Play Fantasy The Most Award Winning Fantasy game with real time scoring, top expert analysis, custom settings, and more. Play Now
Blog Entry

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

Posted on: August 10, 2011 12:55 pm
Edited on: August 10, 2011 5:18 pm

By Evan Brunell

The Toronto Blue Jays stand accused of stealing signs by utilizing a man dressed in a white shirt out in the bleachers, ESPN Magazine reports.

During a 2010 game early in the season, the White Sox's bullpen noticed a man dressed in white 25 yards to their right raising his hands every time there was an offspeed pitch. They examined his patterns and figured out he was trying to tip the batter off as to what pitch was coming, four sources from that bullpen revealed. While they couldn't figure out how the man was getting the information on the pitches, the correlation was too strong, which was backed up the next day when the players stood at home plate and on the mound to see how visible the man would have been to the batter. They found that without the batter even needing to move his head or change the direction of his eyesight, the man would clearly have been visible.

"It's premeditated," one of the AL players said, "as if the guy was a sniper trying to find the best position to make a shot."

When the bullpen noticed the man giving signs, they called into the dugout to warn the rest of the team. For the rest of the game, Chicago used multiple signs even with the bases empty and made their displeasure known to Jose Bautista the next inning.

"It's not too [f------] easy to hit home runs when you don't know what's coming!" the player yelled at Jose Bautista (pictured). The slugger, who hammered 54 home runs in 2010 after a previous career high of 16, confirmed the argument. "We know what you're doing," the anonymous player added. "If you do it again, I'm going to hit you in the [f------] head."

Bautista unsurprisingly denied any knowledge of stealing signs.

"First of all, I don't even know how you can do that," he said. "And second of all, it's obviously something that's not legal in the game. We do not cheat."

Catcher J.P. Arencibia also denied the reports, taking to Twitter to do so.

"Just read the dumbest article on ESPN about us getting signs?" he tweeted. "I'm hitting 200 and we get signs at home, that makes sense? #clowns." A followup tweet added, "Teams/pitchers need to accept when we kick their ass in the rogers centre n not give excuses... Looks like we had verlanders signs #nohitter."

More on Sign-stealing
However, the man in white departed his seat after the incident. That doesn't mean there's a link to stealing signs, but the evidence has been piling up against Toronto. Some players on that same team noticed the same man signaling during the last series of the season in Toronto back in 2009, so the team passed on doing anything about it. It's not the first, nor the last, time that teams have been suspicious of Toronto, though.

One of the players told Yankees' outfielder Curtis Granderson to be on the lookout for the man in white, but Granderson was unable to sight anything during a game where he served as DH and monitored the outfield while the Yankees were on the field. Still, New York started taking precautions by using multiple signs to signal for a pitch even when men are not on base. The Red Sox were also sighted using multiple signs during a June game earlier this season.

"Could be," manager Joe Girardi said when he was asked if the Blue Jays were stealing signs from outside the field. Obviously, if you feel like it's coming from somewhere else besides a player on the field, yeah, I do have issues with that."

Statistical information does bear out a possible unnatural advantage at Rogers Center, with Baseball Prospectus' Colin Wyers, showing statistical deviations that Wyers believes is too significant to be random chance.

Wyers compared performances by players in Toronto with that player's performance in all other parks, finding that Rogers Centre added .011 home runs to a player's production, making the stadium one of the top three percent of home-run parks since 1950. This is up from .002 from 2005 to 2009.

Oh, and only the Blue Jays benefited as their home run on contact rate was 5.4 percent at home, compared with four percent on the road and an AL average of 3.6. To be sure, some of these home runs were due to Bautista's breakout, a resurgent season from Vernon Wells, and more -- but another curious aspect is that many Toronto hitters in 2010 exhibited massive home/road splits -- including Bautista and Wells. Despite a poor on-base percentage of .312 (fifth-worst in baseball), Toronto was able to score the ninth-most runs in baseball with 755 on the backing of the highest isolated power (slugging percentage minus batting average) of a team since 1954. The flip side is that the Jays only batted .269 on balls in play, the lowest in baseball by far.

"Major League Baseball has never received a complaint from any club about sign stealing in Toronto, and this is first [we've been] made aware of it," a MLB spokesperson said.

The ESPN report by Amy Nelson and Peter Young is damning, but as is written:

By themselves, these numbers are circumstantial evidence. Unsupported by data, the four players' accounts might describe a scheme of uncertain impact. And without proper context, the Yankees' decision to mask their signs could be chalked up to paranoia. But together, the numbers, the stories and the actions indicate one certainty: Every pitch to a Blue Jay in Toronto is worth watching.
GM Alex Anthopoulous, who will speak about the topic in further detail at 3:45 p.m. on Wednesday, denied any sign-stealing to the magazine. "That never happened, will never happen, not even a possibility," he said . "If it did happen, we'd be winning a lot more games at home … I think it's a nonstory because no one ever has picked up the phone and called me about it. It's never been an issue, and I would expect them to do so if it was."

For more baseball news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeonBaseball on Twitter or subscribe to the RSS feed.

Since: Oct 22, 2007
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:45 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

Regarding the people saying the Jays would have a much better record if they were stealing signs........first, you have to play in other parks as well......second, they're hitting is obviously a lot better in Toronto according to the numbers, but the sign-stealing isn't going to help their pitching, which is awful (7th worst ERA in MLB right now)......finally, it's possible to steal signs and still have a mediocre record if you are a bad team to begin with and the Jays aren't so good to begin with.

Are they stealing signs? I have no idea, but it certainly isn't out of the realm of possibility.

BTW, I heard Bill Belichick was sighted in Toronto recently during the lockout. Tongue out

Since: May 14, 2008
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:39 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

ask Jo-jo. he's an ex jay with no reason now for loyalty. wait maybe the csis will kill him befor he can answer

Since: Dec 21, 2006
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:34 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

pitchers have catchers paint their nails white so they can see them better, but some guy in the outfield seats can see whats coming in time to signal the batter as to what is coming?

why arent the jays leading the league in hitting and running away with the division?

stupid accusations.    

Since: Jul 17, 2011
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:31 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

and we are still a .500 team lol

Since: Feb 4, 2008
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:26 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

Anyone who actually believes this in their right mind is stupid

Since: Feb 4, 2008
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:24 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

These are totally rediculous accusations.  To say that a whole team is regurally stealing signs is absurd, and totally unfounded.  Who else besides whiny Girardi has come out "against the Jays sign stealing?"  No one, so this is totally rediculous

Since: Aug 20, 2006
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:20 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

The man in white in the outfield at Blow Jay games huh?  Outstanding investigative work to 4 letter word network "the magazine."  If a batter can see some doughnut vendor in right center field allegedly sending signs, I`d say his eyesight is beyond good enough to pick up breaking pitches. Pointless article to file under the ongoing covert game MLB has always had of stealing the signs.  Next thing we`ll hear is Joey Bats is a HR spy. Enough four letter network go cover NFL training camps.

Since: Dec 28, 2010
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:12 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

If they stink this bad every year and are stealing signs then is friggin funny.....The Blue Jays are doormats and everyone knows it. steal away you still can't win!! LOL!!!!!!!Cool

Since: Nov 3, 2006
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:11 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

A couple more of Arencibia tweets:

What's next? Man on CN Tower edge walk was seen relaying signs to bluejay hitters.. #clowns
That's y I love hockey... Say or do something stupid #dropgloves #pro

Since: Dec 4, 2007
Posted on: August 10, 2011 2:11 pm

Blue Jays accused of stealing signs

 They are being accused of something a little bit more than typical sign stealing.  It is one thing for a coach or a player on the field to pick up signals or tendencies.  It is an entirely different issue if you are employing people to pick up signs from the stands and relay them to the player at the plate.


The ESPN article has some interesting statistical analysis; more than what is listed in the above article, on teams and player’s homerun differential at and away from Toronto.  Not sure if it proves anything but it is pretty glaring.


Not sure if it is true or not been there has been a lot of smoke around this subject for a while now.  

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or