Blog Entry

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

Posted on: February 15, 2012 2:34 pm
Edited on: February 15, 2012 3:17 pm
By Matt Snyder

We're just a few days until all 30 teams will have had pitchers and catchers report to spring training. Just like any true baseball fan, I'm giddy with excitement.

Just like with anything, the major-league level sport could use some improvements. While MLB was tied with college football for the second-most popular sport in a Harris Interactive poll, the demographics show that baseball is in danger of drastically losing popularity, as the study showed most baseball fans are older than 50. Now, obviously that gives a solid 20-year window before doomsday really hits, but baseball still needs to be cognizant that growing the younger audience is key for long-term growth.

That means baseball needs to be a little more Blackberry/iPhone and a little less rotary phone. Remember, not all change is bad. At one point in time, it was a home run when the ball bounced over the fence. I wonder what the "purists" thought when they changed it to a ground-rule double? If you wanna call me names and claim I'm not a purist, below you'll find several targets. But make no mistake about it, I'm trying to find ways to make the game more exciting for the next generation. In this century, things move faster and people have less time to pay attention. Adapt or die, as "Billy Beane" said in "Moneyball."

So here are nine things I'd change about baseball in order to make it better suited for the next generation. Feel free to add your own ideas in the comments section and make this an interactive discussion.

1. Put in a pitch clock. I'm dead serious -- put it up like basketball has a shot clock. Not only is it, you know, a freaking rule that pitchers have to throw a pitch within 12 seconds of getting the ball, but this would add some drama for many younger fans. The best reason, obviously, is that the umpires would actually be forced to enforce the rule that they so often just ignore. The rulebook (Rule 8.04) states "The 12-second timing starts when the pitcher is in possession of the ball and the batter is in the box, alert to the pitcher. The timing stops when the pitcher releases the ball."

Has anyone ever watched Josh Beckett (pictured right, surely finding a way to avoid throwing a pitch within the first 20 seconds he has the baseball) pitch? I bet he's had outings where he never once threw a pitch within 12 seconds. It makes me feel like I'm watching Steve Traschel all over again ... well, except that Beckett's actually good. I'm not blaming Beckett. The umpires let him do it and he's not alone at all (Vicente Padilla also comes to mind). Just using him as an example.

2. Get someone with some common sense to rework the blackout rules. I've covered this before, so just click through and see how amazingly stupid it is. Bud Selig needs to hire someone to do something about it. Hell, I'll throw my hat in the ring and volunteer.

3. More Saturday day games. Sunday is fine, because everyone plays a day game with the exception of the ESPN Sunday Night Game. And I understand weekday games needing to be at night. But on Saturday, we usually get about three afternoon games and the rest are at night. This is the best time for families to get their kids to the game and many families don't like to have their kids out at the ballpark late Saturday night for many reasons. Why not just start the Saturday games at 1:00 p.m. local time? Especially when school is in session. I also wouldn't mind seeing Game 3 of the World Series falling on a Saturday afternoon. It's not like Saturday night is prime for TV ratings.

4. Expand replay to everything but balls and strikes. Why does someone like Ron Kulpa or Jim Joyce have to be burdened with an honest missed call for the rest of his life? The Joe Wests of the world are in the minority here, as most of the umpires are honest, hard-working guys who just want to get the call right. As the fast motion and without the benefit of multiple camera angles, calls are going to get missed. The insane thing is we have the technology to show they were wrong within seconds, yet don't allow the umpires to use it. Why not just have a centralized review office at the MLB headquarters where one replay official watches every game? You don't need to give the managers challenges or have the entire umpiring crew go underneath the stadium for 15 minutes. Let's just use some common sense and start getting every call correct. It's very possible.

5. Make the DH universal. I've written about this before and the reasons are very simple. First of all, it's insane that a professional sports organization has a different set of rules for two leagues, especially when the leagues play each other during the regular season and decide a champion by facing each other in the World Series. So you either have to take the DH away from the AL or add it to the NL.

And here's where the purists freak out and start calling me names, since I say add it to the NL. I wouldn't be averse to taking it away from the AL, just as long as the same rules are applied to both leagues. But adding to NL makes more sense here. The first reason is that the players union would obviously never allow the DH to go away, as it would cost jobs to veteran players. The second reason is it's better for offense, and we're trying to get kids to watch the games, remember? Plus, pitchers suck at hitting. We're supposed to be watching pro athletes at their best ... also realize teams don't have to use a DH. So if the Marlins want to bat Carlos Zambrano, for example, more power to them. Just don't come with this "baseball is meant to be played both in the field and at bat" junk. Pitching is a specialization. You don't make a quarterback play defense in football anymore.

6. Out with penny-pinching owners. Among the many complaints I'm waiting on in the comments section is that I didn't mention a salary cap. Here's the deal: With baseball's system, players are under team control for six years. That's a lot longer than other sport. And with the revenue sharing system, many small-market clubs are making hefty profits. Take 2010 ( hasn't released the 2011 numbers yet). Did you know three teams lost money that season? The Red Sox, Mets and Tigers. Large markets. Guess who had the highest operating income? The Padres, who made almost $40 million. And after the season they traded superstar first baseman Adrian Gonzalez for prospects because they couldn't "afford" to sign him long term.

The problem with the difference in payrolls is mostly on these tight-fisted owners from the old boys club of owners. Just over a week ago, Joe Sheehan of wrote an excellent article about how owners like the Royals' David Glass, Athletics' Lew Wolff, Pirates' Robert Nutting and Blue Jays' Rogers Corporation are pocketing millions upon millions while crying that they can't afford high-priced talent (though I'd probably cut the Jays out there, to be fair).

The money is there, so it should be spent on improving the on-field product, not the bottom line of a billionaire. The fans of these teams and others deserve better. There should be more George Steinbrenners -- who would rather lose money while the team wins than vice versa -- not less.

7. Shorten spring training. The always-entertaining Brandon McCarthy, A's starting pitcher, wrote the following about spring training last week for's Hot Clicks: "It's so, so, so LONG: It's six weeks of practice and pretend games. It just never seems to end. It's like our version of Oregon Trail. By the time camp ends, someone's died of Dysentery, there's a bunch of new kids that have been born, and your feet are killing you."

He's right. How many fake games do you need? Cut out two weeks and ...

8. Start/end the season earlier. The reasoning is two-pronged. The first prong is that baseball in cold weather isn't near as enjoyable as baseball in warm weather. With the World Series creeping up on November, there are just too many chances for weather issues during the most important games of the year (remember Game 5 of the Phillies-Rays series). If spring training was shortened, the season could begin the third week of March. Yes, weather is bad for the first several weeks of the season in many parts of the country, but the scheduling is easier then. There are enough warm-weather and retractable-roof teams to cover the first month. The games aren't nearly as important as the playoff games and in the playoffs you don't get to choose the venue (how about a Minnesota vs. Chicago World Series in the first week of November? Shivers everywhere). So you'd start the playoffs the third week of September and the World Series would be over in the middle of October. The second prong is you cut away time in competition with the NFL. Sorry, the NFL is a monster and there's no changing that in the near future, so don't compete with it anymore than necessary. Two less weeks of facing off against the NFL would be great for the sport of baseball.

9. Blackball Jose Canseco. Oh wait, I guess he claims that already happened. Whatever, just please go away, Jose. Take Lenny Dykstra with you. #4TRUTH. Yes, I realize this doesn't have to do with MLB, but I just can't stand these guys. The game is much better without having them around it.

For more baseball news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnBaseball on Twitter, subscribe to the RSS feed and "like" us on Facebook.

Since: Feb 16, 2012
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:26 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

Since: May 22, 2007
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:24 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

Some really good suggestions, and some really bad ones too.

1.  Pitch clock - I think the umpires just need to start warning the pitchers.  There's mention of the rule, but not what the penalty is for not abiding by it.  Is it a balk?  Does the next pitch just count as a ball?  Not know what the rule is, I would say, 3 warnings, 4th and YOU"RE OUT!

2.  Don't care about black out rules.  I live in Boston!

3. Absolutely.  I hate the Saturday night games.  There's nothing like sitting in the bleachers, soaking up the sun, and drinking too much on a Saturday afternoon at Fenway!

4.  Nah.  That would defeat the purpose of the pitch clock, to speed up the games.

5.  I'm kinda torn 50/50 on this one.

6.  Don't disagree, but this is America.  How can you force an owner to sell a baseball franchise?  Plus, a low budget market is a low budget market.  Spend on the scouting and bring in the talent through the farm.

7.  NO WAY!  Spring training is essential to the economy in Florida, and part of Arizona.  The tourism spring training generates is good for baseball and the community.  Plus, if you take away the revenues, that's going to lead to more run down, and less fan friendly spring training facilities.  ST is also a great venue for fans to get up close and personal with the players.  Again, NO WAY!!!

8.  Start the season earlier?  Why, so we can have more games PPD-snow.  Doesn't make sense.  It gets cold in October, but I don't recall any playoff games getting snow.  It defintely snows in Boston late March, and in Chicago, Cincy, Cleve, Minny, etc.....  Not a good idea.  Bad idea.

9.  Enough with the black listing.  It's time to do the right thing and induct Pete Rose!!!!!!!


Since: Jul 30, 2009
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:23 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

LOVE LOVE change #1! Longer than 12 seconds but absolutely great idea. Selig do this now if you're reading.

Since: Jul 30, 2009
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:22 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

LOVE change #1 but longer than 12 seconds. Love it, great idea. Baseball is so great to watch when someone who operates quickly on the mound is throwing like a Verlander but when you get a slower pitcher it can be agonizing. Selig pay attention to change #1!!

Since: Feb 20, 2008
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:16 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

To fix the problem of owners not spending enough money..... why not take away their compensation from the league if they don't win a certain amount of games?  There would be incentive right there to put a winning club on the field at all costs.
No longer would the Padres receive revenue sharing from the Yankees (and other teams) if they didn't win a minimum number of games.  In other words, make it so that a team that tanks the season will not benefit monitarily.

You should not get rewarded for not performing.  This isn't a welfare state.  Is Bud Selig channeling his inner-Obama? 

Since: Apr 26, 2009
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:12 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

Anyone who complains about the how long a game takes is not a real baseball fan. No time limit on any of it EVER.

The DH needs to go away period. It was not an original part of the game and needs to go away.  

I am all for shortening spring training and starting the regular season sooner.

I don't have kids so I don't care what time games start.

I wish instat replay had never been thought of in any sport.  Games should have the human impact in every way.  

I don't understand how anyone complains about the time length of games on one hand but wants instant replay for everything. Replays increase game time length so there is absolutely no logic in wanting both.  Just stupid. 

Since: Feb 20, 2008
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:09 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

I understand the argument.  Really, I do.  And its the same in every sport.  "If the franchise put a quality product on the field, they would have a larger fan base".

But the problem comes down to the basic rule of economics, Supply & Demand, and Physics, What Goes up Must Come Down.

Look, there are 30 teams all vying for 1 goal.  Or, hopefully they all have the same goal of winning the World Series, or Lombardi Trophy, or NBA Championship.  But only 1 team gets to win that every year.  So mathematically, you would win one every 29 years.  Which means, you would have 28 years, on average, of not reaching your goal.

Then take into consideration the teams with multiple Championships over that 30 yr period, and suddenly the average jumps from 28 years between your titles to 48 years.  Realistically, teams can't win without other teams losing.

There will ALWAYS be teams that finish in last.  Not every team can compete.  Some franchises stay in the hunt for 10-15 years straight.  But that means some franchises are not in the hunt for the same amount of time.  You can't have complete parity.  The NFL is the closest major sport to complete competitive parity.  But still, it has its teams that compete yearly, and those that don't.  Look at the New England Patriots and Cleveland Browns.  Would you rather just have a revolving door of a new champion every year, so planned and scripted that you can book it in 29 years that you will have it again....... but no sooner? 

The world of sports has winner and loses.  Both annually, and by decade.  For every dynasty, there is a similar and opposite non-dynasty.  If that makes any sense.  For every Yankees there is a Royals.  You want to end that?  Then you end sports as we know it.  Might as well watch a soap opera or the WWF.  Excuse me, WWE. 

Since: Mar 9, 2007
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:04 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

Never been a game in the history of sports that the outcome relies more on luck.

The NFL far and away is the most luck driven sport on the planet. Its a 16 game crap shoot which relies heavily on keeping players healthy in a violent sport. One unlucky wrong move and a hard tackle can ruin an entire team's season (Brady in 08). After the madness teams play do-or-die matchups where one bad quarter ends the season. After all of that its a one game championship, god forbid if its goes to OT, then they flip a coin to determine who gets the ball.

Flipping a coin for possession is way less luck driven than baseball though.

Since: Jan 6, 2012
Posted on: February 16, 2012 3:02 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

I agree with Saturday afternoon games as positive start. A pitch clock won't work once runners are on base. A pitcher has to hold the ball longer to prevent base stealers, allow for pickoff, defensive rotations etc. When no one is on base, I'm all for it. As for the DH, universally kill the DH, and while you're at kill interleague play. It's a waste of time. As for penny pinching owners, just enact a minimum spending amount. Owners are wise to control costs, but you should at least a minimum amount to maintain fan interest. I'd like Spring training to start 2 weeks earlier and the season 2 weeks earlier. The World Series should never go into November. 

Since: Feb 16, 2012
Posted on: February 16, 2012 2:52 pm

Nine ways to improve Major League Baseball

I didn't read all the comments so this suggestion might not be the first. In reference to suggestion number 5, have the DH in both leagues but make the rule so you can't use it for the pitcher. This way we can have all the gamemanship of the National League, the increased offense of the American League with the increaased value in defense oriented players. Everyone wins - the players union gets the spots for veteran hitters AND increased value of defensive oriented players, the fans get more offense and we get to see the managers actually manage a baseball game instead of a beer league softball game. If need be, add a 26th spot on the roster.  

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or