Play Fantasy The Most Award Winning Fantasy game with real time scoring, top expert analysis, custom settings, and more. Play Now
Blog Entry

Positional rankings: kickers

Posted on: July 5, 2010 3:38 pm
Edited on: July 5, 2010 3:58 pm
 
Josh Katzowitz and Andy Benoit resume their debate, this time taking a look at the top five kickers in the NFL.

D. Akers, the one kicker we agree on (Getty) Josh Katzowitz’s top five


5. Sebastian Janikowski, Raiders

4. Matt Prater, Broncos

3. David Akers, Eagles

2. Stephen Gostkowski, Patriots

1. Nate Kaeding, Chargers


Kickers might get less respect from fans than other position players, but hardly anybody shares the same kind of glory as a kicker after nailing a 52-yard game winner, and hardly anybody can feel the jeers after missing an easy 31-yarder that caused his team to lose.

With that, we start with Kaeding. A little bit of the shine is off him because of the three missed field goals in the 17-14 playoff loss to the Jets last year. But he’s still the most accurate kicker in NFL history (87.2 percent coming into this season). Gostkowski took over for former Patriots K Adam Vinatieri, and he made people instantly forget how good Vinatieri was for New England. Need proof? Check out this Facebook group (ignore the fact there are only 45 members).

You might be averse to 12-year veteran Akers, because people still remember his slump from 2005-07. But last year, he had one of the best seasons of his career and was the best kicker in the league. Prater has bounced around the league a bit, but he found his footing last year. You might not like my Janikowski pick. But he’s got one of the league’s strongest legs and he’s coming off the most accurate season of his career.

Andy Benoit’s top five

5. Olindo Mare, Seahawks

4. Rian Lindell, Bills

3. David Akers, Eagles

2. Ryan Longwell, Vikings

1. Rob Bironas, Titans


Regarding Kaeding being the “most accurate kicker in NFL history”, is it me or have there been about 10 different “most accurate kickers in NFL history” this era? Anyway, I can’t put Kaeding on the list for the same reason you shouldn’t.

Many people forget that Janikowski was a first-round draft pick. In that sense, he has been an underachiever. Gostkowski doesn’t have enough pressure kicks to his name yet. My first memory of Prater is when he admitted to a lack of confidence in 2008. Maybe he got his confidence back in ’09, but I will need at least three years to shake that first memory.

As for the guys on my list, I went with experience. Mare is a booming kickoff specialist - plus he made his last 21 field goals in ’09. Lindell is consistent even in the Buffalo wind (I know, I’m re-using my Brian Moorman analysis). Akers doesn’t quite have the range he once had, but he’s still reliable under pressure. Longwell was 26/28 last year. Bironas is the best long distance kicker in the game (5/6 from 50+ yards last season, range up to 60 yards).

Josh’s rebuttal

It’s surprising that we only have one kicker who made both of our lists. I thought about putting Bironas on my list, but I just couldn’t pull the trigger. Lindell might be consistent, but he was pretty crappy from outside 40 yards last year (58.3 percent). Could be a fluke, I suppose, because he’s normally better than that from long range. Mare has been pretty up and down in his career, but he is coming off two fantastic seasons, so I can see your point there. Even though our lists are almost completely different, it’s hard to get too worked up about it. I like my list. I like your list. Everybody’s happy.


Andy’s final word

To me, recognizing a great kicker is like recognizing a great free throw shooter. How nervous are you when a kicker lines up to attempt a game-winning field goal against your team? In a casual, unofficial way, that gives you some indication of how great a kicker is (or how great you think he is).

(Other positions: Safety | Cornerback | 3-4 Scheme Outside Linebacker | Punter )


--Josh Katzowitz and Andy Benoit

For more NFL news, rumors and analysis, follow @cbssportsnfl on Twitter.



Comments

Since: Sep 28, 2006
Posted on: July 6, 2010 6:38 am
 

Positional rankings: kickers


All I can say about this article is, REALLY?!  Why waste the time or copy?
There is plenty to write about and discuss regarding the NFL; the difference in opinion about place kickers between two writers is NOT on that list.  Hey CBS how about some news out of training camp or how the Commissioner is over-tinkering with the league of maybe rank the top special teams units across the league???

Don't get your panties in a bunch, it's really not a big deal. They are ranking all the positions if you haven't noticed, and these are two positions. It's a change of pace story from labor negotiations, so go with the flow.



Since: Nov 30, 2009
Posted on: July 6, 2010 3:26 am
 

Positional rankings: kickers

Where is Phil Dawson? The guy is almost automatic.



Since: May 26, 2009
Posted on: July 6, 2010 1:28 am
 

Positional rankings: kickers

Umm, Matt did NOT MISS an extra point last year (the year before yes).  30-35 last year (85.7%), no misses from 20-29 yards out and one miss from over 50.  Sure, he had a tough year the year before (started out great but faded badly).  Last year, I thought he made great progress (we can all see why it was time for Elam to go).  His kickoffs are outstanding and he is only getting better.

Jason was money for so long it's easy to understand how you may be bitter.  However after watching the whole season last year, Matt was one of the bright spots.  Seeing Jason hang on too long was just sad.

I can see how he made the list, I would want him kicking for my team (he does!). 



Since: Jul 12, 2008
Posted on: July 5, 2010 7:58 pm
 

Positional rankings: kickers

All I can say about this article is, REALLY?!  Why waste the time or copy?
There is plenty to write about and discuss regarding the NFL; the difference in opinion about place kickers between two writers is NOT on that list.  Hey CBS how about some news out of training camp or how the Commissioner is over-tinkering with the league of maybe rank the top special teams units across the league???


draper1997
Since: Apr 16, 2009
Posted on: July 5, 2010 7:44 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator




Since: Dec 31, 2006
Posted on: July 5, 2010 6:38 pm
 

Positional rankings: kickers

What self respecting journalist would ever list Matt "I can't make a kick" Prater as one of the best in the league? This is the same guy Bronco fans spent 2 years wondering why he was even still on the roster. He missed 14 field goals the past two seasons, and 1 extra point last season. Not to mention that before 2008, he missed 3 of the 4 field goals he attempted. So in 4 seasons he has managed to keep a job due to his kick off distances. This is a kid who has made just 128 of the 146 kicks he's attempted. I was personally shocked to see that he even stayed on the roster after his 08 campaign. He missed 10 kicks that season. Maybe I'm just picky, or maybe it's cause I've watched David Akers, and Jason Elam on my two respective teams for years before this but if I'm a coach I would definitely not put up with Prater missing that many kicks his first season kicking for me. This season will prove if he truly is ready to take a step towards being a great kicker by having another solid season, but I'm not counting on it.


The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or CBSSports.com