Blog Entry

Who called Indiana the dirtiest team in Big Ten?

Posted on: August 10, 2011 7:43 pm

Posted by Adam Jacobi

At Big Ten Media Days, one enterprising reporter for conducted an informal survey of 10 football players who were present for interviews. The players were anonymous, so as to ensure honesty in the answers. The entire survey is worth reading, and there are some entertaining points -- especially when one unnamed player said of embattled Illinois coach Ron Zook, "I've heard he's just kind of funny, and not in a good way."

One question stuck out, however: the dirtiest team of all the Legends and Leaders.

Which is the dirtiest team in the Big Ten?

Indiana - 3 “I was out that game, but I saw what went on and our guys were saying it was bad out there.” Ohio State - 3 Wisconsin - 1 N/A 3

That's not really great news for Indiana or Ohio State, although the fact that three players didn't think there was a dirty team in the conference means we're probably not dealing with an epidemic of unsportsmanlike conduct on the Big Ten gridirons or anything. Moreover, both OSU and the Hoosiers have new head coaches this year, neither of whom should be asked to answer for accusations of dirty play under coaches past. That wouldn't be fair. However, the reporter might have given up a little too much information with that quote.

Out of the 36 players there, nine were on teams that didn't play Indiana last year, and three more were from Indiana. Of the remaining 24 players, only two -- Iowa LB Tyler Nielsen and Penn State LB Michael Mauti -- were out of action in their games against Indiana. Nielsen had just suffered a broken neck (a relatively mild one, obviously; his spinal cord was fine and he's back atop the depth chart), and Mauti was dealing with an injured shoulder from the previous week's contest against Ohio State.

We're not going to press the respective athletic departments about who said what or demand any more definitive answers than this; the survey was anonymous for a reason, and we'll respect that. However, we would like to hear from Iowa and Penn State fans as to whether the Indiana games last year seemed especially dirty. Did knees get wrenched, eyes gouged, hits enlatened? Help us solve the mystery once and for all.

(For the record, the jersey-pulling depicted above is considered legal.) 


Since: Aug 29, 2006
Posted on: August 12, 2011 11:52 am

Who called Indiana the dirtiest team in Big Ten?

There's no factual base to this comment, - got to be written by an Ann Arbor fan.  Man, when will the phoney baloney ever stop.  Jealous turkeys.

Since: Sep 11, 2006
Posted on: August 11, 2011 8:59 am

Who called Indiana the dirtiest team in Big Ten?

Teres Minor now holds the dubious honor of being A blowhard whose dislike for THE Ohio State University clouds his ability to reason. Please list for me the QB's and RB's that were taken out last year by THE dirty Ohio State Buckeyes.

Since: Jun 5, 2011
Posted on: August 11, 2011 1:51 am

Ohio State does double duty

THE Ohio State University now holds two dubious honors: THE Dirtiest Program in College Football and THE Dirtiest Team in the Big Ten.  Indiana plays dirty so they don't get blown out every game.  Ohio plays dirty because paying recruits doesn't give them enough of an advantage, so they want to take out the other team's QB and RB every game.  

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or