Blog Entry

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

Posted on: March 6, 2012 9:28 am
Edited on: March 6, 2012 12:40 pm
Is Nicks, our top free-agent offensive lineman, done hoisting Brees? (Getty Images)
By Will Brinson

Leading up to the start of free agency on March 13, we're compiling lists of the best 2012 NFL free agents by position. These are the offensive linemen.

It's not the sexiest position in the NFL -- just ask Andre "C-Cup" Smith -- and there's a feeling in the NFL these days, whether it's right or wrong, that offensive line is becoming a fungible position. It's OK to laugh at that idea, because a few years ago, wide receiver was the same way. It'll shift back and forth in the next few years. Right now, you'll pay a nice price to land a wideout and offensive linemen are relatively cheap.

Some of the guys on the list below won't be cheap however. There's a pretty nice group of offensive linemen hitting the market this year, and teams might be wise to avoid trying to race in the free-agent market and focus their efforts on improving protection.

1. Carl Nicks

Breakdown: Nicks is probably the best guard in the league, and it doesn't help that his teammate, Jahri Evans, signed a $56.7 million deal for the next seven years. Especially since Nicks wants more money. With Drew Brees franchised, the Saints are essentially forced to let Nicks and top wideout Marques Colston both hit the market and good luck bringing Nicks back. He's the only guy who can hurt the guard-related stock for Stanford's David DeCastro.
Potential Landing Spots: Saints, Cowboys, Chargers, 49ers

2. Chris Myers

Breakdown: Honestly if Meyers left it would be a) a huge mistake for the Texans and b) a big surprise. Everyone talks about Mario Williams as the guy they need to re-sign, but Meyers is substantially more valuable to what they do (especially with the defensive personnel vs. the offensive personnel). Houston's offensive line is by far and away the most underrated in the NFL and while Eric Winston is the anchor, Meyers is the leader. I'd like to think that Houston won't let him walk, simply because the AFC South window is too big not to keep making a run at another division title.
Potential Landing Spots: Texans, Packers, Ravens

3. Jared Gaither

Breakdown: Gaither was a supplemental draft pick with the Ravens in 2007, washed out, went to the Chiefs and then looked finished in the NFL at an early age. But he was a big factor in revitalizing the Chargers run late in the season; after Marcus McNeil went down, Philip Rivers was offered no protection until Gaither came into town. The Chargers want to keep him, but this is a very shallow class for free-agent tackles, and Gaither could pull in good money on the market. He's got gobs of talent and is still young, but keeping him motivated is a concern.
Potential Landing Spots: Lions, Chargers, Cardinals, Vikings, Rams

4. Ben Grubbs

Breakdown: Grubbs, the Ravens 2007 first-round pick, made the first Pro Bowl of his career in 2011. He's a free agent only because Baltimore's had to use their franchise tag on Ray Rice and couldn't commit to the guard. The Ravens still want to re-sign Grubbs, and that could happen between now and March 13 when free agency begins. Working in the Ravens favor is the deep nature of this crop of free-agent guards.
Potential Landing Spots: Ravens, Bengals, Giants, Bears, 49ers

4. Scott Wells

Breakdown: Wells and the Packers are in the middle of a headed non-discussion about a new contract. Wells believes he deserves big money, and the Packers believe he deserves the type of money that a shorter, 31-year-old center would get on an open market. But Wells isn't just any center; he's proven his worth in working with different quarterbacks in Green Bay and helping to develop Aaron Rodgers. Wells made his first Pro Bowl in 2011 and has missed just one game since 2006. He won't want to leave Green Bay but he also won't take less than he's worth. It wouldn't be surprising to see him move closer to Tennessee (he's from there and played for the Vols in college) either.
Potential Landing Spots: Packers, Texans, Broncos

5. Demetrius Bell

Breakdown: Bell's been playing football for less than 10 years, but he's clearly quite good at it. Or at least good enough to keep being named the Bills left tackle. The seventh-round pick out of Northwestern State could come back to Buffalo, but if there are teams in need of offensive line help, there's a good chance he'll bail. The offensive line market is odd this year, in that it appears to be guard and center heavy. The tackles aren't exactly stacked and that could result in a nice deal for a guy like Bell.
Potential Landing Spots: Lions, Bills, Chargers, Cardinals, Vikings, Rams

6. Evan Mathis

Breakdown: Mathis hasn't started 16 games since coming into the NFL. But he's coming off easily the best season of his career and has said he'll take a discount to remain with the Eagles under the tutelage of Howard Mudd. Mathis said he'd work for "$20 and a pizza," but the reality is he got paid the league minimum last year, and at 30, he'd be insane not to maximize his money-making ability.
Potential Landing Spots: Eagles, Saints, Seahawks, 49ers

8. Geoff Schwartz

Breakdown: Schwartz played all over the line for Carolina in 2010 before missing all of 2011 with injury. It'll be interesting to see Ron Rivera's coaching staff handles the offensive line: Schwartz and Jeff Otah are holdovers from a previous regime and might not necessarily stick. But Schwartz, at 25, would be a nice, versatile and discounted signing for someone who needs help and depth across the line.
Potential Landing Spots: Giants, Bills, Panthers, Seahawks

9. Dan Koppen

Breakdown: You know what's weird? Everyone's willing to toss out the "system" word as it relates to anything with the Patriots quarterback but don't bother discussing how their offensive line, which features a pretty cohesive unit, helps Tom Brady's success. Whatever, it's fine. That's the "Patriot Way." But Koppen isn't going to get the franchise tag like fellow lineman Logan Mankins and he stands to make more money for a team that needs a center.
Potential Landing Spots: Packers, Ravens

10. Jake Scott

Breakdown: The good news is this: Scott played for an offensive-line monster in Mike Munchak. Munchak consistently creates cohesive offensive units that over-produce relative to their value. But the bad news is that Scott's 30 (not too old) and if you bring him into another organization, he's not going to have that same Titans cohesiveness. Is that overplayed? Yeah, maybe. But Scott will have bigger questions when it comes to Chris Johnson's production in 2011, whether that's fair or not.
Potential Landing Spots: Titans, Saints, Eagles, Seahawks


Jeff Backus, Nick Hardwick, Vernon Carey, Anthony Collins

For more NFL news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnNFL on Twitter, Like Us on Facebook, subscribe to our NFL newsletter, and while you're add it, add our RSS Feed.

Since: Dec 1, 2009
Posted on: March 8, 2012 4:27 pm

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

CentralMass3, as to why OCs seem to be relatively undervalued today, I suspect that it has to do with the increased importance of the passing game. In that, the only critical role for the center is to contain moster NTs. How many of those are there in the league? Very few. So, unless you have to play one twice a year, or in a conference championship game, containing DTs and DEs and 3-4 OLBs is more important.

Since: Dec 1, 2009
Posted on: March 8, 2012 3:59 pm

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

I hereby nominate Saints GM Mickey Loomis as the 2012 winner of the Worst NFL Executive of the Year. He's hip deep in the pay-for-pain scandal. He's deeply P.O.'ed his franchise QB, who is very likely the most respected man in the league not naned Robert Kraft. By doing so, he kicked away the better half of the best guard tandem to play in the league in almost 40 years. Any day now, I expect to read that he's been indicted for bid rigging that led to the collapse of the levee system in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. Meanwhile, he's still walking about with his chest puffed out, seemingly as clueless about his own incompitence as Matt Millen was.

Since: Jun 25, 2009
Posted on: March 7, 2012 3:33 am

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

I just have this feelin way down deep inside that Nicks and Brees are collabarating on a deal that the Saints cant refuse. They need each other. Saints Super Bowl bound!!!

Since: Jan 1, 2007
Posted on: March 6, 2012 10:44 pm

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

Evan Mathis was OK for the Eagles.  He's no Todd Herremans that's for sure.  I'd take him back, but.....I'd rather see Todd back at LG  Scott Wells and Dan Koppen---I don't know the Packers track record with centers, but Damien Woody can tell you all about the NE philosophy.  Woody's done well with the Jets, et al.  But why are the centers so undervalued relative to the other O-L slots?  Is Jared Gaither related to Omar Gaither?  I think yes---something about the mention of the Ravens.  This guy never lived up to his draft position, IMO.  I wonder if the Saints ran a bounty program for guys like Carl Nicks too?

Since: Apr 28, 2008
Posted on: March 6, 2012 10:06 pm

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

SweetLou: I'm with you, only I'm a Chiefs fan. I mean, our line is atrocious, and we aren't interested in any of these guys? The one position we used to need most was a tackle. Then we let Waters go, and now we need a guard badly. Lilja gets mowed over. Hey, how 'bout Nicks? And guess what, KC has more cap space than anybody in the league. So why isn't KC a candidate to improve the team at the position that needs it most?

Since: Mar 6, 2012
Posted on: March 6, 2012 9:07 pm

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

if the hawks landed mathis, schwartz, or scott i think we can safely say thats a top 4 offensive line

Since: Jan 5, 2012
Posted on: March 6, 2012 3:24 pm

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

The Cowboys need another owner, coach and QB. Nicks and Grubbs will not help, their arrogance prevnts them from winning.

Since: Jan 19, 2012
Posted on: March 6, 2012 2:34 pm

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

The Cowboys need to sign Nicks or Grubbs badly

Since: Dec 22, 2011
Posted on: March 6, 2012 10:31 am

2012 NFL Free Agency: Offensive line rankings

It's funny that the Chicago Bears are listed on only one of these guys and its a Guard. They should be listed on all these guys because their isn't one spot on the OL that is a solid starter. Maybe Garza. They need a major upgrade on this line!

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or