Blog Entry

Peyton 'doubtful' for Week 1, won't practice

Posted on: September 5, 2011 11:31 am
Edited on: September 5, 2011 12:02 pm
Posted by Will Brinson

Peyton Manning's been the story of the NFL preseason thus far, thanks to a complicated neck surgery he underwent 15 weeks ago and the slow process which which he's recovered.

It became a bigger story on Monday when the Colts announced that not only has his rehab "slowed," but that Manning won't practice leading up to the Week 1 game against the Texans and will be listed as "doubtful" on the official injury report.

"During the last week, the rate of improvement in Peyton’s rehabilitation process slowed," the Colts said in a statement released by the team Monday. "Over the weekend Peyton experienced soreness in his back. It was originally thought to be a normal reaction to his rehabilitation regimen. When the soreness persisted, the Colts medical team decided to initiate diagnostic tests and to consult with a number of specialists around the country who have been involved in Peyton’s case from the outset. That process continues.

"As a result of the most recent development the doctors have decided that Peyton will not practice. His participation therefore, in Sunday’s game versus Houston will likely be doubtful. We will update his playing status as required by NFL policy as the week goes on."

The Colts also added that "the end date" of Peyton's recovery "is unpredictable" and that "it serves no useful purpose to speculate about hypothetical outcomes."

Which is precisely what I'll do right now: it doesn't look good for Peyton playing.

Colts Crazy Preseason

That seems insane, but, hey it's been a busy day for Indy, who also announced that new gameday consultant Jim Tressel would serve a non-suspension suspension for the first six games of the season.

And it's still entirely possible that Peyton does play in Week 1 against Houston. Here's the logic for why he won't: Indianapolis has 16 games they'll play this season, and while the first one against Houston is extremely important, it won't decide the fate of their 2011 season.

Additionally, the newest backup in town, Kerry Collins, has seen the Texans a time or two in his career. And while he's just 3-4 against Houston (which probably won't impress at least one of his wide receivers) he has completed 53.8 percent of his passes for 1,550 yards in seven games while throwing for six touchdowns and nine interceptions.

Those aren't Peyton Manning numbers, of course, but they're also not Curtis Painter numbers either.

For more NFL news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnNFL on Twitter and subscribe to our RSS Feed.

Since: Sep 18, 2006
Posted on: September 5, 2011 11:44 am

Colts: Peyton's rehab 'slowed,' won't practice

If Andrew Luck performs to expectations, they won't get him no matter what picks they try to package up. If you have the #1 pick of the draft, and you really think you've got the next Peyton Manning available, what's a fair price for that? He will make you a perennial super bowl contender by himself! How many first rounders would a team have to give up to get someone to pass on that? 3? 4?

Since: Aug 11, 2007
Posted on: September 5, 2011 11:44 am

Colts: Peyton's rehab 'slowed,' won't practice

i think kurt warner is available.

Since: Feb 11, 2008
Posted on: September 5, 2011 11:39 am

Colts: Peyton's rehab 'slowed,' won't practice

Time for a successor to be drafted. While Curtis Painter has improved (there was really nowhere but up from his rookie showing), he isn't a long term solution. Between Painter and Kerry Collins (see 2006 when he came in to play for the Titans after sitting on the farm for all of training camp for how that will work), Andrew Luck is looking like a possibility in the draft next year even if the Colts don't have the #1 pick. It might be time to mortgage some picks to get a guy who has been compared to the guy he would be replacing.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or