Blog Entry

Top 5 NFL Defensive Players of All Time

Posted on: February 2, 2010 5:20 pm
Oh boy, here we go -- this one oughta be F-U-N !!  With apologies to the Fearsome Foursome and the Purple People Eaters, on with the rankings:

1) Lawrence Taylor -- THE game changer....not only did he change every game in which he played, he changed the entire NFL.  Offenses had to account for the off-side rush thanks to LT -- and I can't imagine anyone ever in any era dominating more than Taylor.

2) Dick Butkus -- I doubt there has every been a more feared player than Butkus (although a certain #52 in Baltimore may beg to differ).  Granted I'm not old enough to have watched his every play, but every account tells of his greatness.  I'm a believer!

3) Reggie White -- Impossible to block, tenacious as anything, and meaner than a snake on Sundays -- off the field, not one of my favorites, but between the chalk, a true All-Timer!!

4) Ray Lewis -- Oh Ray-Ray -- the part of his game that goes competely under-appreciated is his intelligence.  Ray is the Peyton Manning of the D, and his skill set....are you kidding???  Never takes a play off -- and his true greatness lies with his innate ability to make every single teammate better.

5) Deion Sanders -- This was the hardest cut -- but Prime gets the nod over Ronnie Lott byjustthismuch.  Deion's stats are one thing, but his mere presence kept most offenses from even considering his half of the field.  Think about a D-Coordinator, all you had to do was put #21 on one side and swarm to the other.  How good do have to be for QBs to prefer to throw into double coverage than throw at you?!?!?  Prime Time!!

I'll list an 'Honorable Mention' group, in no particular order.  These guys are definitely worhty of consideration and mention:  Ronnie Lott, Derrick Thomas, Jack Lambert, Mike Singletary, Rod Woodson, Ed Reed, Michael Strahan, Ray Nitschke, Mel Blount, NightTrain Lane, and the aforementioned Purple People Eaters and Fearsome Foursome.  Hard to fit em all in -- the list is only 5 deep!

Let the games begin!

Since: Nov 12, 2006
Posted on: February 4, 2010 4:44 am

Top 5 NFL Defensive Players of All Time

Gotta disagree with #5.  Deion certainly is worth mentioning, but Ronnie was a game changer.  He could play at the all-pro level at either corner or safety, and was a major factor in the running game as well as the pass, and was the complete emotional leader of a great 49ers defense that doesn't get it's just deserts in the pantheons of the great Ds.   Deion could take away one player - the WR.   He wasn't exactly enthusiastic about taking on the sweeps.  And he simply wasn't the presence Ronnie was when it came to elevating every single player around him. 

Herb Adderly is another guy who deserves mention.  He was probably the single best player on a Packers defense that was among the best ever.  He then went on to start for the Cowboys in their early super bowl runs.

Hell, lots of guys you could make a case for.   Alan Page, Jack Hamm, Joe Greene, Bob Lily, and my personal favorite Deacon Jones who likely would still have the sack record if accurate stats were kept back then.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or