costas possesses the skills to connect with the average fan of the sport, unlike Selig.


Since: Jul 10, 2009
Posted on: January 17, 2010 6:30 pm

Baseball needs Bob Costas as commissioner

Having Kirby Puckett as his assistant would be difficult considering he died in 2006

Since: Apr 30, 2008
Posted on: January 17, 2010 4:50 pm

Baseball needs Bob Costas as commissioner

I would make Cal Ripken Commissioner, he'd be perfect to clean up the game and get past this horrendous Selig era.  And he has respect.  The players would never respect a TV guy, I mean come on.  Selig was a used car salesman that's why he was never respected.  And his assistants should be Tony Gwynn and Kirby Puckett.

Since: Apr 30, 2008
Posted on: January 17, 2010 4:28 pm

Baseball needs Bob Costas as commissioner

I know at least 20 people better qualified than Bob Costas, geez come on people get real!  Costs is a fan - period.  My grandfather forgot more about baseball than Costas ever knew, and he doesn't look like a chipmunk either!  And my friends in the baseballk world are much better ambassadors and represnetatives of the game.  Costas has always been veryoverrated as a TV personality - this is a perfect example.  To the point peopl ethink he is wualified for something else. On one hand Selig wasn;t wualified either, but that;s the point we want to do better this time.  Come on folks lets talk about something important like how do wewc reate jobs and get illigeal immigrans out of here.  Selig was a joke, the game was severely tarnished on his watch with the steroids and he failed to address free agency properly and the result is financial imbalance and teams buying championships like Boston and the Spankees try to do every year.  This playoff in 2009 was the most boring baseball I have seen in years, well gee since that horrible '05 series when the white sox and astros got in there.  Jeter after his errors and hitting into double plays somehow gets another ring - the first one of his life without O'Neil and Martinez and Brosius and all those guys - and somehow he is a "leader" now?  It's hilarious.  How many years has he supposedly been the "leader" and they came up short?  Like 8? An dnow they finally win one and he is a "leader"?  Don;t ake me laugh any harder.  He's as much a leader as the stadium janitor.  But in today's ridiculous MLB, he gtets called a great player when he has no range at SS, led the AL in errors as a SS at least once, and is a singles hitter.  What is it like 85% of his hits are singles?  I'll take larry Bowa any day!  Or Cal Ripken, he was three times better at SS and that was a real leader.  Im sure they will find someone better than Selig, and certainly better qualified than Bob Costas.  Wow I can't believe someone actually suggested Costas, we heard this crap 10 years ago but it was mainly jokes, nobody really wanted him.  It got nowhere - like it should now.  These people suggesting him must be young and under 40 and don't remember Costas as the "little chipmunk that could" as he wa sknown for years whe he started on the networks.  They actually buy into all the bs hype that he is qualified.  He is a TV guy, that's it people.  A talk show host is really all he is qualified for.  And not even a good one, he is too annoying and pompous too be taken seriously on any subject.  Who's next on your list - Katie Couric? Unbelievable.

Since: Oct 28, 2008
Posted on: January 17, 2010 4:17 pm

Baseball needs Bob Costas as commissioner

I would have in this order,

1. Mike Greeenberg
2. Bob Costas
3. George Will

You have stated it well but I put Greeny first because he is just a fan! Most likely hit below the mendosa line in pee wee ball and Costas is kewl because he really knows the game. George Will is third because he should have been the commish 25 years ago and there would not have been a steroid era.

My humble opinion.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or