Blog Entry

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

Posted on: August 25, 2011 11:39 am

By Matt Snyder

Friday will mark exactly one week since the Cubs announced they had fired general manager Jim Hendry. Cubs' chairman Tom Ricketts asserted he wants to find a GM with a strong track record, an analytical background and with an emphasis on player development. The latter two criteria would seem to point to someone opposite of Hendry -- who had a recent history of big contracts and trading prospects for veterans. The former criterion points to an experienced general manager, not a first-timer.

So many names have been tossed around for what is absolutely an attractive job. Now, this is where the Cubs haters all jump up and down and start screaming about how bad the Cubs "suck." No one in his right mind can deny nearly any general manager would want this job, though. As the Cubs' general manager, one would have the capability to work with a payroll that dwarfs any other in the NL Central. One would have a rabid fan base that is absolutely desperate for a World Series, so residing over one would be the ultimate sports accomplishment. Also, in the present, the Cubs have more than $50 million falling off the payroll next season, so there's a chance to basically start over. No ballclub can compare to the resources the Yankees have, but there's no reason the Cubs can't eventually be the Red Sox of the National League -- and there is no Yankees in the NL.

With this in mind, you'd have to figure almost every name is initially in the mix with few exceptions. And it sounds like that's true. Let's sum up the recent rumors:

ESPN's Buster Olney said earlier this week that Red Sox GM Theo Epstein "could" be a name for the Cubs to consider. What Epstein did under John Henry's ownership group is something similar to what the Cubs want under the Ricketts family, so it makes sense. Of course, Epstein also has very strong Boston roots and is currently in a better situation than what he'd be taking over with the Cubs. Unless he wants a fresh, new challenge or is simply tired of competing with the Yankees, it doesn't seem like he'd have any incentive to leave. For what it's worth, Henry emailed Red Sox reporters about the speculation:

“This kind of speculation happens from time to time to successful GMs and managers,” Henry wrote ( “The Cubs have one of the best presidents in baseball. I think this shows how highly regarded Theo is by the media and baseball in general.”

• Speaking of AL East powers, a "long-odds" option is Ricketts calling Yankees general manager Brian Cashman and trying to convince him to head to Chicago as a package deal with manager Joe Girardi. Cashman's contract does expire at the end of the season. ( This is total speculation on my part, but there's not much more Cashman could accomplish with the Yankees and he could very well be tired of ownership forcing his hand (a la the Rafael Soriano contract this past offseason that he didn't want to give). Also, keep in mind Girardi had two different stints with the Cubs as a player and was born and raised in Peoria, Ill. This scenario makes sense, if Ricketts could convince the two to leave New York. But, again, this was reported as a long shot.

• More AL East: Rays executive vice president Andrew Friedman has been named by pretty much every reporter in the business as a possibility. Friedman should be incredibly attractive because of what he's helped do with the Rays. He now has experience building a farm system basically from the ground up and in Chicago he'd be able to sign and keep higher-priced players. He also wouldn't have to worry about attendance or moving. ESPN's Olney wrote about Friedman's tough decision this coming offseason.

• Another small-market guy who might enjoy getting to have a few extra payroll dollars for once is A's general manager Billy Beane. According to Susan Slusser of, Beane "might consider an offer" if the Cubs came after him. Slusser also reports the Cubs are "expected" to talk to Beane. Another reason Beane might want to bail on Oakland is how long it's taking to get the A's stadium situation resolved. Beane is signed through 2014, but the report indicated owner Lew Wolff would let Beane out of the deal if he wanted.

Dodgers GM Ned Colletti is an option, despite that he's a bit more old-school than Ricketts seemed to say he preferred. In the case of Colletti, one reported benefit would be that he'd bring Hall of Famer Ryne Sandberg back to the organization as the Cubs' manager, the job which Sandberg didn't get last season. (

• On the flip-side of much of the above notes,'s Jon Heyman reported that the big names -- Cashman, Beane, Epstein, Friedman -- are not likely to take the job. Heyman instead reports it's going to come down to Rick Hahn and Josh Byrnes. Hahn is the vice president and assistant general manager of the White Sox and is considered a true up-and-comer by several in the business. In fact, several outlets have ranked him as the top GM candidate in baseball (excluding current GMs). The issue, of course, is he doesn't have experience as the top dog. Byrnes is the vice president of baseball operations for the Padres and has previously been the GM of the Diamondbacks. He had a hand in putting together the 2007 playoff team, but when things fell apart afterward, he was fired in 2010.

• According to Danny Knobler of, Cashman is "very unlikely" and the Cubs might have to pay something like $10 million a year to pry Epstein away from Boston.

So there you have it. Several huge names, a hot-shot up-and-comer and lots of things we don't know. We need to keep in mind that initial interest in either side doesn't necessarily mean a job offer -- or acceptance of the job offer -- is coming. We also have to keep in mind that guys presently on the job, especially those in the middle of pennant races, will publicly deny interest no matter what.

Ricketts will likely want a new GM in place very quickly once this season ends, but until then -- about five weeks -- we'll continue to see the names swirl.

For more baseball news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnBaseball on Twitter or subscribe to the RSS feed.

Since: Sep 14, 2006
Posted on: August 27, 2011 2:48 pm

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

What you're not the best at: grammar, spelling, and punctuation.


Since: Jan 13, 2007
Posted on: August 27, 2011 2:13 pm

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

Cubs fans are some of the greatest in sports,they are loyal to the core and deserve a winner and they also deserve a new stadium,Wrigley is a neat old stadium but is past it's prime and they should build a nice new stadium for the Cubbies and their fans and put a winner on it's field.

Since: Dec 23, 2009
Posted on: August 27, 2011 1:31 pm

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

I don't know who you root for, probably tired of loyal Cub fans taking over whatever stadium you go to no matter their record.

Since: Aug 20, 2006
Posted on: August 27, 2011 12:45 pm

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

What a joke...the Cub$ job is such a good one!??  Maybe Obama since he`ll need a job real soon. Keep losin Cubs, your the best at it.

Since: Feb 17, 2007
Posted on: August 27, 2011 11:05 am

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

Friedman and Byrnes would be the better options, lesser known names without the high asking price of the Beane,Cashman, and Epstein trio; but having similar resumes. Altho nomatter who gets the job, Ricketts has got to give his man atleast 5 years to implement the player development side of the plan. And as we all know, the odds of that happening are very slim.

Since: Apr 1, 2011
Posted on: August 27, 2011 9:43 am

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

Chuck Norse

Since: Dec 16, 2009
Posted on: August 27, 2011 9:08 am

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

Friedman from Tampa is probably their best option. I'm not a Cubs' fan, but its a move that makes a lot of sense. He has experience building a farm system, and now, building a winner on the field. I'm not sure what will happen if realignment happens, but, the chance to do some work, not having to compete with big money teams like New York and Boston, will also be very attractive. Also, if he moves, there's a chance that some of the pieces may migrate in the future. Joe Maddon seems like he'd be a perfect NL manager.

Since: Jun 10, 2010
Posted on: August 27, 2011 3:05 am

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

Wow what are the chances... I just heard a story on the radio here in Australia about the world's oldest woman - she just celebrated her 115th birthday somewhere in the USA! She'd probably remember the last time the Cubs won it all...

Since: Jun 10, 2010
Posted on: August 27, 2011 2:09 am

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

Yep the top pic is Epstein, left, and Beane, right.

I hope things go well for the Cubs in the next few years, because the fact is that there may only 5 people on the entire planet that can remember the Cubs last World Series win. They'd have to be close to 110 years old!

Since: Nov 25, 2008
Posted on: August 27, 2011 1:46 am

No shortage of rumored names in Cubs' GM search

Brian Cashman!  This guy has thrown away $200 million dollars of Yankee money and he doesn't even have a pitching staff.  Hire the Phillies GM, he seems to know what he is doing.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or