Blog Entry

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?

Posted on: January 16, 2012 10:35 am
Edited on: January 16, 2012 10:46 am

By Matt Snyder

As we continue the ongoing series of Would You Rather Have, we'll tackle a PED-themed version today. As every baseball fan surely knows by now, Ryan Braun failed a drug test and is facing a 50-game suspension for the beginning of the 2012 season, unless his appeal is upheld. Jose Bautista, on the other hand, has never failed an MLB drug test. However, I'd wager a hefty sum that if the Braun news first broke as "an unnamed All-Star slugger has tested positive for a banned substance" that the overwhelming majority of people would have guessed Bautista was the culprit.

In no uncertain terms, I think it's unfair how many people -- and it's not just fans, some media members are in on the witch hunt -- seem to believe that Bautista could not possibly get better at age 29 without having cheated. I've written about it multiple times (like here) but it drives me crazy. His body type hasn't changed one bit. Then again, neither has Braun's.

Whatever the case may be, that's why I connected these two superstar corner outfielders. Fair or not, one of these players has failed a drug test and the other has the suspicions of the majority of baseball fans. Since they are both big-time power hitters and play a corner outfield position, the debate works. Let's dive in.

The case for Bautista

Last year at this time many people believed the slugger's breakout campaign in 2010 was a fluke, but then Bautista went out and had an even better all-around season. He was once again punished for not playing on a team in contention in the MVP voting, finishing third. This time around it was much more egregious, considering the batting average and on-base percentage gains made. Bautista led the AL in home runs, walks, slugging percentage, OPS and Wins Above Replacement, version (he actually tied Justin Verlander there with 8.5).  Bautista's 181 OPS-plus led the majors and is insane (if you aren't familiar with the stat, it's ballpark adjusted and means Bautista's OBP plus slugging percentage was 81 percent better than the league average).

Would You Rather Have
Also impressive, Bautista walked more times than he struck out, an amazing feat for a slugger of his caliber. Albert Pujols regularly does it, but not many other power hitters ever do.

While neither outfielder here is going to approach a Fielding Bible Award any time soon -- both rate out poorly in advanced defensive metrics -- Bautista has a nice arm in right field, racking up 13 outfield assists in 116 games last season (he played 25 games at third). Using the eye test, too, I'd much rather have Bautista in the outfield than Braun.

Oh, and Bautista isn't facing a 50-game suspension.

The case for Braun

The 2011 NL MVP, Braun had a spectacular season with 33 homers, 111 RBI, 109 runs, 33 stolen bases and led the NL in slugging percentage and OPS. His OPS-plus was 166 and WAR was 7.7, for comparison's sake. Since winning the NL Rookie of the Year (after playing just 113 games) in 2007, Braun has been one of the best hitters in all of baseball.

Again, neither is a very good defender in terms of range or saving runs for his pitching staff, but one thing Braun does very well is not commit errors. He's only made six errors in the past four seasons combined. So while he won't get to as many balls as, say, Brett Gardner, Braun is sure-handed when he does.

If you wanna use age, Braun isn't that much younger than Bautista. He does have a three-year lead, as he turned 28 in November while Bautista turned 31 in October.

Our call

You can call me petty, but I'm going with Bautista until -- if ever -- he fails a drug test of his own. I'm pretty sure I would have leaned that way in October, but it would have been incredibly tough. That's irrelevant now, though, because Braun's name is tainted, even if temporarily, while Bautista's is not.

Vote away, and I have to say, I'm very interested to see how this one goes down. Lots of different issues in play, so let's hear those opinions. Please do keep in mind this is moving forward. Even if Braun misses 50 games this year, he's signed with the Brewers into his late 30s.

Fan Vote:

For more baseball news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnBaseball on Twitter, subscribe to the RSS feed and "like" us on Facebook.

Since: Jun 3, 2010
Posted on: January 16, 2012 1:52 pm

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?

Looks like someone didn't read the second paragraph. Or the multiple other times I said Bautista hasn't tested positive.

Since: Sep 28, 2010
Posted on: January 16, 2012 1:42 pm

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?

Matt, you realize that by lumping Bautista with Braun you are furthering the conspiracy theory against Bautista. Cheap journalism. How about a more clever comparison,  would you rather have 112 games of Ryan Braun or 162 games of Alex Rodriguez. Both have well-founded connections to PEDs. Comparing Braun to Bautista is like comparing Roger Clemens to Tim Lincecum. Comparing someone with well-founded ties to PED use, to someone who has no ties to PED's, but is much smaller than the typical Ace pitcher or homerun hitter.

Since: Oct 16, 2011
Posted on: January 16, 2012 1:27 pm

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?

Before the suspension I would have said Braun, but I refuse to ignore or excuse any more steroid use. So I would chose Bautista.

Since: May 2, 2007
Posted on: January 16, 2012 12:38 pm

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?

Brauns size reminds me of another former Brewere Robin Yount.  Tall and skinny but strong.   Honestly I believe that all the sports are giving their players something....and trying to find the next best thing to help the owners investments play better and longer and of course make them more money.  My belief is their all taking something.  Every single one!  The system is working together...just like it always has been.  But were behind the scenes and will never truly know the truth....which is sad bc I really wanna know the truth.

Since: Jan 8, 2012
Posted on: January 16, 2012 12:17 pm

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?

I choose to have Ryan Braun on my team. Because he is on my favoite team. He's been such a fun player to watch ever since his "Rookie of the Year" season. And I will support him and the Brewers even if his suspension is upheld. That 50 games is going to be a drag. I wish the leak had only stated an "an unnamed All-Star slugger has tested positive for a banned substance." This has been an upsetting 5 weeks.

Since: Mar 1, 2009
Posted on: January 16, 2012 11:42 am

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?


Since: Jan 30, 2011
Posted on: January 16, 2012 10:52 am

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?

Bautista plays RF AND 3rd base and doesn't take banned substances. BAUTISTA

Since: Jan 16, 2012
Posted on: January 16, 2012 10:52 am
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Nov 22, 2011
Posted on: January 16, 2012 10:44 am

Would You Rather Have: Bautista or Braun?

You can pretty much guarantee that Bautista will have better stats through the first 50 games of the 2012 season.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or