Blog Entry

Good news: Tebow better than Eli to start career

Posted on: November 6, 2011 11:18 am
Amazingly, it could be worse for Tim Tebow(Getty Images)

Posted by Ryan Wilson

The Broncos' Tim Tebow will face the Oakland Raiders in the Black Hole Sunday. Not ideal circumstances for a young quarterback coming off a horrific performance last week. In fact, depending on how he plays, this could be the 2010 first-round pick's last chance at a starting gig this season. First-year coach John Fox, who inherited Tebow from Josh McDaniels, doesn't seem particularly thrilled with any of his options at quarterback, and more than anything, he sounds tired of answering questions about Tebow.

“The goofy thing is, it’s almost like if he doesn’t have success it will be anybody’s fault but his. It’s almost that kind of polarizing thing,” Fox told the Los Angeles Times' Sam Farmer last week. “They’ll say it could be his supporting cast, or the type of plays. At the end of the day, we are what we are. We’re doing everything we can to win, and we’re finding out about a young quarterback, good, bad or indifferent.”

This comes days after an anonymous Lions defender called Tebow "embarrassing" and "a joke." But not everybody thinks the former Heisman winner is a sideshow and a pushover.

Raiders coach Hue Jackson, the man who gave up a first- and (likely) a second-round pick for Carson Palmer, isn't taking Tebow lightly.

“He came in here last year and played really well, and I expect he’ll come here again with the same thought,” he said, via the Oakland Tribune. “The guy has talent. I’ve never questioned that. He can throw. He can run. And he’s on the opposing team, so we have to do everything that we can to get him under control.”

Raiders defensive end Jarvis Moss was also asked about Tebow, his former teammate at Florida.

"He’s a good athlete, man,” Moss said. “He’s a strong dude. He can definitely hurt you with his legs.”

The phrase "damning with faint praise" immediately comes to mind but Moss is right: Tebow isn't much of a passer, despite that being a big part of the job description. But former NFL quarterback Kurt Warner, who now works for NFL Network, made this comparison on Sunday's NFL GameDay Morning: Eli Manning vs. Tebow through their first five NFL games.

Wins-Losses: Manning, 0-5; Tebow, 2-3
Completion percentage: Manning, 44.4; Tebow, 48.3
Passing yards per game: Manning, 126.4; Tebow, 196.8
TD-INT ratio: Manning, 3-7; Tebow, 7-4
Passer rating: Manning, 44.8; Tebow 74.8

So there's your silver lining, Broncos fans. Of course, Denver has other issues -- the offensive line and defense chief among them.

Either way, Warner says not to panic. "I think the verdict is yet to be determined (on Tebow), I think everybody needs to relax," he said.

Warren Sapp, Warner's NFL Network colleague, couldn't help but ask: "Were those really Eli's numbers?"

After a loss to the Lions last week, Tim Tebow and the Denver Broncos look to rebound as they prepare to take on the Oakland Raiders on Sunday. Jason Horowitz and's Pat Kirwan preview this matchup, Watch the game at 4:05 PM ET on CBS.

For more NFL news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnNFL on Twitter, subscribe to our NFL newsletter, and while you're at it, add our RSS Feed.

Since: Apr 1, 2007
Posted on: November 6, 2011 1:18 pm

Good news: Tebow better than Eli to start career

Numbers are just that. One thing about numbers is they lie. A person can find numbers to use in an argument most every time. That still doesn't mean Tebow looks like an NFL quarterback. The man has a unique style, one that made him a great college QB. The numbers will tell you numerous successful college QBs didn't translate into successful NFL QBs. Nothing against them, they just didn't have what it takes to make it in the NFL. The jury's still out on Mr. Tebow. He may or may not have success in the NFL. Personally, I don't think he gets the ball out quick enough to become a really good NFL passer. In that respect I'd have to say Manning may not have had as good of numbers as Tebow, but he was a visually much more impressive QB. I think Warner would have to agree with that, too. I wish Tebow the best. But, I think a switch of position is in the cards for Tebow's NFL future.

Since: Aug 19, 2006
Posted on: November 6, 2011 12:01 pm

Good news: Tebow better than Eli to start career

Seriously, a 75 passer rating for a young qb's first five starts really isn't too bad.  It will be interesting to see if Denver insists on making him a pocket passer 90% of the time, which isn't his strength right now, or whether they integrate more of his strengths into the offense, taking advantage of his running ability and preference for lining up in the shotgun.  The Panthers are committed to Cam Newton and are turning him loose.  While I agree that Tebow is not the passer Newton is, I'm not yet convinced that the Broncos are really committed to helping Tebow succeed.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or