Blog Entry

What I learned from the Big Ten (Oct. 9)

Posted on: October 10, 2010 3:38 am

Posted by Adam Jacobi

1. Perhaps Denard Robinson's competition matters. Hey, we'll be the first ones to admit to falling in love with Denard Robinson's early-season performance. Sure, Michigan's opposition wasn't very good (at all), but lots of other teams were playing cupcake schedules at the same time, and nobody -- except maybe for Cam Newton -- was doing what Shoelace was doing. But Michigan State provided a pretty easy blueprint for containing Robinson: have a decent defense and don't do anything stupid with them. The Spartan defense, led as always by All-American linebacker Greg Jones, played disciplined defense against the explosive sophomore and forced him into three interceptions -- two of which came in Michigan State's end zone. Sure, Robinson ended up accounting for 301 yards (215 passing, 86 rushing), and those are good numbers, but remember: he's basically their entire offense. So while giving up 301 yards of offense to one guy isn't ideal, holding the entire team to 377 yards is much more palatable, and that's exactly what the Michigan State defense did. Next up for the Wolverines: Iowa -- and 60 more minutes of that defensive intensity.

2. Don't run up the score on Tim Brewster, please. The second-oddest thing about this week of Big Ten play was seeing Minnesota head coach Tim Brewster get into an arguing match with Wisconsin coach Bret Bielema after Wisconsin's 41-23 victory over the Golden Gophers. The oddest thing came about six minutes prior, when Bret Bielema elected to try a two-point conversion after the Badgers scored a touchdown to extend their lead to 41-16. The try failed, because not even Football God hates Minnesota that much, but Brewster certainly took it personally; the Minnesota coach said some very unprintable words to Bielema on the field, and used the word "wrong" to describe Bielema's decision about 15,000 times in his postgame press conference. Bielema said his little when-should-you-go-for-two card dictated that his team attempt the two-point conversion in that scenario. Even assuming Bielema's excuse is true, we have to wonder why Bielema didn't heed his card's advice 5:16 earlier, when his team scored a fourth-quarter touchdown to go up by 25 the first time. After John Clay's third touchdown of the game, Wisconsin led 34-9 with 11:55 to go, and Bielema kicked a harmless extra point then. Maybe, maybe Minnesota could have engineered 27 points in 11:55, but there was no chance of it happening with 6:39 left, so there's really no sense in kicking the extra point the first time but not the second. Bielema doesn't necessarily owe Brewster an apology; he's Bret Bielema, and he's kind of a jerk, and that's what he does. But at the very least, he owes Brewster and the rest of Big Ten fans an actual explanation of what the heck he was thinking going for two.

3. Penn State just isn't very good. Okay, we sort of knew coming into this season that Penn State would be taking some more lumps than usual on account of their true freshman quarterback, Rob Bolden, winning the starting job in Week 1. And sure, their 24-3 losses to Alabama and Iowa were disappointing, but not really shocking; 'Bama and the Hawkeyes are both pretty legit programs with pretty legit defenses. But 21-point losses to top-15 teams are one thing; a 20-point loss to middling Illinois is another altogether. Illinois controlled the action on both sides of the ball Saturday, shredding Penn State's vaunted front seven for 282 yards on the ground. Mikel LeShoure was a workhorse with 119 rushing yards and a 32-yard reception, and Illini QB Nathan Scheelhaase was both efficient (15-19, 151 yards, 1 TD) and mobile (eight carries, 61 yards). Meanwhile, Bolden had one of his worst starts of his nascent career, going 8-21 for 142 yards, a score, and a pretty bad pick-six to Nate Bussey that pushed Illinois' lead to 14-3. It was a freshman mistake, of course, and one he probably won't make next season and beyond. But it's that sort of thing, coupled with a general lack of special talent on the rest of the offense, that dooms the Nittany Lions when their defense isn't perfect. The Nittany Lions are 3-3 (0-2) now. Right now, it's pretty hard to guarantee they're going to a bowl this season.

4. Northwestern is also not very good. Going back to 2008, Northwestern's habit of winning games by close margins -- which is to say, playing both up and down to the competition -- has never really come back to haunt them; coming into Saturday's game the Wildcats were 14-4 in one-possession games since '08, a streak that's both remarkable and completely doomed to come back down to earth sooner or later, and that's where we find the Wildcat today. Two special teams disasters in the fourth quarter -- a blocked field goal and a poorly-kicked game-tying attempt with a minute left -- effectively kept six points off the board for the Wildcats, and a Dan Dierking rush from 7 yards out sealed the 20-17 upset for lowly Purdue. It's a bummer of a loss for the Wildcats, but the type of inexplicable upset that besets them pretty much every year. Their benchmark game is likely their next: Michigan State comes to town, and a win would put Northwestern back on the map. But it would take the Wildcats' best performance of the season, and any time the prerequisite for respectability is something a team hasn't yet shown itself to be capable of doing, odds are that the fans will go home disappointed.

For more breaking news and analysis follow us on Twitter @CBSSportsNCAAF or subscribe to our RSS Feed.  


Since: Sep 13, 2006
Posted on: October 12, 2010 7:47 am

What I learned from the Big Ten (Oct. 9)

Penn State does not have a lack of special talent.  They are young and the last few years they have recruited a lot of talent especially at WR.  The lack of creativity and modern game play calling is what is killing them.  I'm sorry but it is time for Joe to retire and the complete offensive coaching staff needs to be revamped.  You cant expect Evan Royster to carry your team behind an average offensive line, by running up the middle repeatedly.  What happend to spread HD?  If they dont have faith in the young guys then why play them?  Take the hand cuffs off and let the kids try to make plays, being conservative is making you predictable and losers.

Since: Oct 26, 2009
Posted on: October 10, 2010 6:33 pm

What I learned from the Big Ten (Oct. 9)

Maybe Penn St is not as bad as you think.   Maybe Illinois is better than you think. 

Illinois has lost games no doubt.  But look at who they have played and lost too.

Missouri they lost by 10.   Missouri is not the worse team and staying within 10 is not too bad either.  Certianly no 50-3 blowout.   Might have even been closer than the score suggest(see Ohio St), don't know didn't see the game.

Ohio St, only lost by 11.   And they played them pretty good for awhile too. 

Illinois probably won't win more than a couple of games, but I probably wouldn't pick the other team to cover the spread.     And they might get some more surprise wins this season too(looking at Michigan).

Since: Aug 22, 2009
Posted on: October 10, 2010 1:50 pm

What I learned from the Big Ten (Oct. 9)

I disagree. First off, which one is harder to get one point or two? Two, thats why most people go for the give me one pointer. So he gave Minn a chance to stop him and not get any points besides the 6 for the TD. As for running up the score, SEC teams and PAC 10 teams do it all the time and it's okay. Just because they don't go for two instead of one (one more point big deal), doesn't mean they don't. I wouldn't put Kiffin and Bielema even close to each other. Look at Meyer or Saban or some of the other coaches if you want to talk about running up the score. This isn't anything. Brewster needs to stop whining and Minn needs to get rid of him. At one time I thought he'd do well there but I was clearly wrong and he needs to go.

Since: Aug 18, 2010
Posted on: October 10, 2010 10:33 am

What I learned from the Big Ten (Oct. 9)

Bielema showed a total lack of class.  How pathetic must you be to try and run the score up against Minnesota.  I laughed at USC when Stanford did it to them, because USC had been the conference bully for the previous 10 years.  Nothing similar going on here.  Bielema is now next to Kiffen as the most low class coach in the sport in my eyes.  I am sure all of Wisconsin is proud of this display.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or