Blog Entry

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

Posted on: December 12, 2011 12:44 pm
Edited on: December 29, 2011 5:31 pm
By Will Brinson

As is tradition, when an NFL coach is "relieved of his duties," like Todd Haley was on Monday, we'll plow through a list of potential candidates to replace said coach.

The Chiefs search is a little different though, because it's widely assumed that Scott Pioli will chase a "Patriots Guy," which is someone with, duh, connections to the Bill Belichick coaching tree. The success of the next Chiefs coach will likely determine whether or not Pioli continues at the helm of the Chiefs, and thus it would be surprising to see him go in a different direction and hire someone he wasn't truly confident could succeed.

Leave your suggestions in the comments.

Romeo Crennel

Crennel's going to be running the team for the final three games of the 2011 season, and it's possible that Scott Pioli would be comfortable with Crennel as the full-time coach going forward. After all, Romeo was the defensive coordinator for championship-caliber teams in New England when Pioli was working for the Patriots, and Crennel's got head-coaching experience with the Browns. That wasn't the most successful tenure, but, hey, neither was Bill Belichick's first gig in Cleveland either.

Josh McDaniels

McDaniels was canned in Denver and took over as Offensive Coordinator for the Rams this past season. His star has fallen mightily from the 6-0 start with the Broncos in 2009 to the 2-10 effort the Rams have put forth so far in 2011 and the regression St. Louis has shown on offense. McDaniels real downfall in Denver, though, was his personnel decisions (although you could argue he made some smart calls after all) and he wouldn't have to worry about that in KC. At the very least, he'll warrant strong consideration as offensive coordinator for his old boss Pioli. (Added bonus: Haley hates him!)

Kirk Ferentz

My buddy Nathan and I have a running joke about how Ferentz is the hottest coaching candidate on the planet every year (seriously: his name gets dropped into every single coaching search at every single level of football)  but never even considers leaving Iowa. This is actually one gig that could truly entice him to make the jump to the NFL, though, as he and Pioli go way back to the early 90's when they worked together in Cleveland and Baltimore. Plus, you never know -- he could be the AFC's version of Jim Harbaugh!

Jeff Fisher

Fisher's going to be one of the hotter names in most coaching searches this offseason, because of all the success he had in Tennessee, and the fact that he ultimately just left because he and Bud Adams couldn't really agree on Vince Young. Or something. The Chiefs have a lot of cap room and their roster actually resembles the construction of his Titans teams the last few years he was there.

Bill Cowher

Little-known fact about all NFL coaching searches: you must include Cowher's name or else it's not complete. Also, Cowher coached in Kansas City for two years and apparently loves it there. So I'm changing my tune from earlier when I didn't include Cowher. I still don't think he's the answer here, though, because Pioli isn't going to just hand over a pile of player-personnel power to Cowher and it's widely believed that's something he'll require.

Rob Ryan

Ryan's refusal to cut his hair and stop running his mouth prior to games has hurt his reputation as a strong candidate to succeed at the head-coaching level, but he's done good work with the Cowboys defense this season and his track record as a defensive coach is pretty damn impressive. He also worked for the Patriots (linebackers coach for three years) and given how much Rex Ryan's succeeded in New York, it's hard to ignore the possibility of success by the other sibling. On the other hand, given the tenuous nature of Pioli's relationship with the fiery Todd Haley, he may want to avoid a big personality with this hire.

Brian Daboll

Daboll was brought to the Dolphins in 2011 to revamp the Fins offense, and while Miami isn't the most high-powered offense in the NFL, the rejuvenation of Reggie Bush and the late-season success of Matt Moore is impressive. Daboll's offenses haven't ever finished in the top half of the NFL -- he was quarterbacks coach of the Jets in 2007 and 2008 and offensive coordinator of the Browns in 2009 and 2010 -- but he hasn't exactly been working with the same personnel you might find on the 1999 Rams or anything. No head coaching experience probably makes this a dealbreaker, but he could warrant consideration as an assistant.

Eric Mangini

But, no, seriously. Mangini's been known to have interest in returning to the NFL and as recently the past month he's been rumored as someone who might come in as a consultant for various teams. He's currently working for ESPN (and is actually doing a fantastic job, in my humble opinion), and may have burned bridges with comments he made about the Patriots while working as the Jets head coach. But people forget he did a pretty good job there of rebuilding the Gang Green before struggling in a rebuild job in Cleveland.

Pat Hill

Hill, the recently-fired Fresno State coach, is a bit of a darkhorse, especially since "getting fired by a non-BCS school where you've been since 1997" isn't usually the career step taken before "getting hired to take over an NFL team." But again, he's part of the Belichick tree, so it's impossible to count him out completely.

For more NFL news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnNFL on Twitter, Like Us on Facebook, subscribe to our NFL newsletter, and while you're add it, add our RSS Feed.

Since: Dec 5, 2011
Posted on: December 12, 2011 8:58 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

I think  . . . .

Jeff Fisher !

Since: Feb 2, 2007
Posted on: December 12, 2011 8:57 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

If the Chiefs could afford any of those three names, they'd never have hired Todd Haley in the first place. None of those guys is leaving the college game to take over a program in as sorry a condition as the Chiefs. Besides, LSU and Alabama could beat the Chiefs with the teams they have now.

Since: Dec 18, 2010
Posted on: December 12, 2011 8:37 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

Saban LIES     &
nbsp; and already has shown he cannot win as an NFL coach

Since: Dec 12, 2011
Posted on: December 12, 2011 8:27 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

What about Gregg Williams?  I understand that he grew up in Kansas City area and has family there.

Since: Apr 12, 2008
Posted on: December 12, 2011 8:13 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

Is this a joke?  You must be kidding.  The Chiefs will not talk to any of these.  Not even one.  Wether it by their choice or the coach's choice.

Since: Jul 28, 2011
Posted on: December 12, 2011 8:05 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Mar 29, 2008
Posted on: December 12, 2011 7:19 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

The Best Coach from the Patriots (Besides Mr. Bill) would be the other Mr. Bill as in Offensive Coordinator Bill O'Brien. The guy is excellent with his play calling and has no trouble correcting Hall of Famer to be Tom Brady when Brady makes mistakes.

Since: Aug 6, 2010
Posted on: December 12, 2011 7:15 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

Im not a Haley fan but he was doing a good job I believe. He cant control injuries, he lost he best player on offense and the best player on defense. Hard to come back from that, not to mention losing cassel las well.

Since: May 31, 2007
Posted on: December 12, 2011 7:10 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?


There are several advantages to doing it mid-season once you're sure that the playoffs are out of the picture.  The first is that you get a head start on reaching out to possible candidates, finding out what it would cost/take to attract them to your organization, etc.  Even if you are undecided, getting the jump on the research and interviews means you'll be in the position to hire first, and thus get whichever guy you end up wanting most.

The other advantage comes from having a potential candidate on staff.  By giving a guy like Crennel a shot for the last few weeks, you can get a look at how he handles himself.  Obviously, you can't judge his whole system... there's no time for him to completely change an offensive or defensive system, make major personnel changes, etc.  But you do get to see how he manages the game, how the players respond to him, what his habits and preparation skills are like, and so on.  It can help you either eliminate a candidate (if you don't like what you see), or get a valuable hands-on look at him.

Plus, if a coach starts to know they're a lame duck, they could conceivably check out or cause trouble.  That depends upon the situation and people involved, of course, but it's not unheard of.  In that sort of situation, it's best to get them out the door ASAP.

With respect to the Chiefs, specifically, I'm guessing item #2 on the list here is their biggest motivation.  They probably figured there was nothing to be gained by keeping Haley around for a few games... and every reason to see how Crennel might work out in the driver's seat.

Since: Dec 20, 2008
Posted on: December 12, 2011 6:23 pm

Who will replace Todd Haley in Kansas City?

The name not mentioned here is Brian Shottenheimer. Marty is still close with the Hunt family, brian wants to get out of the Sexy Rexy shadow, and talk about getting a head coaching job where there are still a lot of great players.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or