Blog Entry

MLB Facts & Rumors Managers of the Year

Posted on: November 9, 2010 10:27 am
Edited on: November 9, 2010 11:05 am
Ron Washington The major baseball awards will be announced next week, and the staff at MLB Facts and Rumors is making our choices this week. Today, David, Evan and Trent name their Manager of the Year selections. As with the BBWAA awards, a first-place vote is worth three points, second place two and third place one.

The outcome of the American League race is considered fairly clear, while the National League seems to have several possibilities. Manager of the year is always the toughest award to forecast, because voters value different things.


David Andriesen

1. Ron Washington, TEX
2. Joe Maddon, TB
3. Ron Gardenhire, MIN

Washington was lucky to even have a job after testing positive for cocaine last year, but he rehabbed his reputation while making a good team great. Much of the credit for the team’s easy, confident vibe goes to him, and his players are very loyal to him. Maddon used a bunch of kids to best a team with three times the payroll, and Gardenhire won his sixth division title in nine years.

Evan Brunell
1. Terry Francona, BOS
2. Ron Washington, TEX
3. Joe Maddon, TB

Francona somehow kept Boston in contention up until the final week, an amazing success given the team was besieged by injuries so much it became almost comical each time there was an injury. Factor in Tampa Bay finishing with 96 wins, New York with 85 and Toronto with 85, and you appreciate how stiff the competition was.

C. Trent Rosecrans
1. Ron Gardenhire, MIN
2. Ron Washington, TEX
3. Joe Maddon, TB

I really believe Washington will win it, and it's hard to argue against it. Many were shocked he made it out of spring training after word of a failed drug test surfaced, and then Washington led his Rangers to their first-ever World Series. Washington's players love him and he was rewarded with a new contract and will also win the award, but my nod goes to Gardenhire. Yeah, it seems boring that the Twins win year after year, and Gardenhire has a big part in that. I'm one of those that believes 70 percent of managing is stuff other than in-game moves, and that's where all three of these excel.


David Andriesen
1. Bud Black, SD
2. Bobby Cox, ATL
3. Brad Mills, HOU

A lot of ways to go here, but Black and Cox both won with teams that shouldn’t have. The Padres fell short of the playoffs, but they won 90 games when a lot of people picked them to finish last. The Astros stumbled horribly out of the gate, but first-year skipper Mills guided them to a 59-53 record after June 1 even with Roy Oswalt and Lance Berkman traded away.

Evan Brunell
1. Bobby Cox, ATL
2. Bud Black, SD
3. Dusty Baker, CIN

Cox did perhaps his finest managerial job in the offseason, taking a ragtag bunch of players and getting them into the postseason. San Francisco got a lot of credit in the playoffs as "outcasts" and "misfits" ... the Braves were the more misfit team.

C. Trent Rosecrans
1. Bud Black, SD
2. Dusty Baker, CIN
3. Bobby Cox, ATL

To be so close to the playoffs with only one legitimate hitter, Black deserves more than just a trophy. Will Venable was the only hitter on the Padres besides Adrian Gonzalez with 400 plate appearances and an OPS+ better than 100. Everyone expected the Padres to fade long before they ever did, and a lot of that to go to Black. Baker did a hell of a job in Cincinnati as well, and who wouldn't like to see Cox win it in his last year? But Black is the most deserving.

MLB Facts and Rumors AL Manager of the Year
Ron Washington takes this one in a rout, tallying eight points to four apiece for Maddon and Gardenhire. It'll be a surprise if he doesn't win the BBWAA award.

MLB Facts and Rumors NL Manager of the Year
Black gets the nod with eight points, as Cox finishes with six. It will be interesting to see whether a guy who didn't make the playoffs wins the real award, which is not common.

-- David Andriesen

For more baseball news, rumors and analysis, follow @cbssportsmlb on Twitter or subscribe to the RSS feed.


Since: Sep 28, 2006
Posted on: November 9, 2010 11:21 am

MLB Facts & Rumors Managers of the Year

LOL Brunell picked Francona, that guy is such a Boston homer, it's amusing.  None of the others even had him in their top 3.  What was so great about Francona's job?  He had injuries, wow, so did every team in baseball. The Phillies lost Ryan Howard, Chase Utley, Jimmy Rollins 3 times, Carlos Ruiz, Placido Polanco, Ryan Madson, Brad Lidge, JC Romero, Jamie Moyer, and more players to injuries, so if you are using the injury argument, then the Phillies manager should have won your NL award and not Bobby Cox.

With the wildcard team in their division, Manuel still got the Phillies to the NL East crown and 97 wins with all the injuries they had, including 2 former league MVPs, his closer, main set up man, and a perennial all-star second basemen. 

Don't get me wrong, I don't think Manuel is a good manager and I don't think he should be manager of the year.  I actually think Charlie Manuel is a lousy manager and the Phillies win despite him, not because of him, but the point is if you use the injury argument, then you should use it in the NL too.

My vote would be:

AL - Has to be Ron Washington, followed by Gardenhire and Maddon. 

NL - Bud Black, Bruce Bochy, Dusty Baker, Bobby Cox should all get some votes, I'd go Black personally because the Padres stink and they almost made the playoffs.

To vote Terry Francona is a joke. 

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or