Blog Entry

How will the Carter-Nash duo work in Columbus?

Posted on: July 24, 2011 12:40 pm
Edited on: July 24, 2011 1:16 pm
nashBy Adam Gretz

Now that the Columbus Blue Jackets have acquired a No. 1 center, the discussion has shifted from whether they will ever find a player capable of matching Rick Nash's ability on their top line, to whether the player they acquired -- Jeff Carter -- is the right fit.

The concern now is that Carter and Nash might be too similar to complement each other as they are nearly identical players. They both have roughly the same build; they both score a lot of goals; and both take a lot of shots. Over the past three years, they've been two of the top-five goal-scorers in the NHL, while both finished last season in the top six in shots on goal.

Assuming the two are paired on Columbus' top line, somebody is going to have to take on more of a playmaking role because, well, you have two guys that love to shoot and only one puck to go around. The expectation seems to be that Carter, the center, will be that player, and he's been asked about it since being officially introduced to the Columbus media this past week.

AJ Mazzolini put together a story in the Columbus Dispatch on Thursday talking about the expectations Carter will be facing, where he acknowledged passing will have to become a larger part of his game. But should it?

As the center it's easy to assume Carter will distribute the puck more, and while neither player has put up huge assist numbers throughout his career, I think Nash, based simply on personal observation, possesses more playmaking skills and could be a better set-up man on the wing.

Nash has taken on such a shooting role in Columbus for, I think, two main reasons: 1) because, obviously, he's an excellent sniper on the wing, but also 2) because he's been forced to take on such a role.

He's been forced to take on such a role because he's been the only consistent goal-scoring threat in Columbus over the past seven seasons. Since 2003-04, he's been the only Blue Jackets player to score at least 30 goals in a season, while only three others (Antoine Vermette in 2009-10, R.J. Umberger in 2008-09 and 2010-11, and Nikolay Zherdev in 2005-06) have managed to score more than 25 in a season. If he doesn't do it, nobody is doing it.

Not only does Columbus have another option, Nash has somebody else on his line that will also be capable of finishing plays. And Nash brings more to the table than just the ability to shoot. He has vision, he can create space for himself and his linemates, he works along the walls and he even has some touch to his passes. Take this play for example:

He's just needed somebody else to take advantage of all of it.

I don't expect Nash's game to change all that much, but I do think we'll see his performance go to another level. He's going to have a much better player on his line -- perhaps the best player he's ever played with in the NHL -- that is also capable of scoring goals and highlighting his playmaking ability that has gone relatively unnoticed the past seven years.

Photo: Getty Images

For more hockey news, rumors and analysis, follow @cbssportsnhl and @agretz on Twitter.


Since: Apr 10, 2007
Posted on: July 26, 2011 4:37 pm

How will the Carter-Nash duo work in Columbus?

No doubt, Jeff Carter is one of the most talented "sniper's" in todays game.  Columbus gained one of the best wrist shots in the game in Carter.  Recently, he has become an injury liability.  No doubt, Carter/Nash pairing is going to be good, but Carter being one hit, one slash, or one hard-hit away from missing 15-20 games will always be a factor. 

Since: Nov 5, 2007
Posted on: July 25, 2011 5:22 pm

How will the Carter-Nash duo work in Columbus?

Jeff Carter can score goals.

He once trailed only Alex Ovechkin with 47 on the season a few years ago.

The question for Carter is when and how important are these goals he scores.

One of the most painful memories of the 2010 SCF was in game 6 watching Carter wiff on an open net in the final moments of regulation.

Unfortunately, those type of moments accumulated to label Carter a player that has a tendancy to carry some inflated stats.

Carter is the kind of guy who has flashes of greatness one game, and looks disinterested in the next. He scores 5-6 goals in a few games, then goes 5-6 games without any.

The bottom line is he is inconsistent. He is young, talented, but inconsistent. Carter should benefit from being in a situation where he is not heavily leaned on for leadership. In Phiiy, he was part of the evolving future. In Columbus, he should benefit from being looked at as an added weapon. There is a big difference there.

I liked Jeff Carter while he was in Philly; more than most. But there are parts of his game that will drive you nuts. But overall, I think Columbus will be a great fit for him.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or