Blog Entry

SEC Winners and Losers, Week 12

Posted on: November 20, 2011 2:32 am

Posted by Jerry Hinnen

WINNER: The top quarter of the SEC. Things are as good for the three teams that have perched at the top the SEC all season as they've been, well, all season. LSU? Just another ho-hum 49-point pounding of some hapless overmatched opponent, and now just two wins away from the BCS national championship game. Arkansas? A 27-point thumping of a team that's given them fits in the past, and thanks to the carnage across the country a certain spot in the BCS top five--potentially setting up the Hogs for an SEC West title if they knock off the Tigers. (We think. Maybe.)

But neither the Tigers nor the Razorbacks are as happy this weekend as is Alabama. Thanks to Oklahoma State's pratfall in Ames, Oregon's loss to USC, and Oklahoma's defeat in Waco, the Tide has now seen every conceivable obstacle between themselves and a hypothetical BCS rematch against the Tigers fall by the wayside. Win next week against Auburn, and the Tide are all but guaranteed to head to New Orleans ... one way or another.

LOSER: The other three quarters of the SEC. No one who's watched the SEC week-in and week-out would argue this is a vintage year for the league's depth, but the conference reached a new 2011 low on Saturday morning. With three SEC teams taking on three representatives from the FCS Southern Conference, the combined score of the three games midway through the collective second quarter was a tight 42-34 ... in favor of the SoCon.

Yes, Auburn eventually pulled away from Samford, Florida from Furman, and South Carolina from the Citadel. But when the conference's de facto No. 5/6/7 (in some order) teams have those kinds of struggles with FCS competition, "down year" doesn't totally cover it. And team No. 4 -- Georgia -- may have won the East, but anything similar to their sloppy, flat, lackluster performance against Kentucky will get them annihilated in Atlanta in two weeks.

WINNERS: Tauren Poole and Da'Rick Rogers. Even as Tennessee collapsed to a 0-6 SEC record, a handful of Vols continued to shine amongst the wreckage, and Poole and Rogers were two of the brightest spots. With a chance to salvage a bowl berth at home against a Vanderbilt team that some would argue had surpassed the Vols -- in the coaching department, on the recruiting trails, and on the field -- Poole and Rogers put the team on their back. Poole ran 19 times for 107 big yards and added 21 more in the receiving game. Rogers was even bigger--10 catches, 116 yards and two touchdowns, including a sensational one-handed grab to tie the game at 21 in the fourth quarter. The two late interceptions of Jordan Rodgers -- the game-winner obviously included -- were the Vols' biggest plays. But with Tyler Bray rusty, Poole and Rogers were their biggest players.

LOSERS: The officials at Tennessee-Vanderbilt. We want to be kind to college football officials, who have a thankless job we would never, ever volunteer for ourselves. But kindness only extends so far, and it doesn't extend past the phenomenal botch-job in the first overtime of 'Dores-Vols. If you missed it: Rodgers threw an interception to Eric Gordon, who returned it for an apparent game-winning touchdown. But Gordon was whistled down by the line judgeeven with replay showing he wasn't close to having his knee down. Unfortunately for the Vols, that play isn't reviewable ... except that the officials reviewed it anyway under the pretense of checking if the whistle blew. And even though it did, the call was overturned anyway. It's not just us saying this either--the official SEC response confirms that the call was butchered six ways from Sunday.

To be fair, the officials eventually arrived at the right call; Tennessee won the game fair-and-square on Gordon's play. But that it took two dreadful wrongs to get there was an embarrassment.

WINNER: Blair Walsh. Sure, the longest of his four field goals vs. Kentucky was just 39 yards. But Walsh has been so erratic this season -- just 13-of-23 coming into this game --that Georgia will take four routine makes in a heartbeat. The Dawgs won't feel better about their chances of winning the SEC after their outing today, but a Walsh with his head screwed on correctly will be a big positive nonetheless.

LOSER: Will Muschamp's defensive reputation. The transition from Urban Meyer's spread looks to Charlie Weis's pro-style schemes was always going to be a problem for the Gators. But with the bevy of athletes at their disposal in the front seven, Muschamp's coaching acumen, and a defense that ranked ninth in the country in total defense a year ago, the Florida defense shouldn't have taken that much of step back, right? Statistically, they haven't; entering this week, the Gators were still 11th in the FBS. But Muschamp's and coordinator Dan Quinn's defense has had a few notable lapses this season, maybe none bigger than somehow allowing Furman 446 yards and 32 points. Motivation couldn't have been easy to come by, but that's simply not the sort of defensive numbers put up by a top-notch SEC defense.

WINNERS/LOSERS: Rematch lovers/haters. The bottom line about one of the wildest weeks in BCS history: LSU vs. Alabama is now the clearcut most likely outcome for the BCS title game. Love it or hate it, we can at least say this: you'd better get used to it. 


Since: Nov 7, 2011
Posted on: November 20, 2011 12:26 pm

SEC Winners and Losers, Week 12

Will never happen... Sorry!!!

Since: Nov 7, 2011
Posted on: November 20, 2011 12:25 pm

SEC Winners and Losers, Week 12

All I have to say is Ok State doesn't have a prayer getting into the BCS Championship game and LSU it won't be the same game this time... The TIDE will ROLL into the Super Dome we will see you there....

Since: Nov 20, 2011
Posted on: November 20, 2011 12:19 pm

SEC Winners and Losers, Week 12

I have a big question mark over Georgia though. They’ve won 9 straight which is something only a few teams have accomplished at this point. Late season losses are common with injuries and such but they have shown me a lot lately with their ability to pull out wins at the end. They are by no means a top 5 team right now but it seems they are deserving of a high spot in the 2 loss team bracket. When you look at the fact they have only lost to high ranked teams and haven’t lost since September, shouldn’t this be given more weight than an 0-2 start?

Also, Oklahoma lost to a #22 team and an unranked team – Georgia lost to a #5 and #12 team.ThenewBCS projections have Oklahoma ranked 7th with Georgia at 14th.

Is it that everyone else has a big question mark over Georgia like I do so they don’t want to rank them higher?

Since: Nov 25, 2006
Posted on: November 20, 2011 11:27 am

SEC Winners and Losers, Week 12

I would agree with that.

Since: Nov 2, 2006
Posted on: November 20, 2011 8:15 am

SEC Winners and Losers, Week 12

If Oklahoma State wins vs. Oklahoma, I still see the Cowboys leapfrog Alabama to play in the title game against LSU. I see the same thing happening as happened between Michigan and Florida in 2006-07 and pollsters will want to avoid a rematch. In addition, I imagine there will be some sympathy and forgiveness for Oklahoma State's loss on the road the week after their women's basketball coach was killed.

My BCS bowl projections:

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or