Blog Entry

James Rodgers gets hardship waiver for fifth year

Posted on: January 5, 2011 7:01 pm

Posted by Adam Jacobi

Oregon State got a boost of good news today when senior James Rodgers -- brother of Jacquizz Rodgers , of course -- was given an extra year of eligibility by the NCAA. Rodgers was injured after making a (negated) touchdown catch past Arizona safety Adam Hall in the first half of the OSU-Arizona game; Rodgers' knee buckled as Hall tackled him in the end zone, tearing Rodgers' ACL.

Technically, Rodgers' season-ending injury came during the fifth game of the year, but he had missed the prior game after suffering a concussion on a hit by Boise State safety Will Venables (the helmet-to-helmet hit by Venables would result in a two-quarter suspension), so Rodgers really only played in four of the season's 12 games. That's small enough to meet the NCAA's requirement of 30% games played (yes, there's rounding involved) to grant a medical hardship waiver.

But while Venables' hit was obviously dirty and punished as such, the play that resulted in Rodgers' blown knee would probably be less defensible if it weren't so common. On the fateful play, Rodgers had clearly scored the touchdown and taken several steps in the end zone with Hall on him when Hall finished the tackle, twisting Rodgers' knee past the ACL's tolerance. If that play happens out of bounds, Hall gets flagged and perhaps ejected for unnecessary roughness. And yet, the ball is dead in the end zone after the officials signal a touchdown too, and Hall wasn't trying for a last-gasp strip. It's just common practice to go ahead and get the ball-carrier down in the unlikely event that the ball comes out. Not only is the practice cheap, it's demonstrably dangerous, and with replay being such a part of college football, it wouldn't even work anyway. You're really going to strip a guy 5 steps into the end zone and then expect the ref and replay booth to all think it's a legitimate play? Come on.

Again, it's still technically legal, mainly because it's so widespread, but the fact that someone who has just scored a touchdown can get whacked without any repercussions from the officials seems inconsistent with the rest of the protections afforded to players everywhere else on the field.

At any rate, this is a welcome change of circumstance for Rodgers, who came into the 2010 season as a preseason All-American only to fall off his school-record pace from 2009 even before the injuries. If he can put together a solid senior season with his brother in the backfield, cannon-armed junior Ryan Katz returning as the starting quarterback, and a bevy of experienced receivers coming back, the lousy 2010 campaign will become little more than a distant memory.


Since: Dec 2, 2011
Posted on: December 22, 2011 11:00 am

James Rodgers gets hardship waiver for fifth year

Without doubt precisely what a very good blog We now have get there crossways and furthermore think about it me to Individuals taking a look at for this purpose the same type short post to obtain over each week plus not even observed that. With thanks lots and definately will look at a heap a lot of articles . on your side.

Since: Feb 11, 2009
Posted on: January 7, 2011 4:10 am

James Rodgers gets hardship waiver for fifth year

Good for the kid.  His season was short and he misses out on all of this great championship run by the Ducks.  I hope he does well and they do good again next year.  The NCAA gets one right shocker!

Since: Oct 31, 2006
Posted on: January 6, 2011 9:27 am
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Jan 26, 2007
Posted on: January 6, 2011 8:53 am

James Rodgers gets hardship waiver for fifth year

This couldn't have happened for a nicer kid. I watched both of the games and could not believe how blatently both teams were trying to take him out of those games. Something should have been done to them. Hit men have a place, but it shouldn't be in NCAA football. I hope he can heal properly and return for the deserved glory next season. Good luck to him.

Since: Feb 21, 2007
Posted on: January 6, 2011 12:48 am

James Rodgers gets hardship waiver for fifth year

I think this is the right thing to do. At least the kid wants to stay in school and get an education on top of showing the scouts that he his healthy. Im not a fan of Oregon State but im a fan of people getting a second chance so to speak in this case. Plus its good for college football. Good luck in your recovery James.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or