Blog Entry

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

Posted on: September 10, 2010 11:43 am
Edited on: September 10, 2010 11:44 am
Posted by Royce Young

Fall is here, hear the yell, back to school, ring the bell ... The NBA season is right around the corner, and NBA training camp starts in just a few short weeks. To get you ready for the NBA season, we've put together 25 pop quizzes. Pencils ready? We continue our Pop Quizzes with this question...

Who is winning Rookie of the Year? John Wall, Blake Griffin or someone else?

There's the Madden Curse, the Curse of the Billy Goat and the the Curse of the Sacred Buffalo. And for the past couple years, there's been the Curse of the No. 1 Overall Pick.

Of course there's Greg Oden who missed his entire 2007-08 rookie season because of microfracture surgery on his knee. Derrick Rose escaped and had a nice 2008-09 rookie campaign, but then Blake Griffin fractured his patella and sat out all of 2009-10.

Maybe it's a trend. Or maybe like the other "curses," it's just a combination of coincidence and bad luck.

But not often do you have a season with two No. 1 overall picks playing their rookie seasons together. John Wall and Blake Griffin are the last two top picks in the NBA and they are both entering their official rookie seasons. Griffin was the clear-cut favorite for Rookie of the Year last season before he got hurt, but his injury opened the door for Tyreke Evans to snatch the award. But with how electric Evans was last season, who knows, he might've won the award anyway.

So coming into 2010-11, we have two obvious favorites. But will one of them win it? If so, which one? Or if not, who else could slip in and grab the Eddie Gottlieb Trophy? Here are the favorites and then two sleepers:


Blake Griffin, Clippers - It's easy to forget what a freak of nature Griffin is. It's easy to forget his non-stop motor, his talent, his ridiculous ability and his awesome athleticism. He sat out last season so it's easy to forget that he was pretty much a consistent 20-20 threat at the University of Oklahoma and that he averaged almost 30 points and 15 rebounds in the NCAA tournament. It's easy to forget that he was the most dominant college big man since Tim Duncan.

But he's healthy and he's hungry. Those are two very, very scary things for those that dare challenge him head-to-head. Griffin has an other-worldly work ethic and he's spent the last 15 months waiting to get a crack at the NBA. He's ready to go and the Clippers need his services. He'll get big minutes and he'll likely put up big numbers.

John Wall, Wizards
- In terms of pure flash, skill and NBA talent, it's hard to top John Wall. He just has some sort of allure to him that makes him must-see. And that sort of thing goes a long way in determining Rookie of the Year. Wall has "it," whatever "it" is.

He's going to struggle some though, especially early on. He's being put in charge of a fairly bad Wizards team from the get-go. He's going to have to manage being a scorer and a distributor, something really good point guards don't figure out most times until their third year. He will struggle at times. He'll turn the ball over. He'll miss open shots. And he'll likely get frustrated. But Wall will have flashy games, good numbers and most of all, that Derrick Rose like draw that just makes him fun to watch.

DeMarcus Cousins, Kings
- A lot of really smart analysts agreed in June, DeMarcus Cousins was the most talented overall player in the draft. He's the most NBA ready player and most capable of stepping on the floor and contributing this second.

But for Cousins, it was a between-the-ears thing.

Assuming his head is on straight and he's focused, Cousins is an absolute force on the post. In the first three games of Vegas summer league, he was nearly unguardable. He was a walking double-double. But then he got tired, lost interest and his numbers dipped severely. If we see the good Cousins consistently, he's a legit contender. If he wavers, he might not even make an All-Rookie team.

Evan Turner, 76ers - During summer league, Turner looked lost. He looked confused. He looked as if he wasn't sure of himself, his abilities or how he was supposed to fit in.

But remember, summer league.

Turner nearly averaged a triple-double at Ohio State last season. His issue will be something he doesn't really control. New 76ers coach Doug Collins will have to figure out where he's supposed to play. Is it point? At the 2? At the 3? Once that gets settled and Turner fits into his role, he should be a guy that finishes with quality numbers on a team that likely won't be very good.

Greg Monroe, Pistons - Maybe Monroe would be better suited in the "sleeper" category. He was drafted seventh overall and isn't set up to garner a ton of attention or playing time early on in Detroit.

But Monroe's skills are unignorable. He passing beautifully out of the post, has terrific footwork and rebounds better than people give him credit for. Right now, he's a little low on the depth chart, but the Pistons are likely planning on moving some pieces around. So Monroe will probably get plenty of playing time in a rebuilding situation.

Patrick Patterson, Rockets - Daryl Morey traded Carl Landry away to Sacramento last season at the deadline. And he replaced him with, basically another Carl Landry.

Patterson is a machine on the post. He never stops working, never stops fighting. He's pretty much a perfect Houston Rocket at this point. The traditional box score may say he's not great, the measurables may say he's not super talented, but he just gets it done. Given the chance, he might slip in and average quality numbers playing in a bench role for Houston. And if so, he might also slip into the ROY discussion.

James Anderson, Spurs - With the oft-injured and aging Manu Ginobili playing in front of him, James Anderson might be called upon at some point to step up in a big way for the Spurs. And since he plays for San Antonio, obviously Anderson will be up to the task, because that's the just the way the Spurs work.

He was an elite scorer in college that was questioned at the next level because he's not overly athletic and doesn't score at the rim. But does it matter when you can just plain score? He shoots an open 3 beautifully, he gets to the free throw line and he's not a bad defender. If he gets opportunities, he could potentially average double-digits and play a big role in keeping the Spurs going. And that might be enough to at least get him in the conversation.

This is a weird year. On one hand, there are the obvious favorites as in, two No. 1 overall picks. But on the other, it's a wide open race because there's a lot of uncertainty surrounding those guys. Can Wall settle in with Washington? Is Griffin completely healthy? How good is DeMarcus Cousins and can he jump other candidates?

After Blake Griffin's injury last season, the ROY race opened up completely. Basically everyone had a shot. This season, it's pretty much a two-man showdown, with a couple dark horses hanging around. Writers are just waiting to hand the award to either Wall or Griffin, so in order for someone else to get into the conversation, they'll have to have a big time year.

So it comes down to the two No. 1s. Griffin has the advantage of going through an NBA season already, even if he didn't play. He's had a year of practices, a year of meetings, a year of travel. And most importantly, a year away from home in a big city with a lot of money in his pocket. He knows how to handle it. Wall on the other hand, is coming in like a traditional rookie - fresh.

Basically in my mind, it comes down to Griffin's health. If he doesn't sustain anymore injuries and is able to play the bulk of the season, he's going to have seriously good numbers. Probably something in the 17-10 range or maybe even better. He's a statistical machine. Wall will have a nice year no doubt, but Griffin will likely put up numbers that can be ignored. And that's why, in his second rookie year, Blake Griffin gets the Eddie Gottlieb Trophy.

Since: Apr 5, 2008
Posted on: October 17, 2010 8:23 am

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

Dang all you "Cousins is a head case" idiots are going to have to eat those words soon. He put up with more crap in college than any 4 players I've ever seen COMBINED! He got punched hard in the family jewels by a Tennessee thug and he never over reacted. He had at least 3 teams deliberately try to get him to lose his cool so he would get tossed and it didn't happen. He had the entire fan base of Miss. St. call him and harass him on his cell for a week and he didn't freak. You people are buying into the hype created by known UK haters (Dick Vitale) who wanted to paint a target on his back to ruin his game. It didn't work. Cousins has taken it like a man for a long time. The one thing you think you can point to was a farce. He didn't try to knee anyone in the head. Watch the video without the Vitale colored glasses on. It was Cousins who was the guy who got punched in the head. You're so wrong about him it isn't even funny. He may have a hard time with conditioning but he will never be a head case. He just isn't a person with a big motor but when he's on the floor expect great things from him. He was talent to burn and he is NOT a hot head. He's as far from that as it gets.

Since: Sep 27, 2010
Posted on: September 27, 2010 9:18 pm

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

The last 5 ROYs have been guards. This has become a trend with the way the NBA rules favors scoring, slashing guards.
If Griffin doesn't get the award, we'd probably won't see a dominant big man ROY in a long time.

Since: May 20, 2009
Posted on: September 13, 2010 7:53 pm

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

********BREAKING NEWS*********
This just in: Blake Griffin is still a rookie. As it has ALWAYS been in the NBA, if a rookie never sets foot on the court in his initial season, he's still eligible as a rookie the next year. Always has been, always will be. Happened to Greg Oden when he had microfracture surgery. Happened to David Robinson when he left to serve the military. So no, he's not a sophomore. And no, he's not a 2nd year player. He's a rookie. A rookie that was drafted in '09.

Since: Sep 11, 2010
Posted on: September 11, 2010 2:49 am

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

********BREAKING NEWS**********
This just in: Apparently Blake Griffin is not a rookie after all. He is not a sophomore. He is a 2nd year player.  You dont have Freshmen, Soph's, Junior's or Senior's in the NBA.  Who knew...

Since: Apr 9, 2010
Posted on: September 11, 2010 12:52 am

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

Marked4life, Blake Griffin is still eligible to win the ROY because he never played in the regular season.

This is going to be an interesting year, however. John Wall will be setting up Gilbert Arenas and the rest of his teammates and I think he will have a Brandon Jennings or Tyreke Evans type year. He will be one of the best players on his team and I think his stats will go something like 16-18ppg and 7-10ast. Thats a big margin, but it's hard to compare what he did in the summer and college compared to what he will do in the NBA.

Blake Griffin will bring that gritt and 100% effort that everyone loves, but what remains to be seen is how he holds up, if he still has his great athleticism, and has he improved in a year off? I think he easily gets 15-18ppg with 8-11reb. I think it will come down to how much they impact their respective teams.

Since: Sep 17, 2007
Posted on: September 11, 2010 12:15 am

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

********BREAKING NEWS**********
This just in: Apparently Blake Griffin is not a rookie after all. He is a sophomore. Who knew...

Since: Feb 16, 2007
Posted on: September 10, 2010 10:46 pm

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

Greg Monroe but no Wesley Johnson?  He's a player with all the tools and plenty of opportunity to show them off.  He is probably the best pure athlete of the draft, with the best head on his shoulders, and is going to be playing on a team full of people who know how to pass the ball.

Since: Aug 24, 2006
Posted on: September 10, 2010 9:14 pm

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

It may be a 2 horse race, but that is not a given. Last year a couple of players came from nowhere to be very good players. Griffin is a machine, if healthy, but at this point of the season, I would have to go with Wall. Usually the person that handles the ball the most gets the most media attention. Wall is playing for a pretty bad team, but he has a lot of talent and a couple of good players to feed the ball to. This post is just something to talk about before the season begins. The fate of the Heat is the biggest concern of the NBA fan. As for me, how can James be the 3rd rated fantasy player all of a sudden? I love Durant, but no way I take him ahead of James. Wade may have fallen some, and Bosh a couple of spots, a late 3rd perhaps, but specu;ation feeds the frenzy.

Since: Aug 15, 2008
Posted on: September 10, 2010 8:12 pm

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

I really don't care who wins, although I really don't like Cousins or Wall, I think they are both overrated and Cousins is just a psycho.  My big issue here is Blake Griffin though.  I loved watching him at OU and think he will become a dominant PF in the NBA and wish him the best of luck in coming back from injury.  However, HE IS NOT A ROOKIE!!!  I understand he missed his entire rookie regular season due to injury, but seriously, he was in the NBA for a year, he isn't a rookie.  I don't understand how he can be in the running for a rookie award in his second year.  He was at practice with NBA players and coaches for a year and (theoretically) has had a year of being a professional basketball player while Wall, Cousins, and Co. have been (theoretically) amateures splitting their time and focus on academics, college life, and basketball.  Since the NBA seems to be all about numbers, shouldn't Griffin be the overwhelming favorite for this award since he has a year of learning in the NBA under his belt?

Since: Dec 8, 2009
Posted on: September 10, 2010 5:05 pm

Pop Quiz: Who's the Rookie of the Year favorite?

I think someone else who should be mentioned as a sleeper is the brazilian big man, Tiago Splitter. He is going to be joining a Spurs team that is aging down low with with the 34 year old Tim Duncan and the 36 year old Antonio Mcdyess. The only other competition for minutes at center would be from the undersized(although this is and understatement with him being a 6'7'' center) DeJuan Blair. Splitter has done nothing but tear it up in Spain before coming over, and can now begin to learn from one of the best big men in NBA history in Tim Duncan. Although he may be expected to play a lot early, he will have some of the pressure taken off from him due to the fact that Duncan is still a huge threat. He will also benefit from the dynamic passes of Manu and Parker.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or