Blog Entry

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Posted on: December 6, 2011 11:09 am
Edited on: December 6, 2011 11:26 am
Coming into the season there was so much optimism at different programs, but fast forward three months and there's been a lot of disappointment. This week's Top 10 list: biggest duds of the 2011 season. (I'm leaving off the BCS, which you could make a strong case for deserving to be on this list every year.)

1. Maryland: Randy Edsall's first season in College Park was a disaster of the highest order. The Terps got off to a nice start, edging a seriously depleted Miami team that was gutted by NCAA suspensions, but then things completely fell apart. They didn't beat another FBS program the rest of the way. They got blown out at home by Temple 38-7. They lost to a bad BC team by 11. They blew a huge second-half lead against NC State. The stunning part in all of this was it's not like Edsall inherited the FAU squad. They were 9-4 last year and had the best young QB in the conference in Danny O'Brien. However, the sophomore quarterback regressed in a big way under Edsall. The team was 111th in passing efficiency. In the final eight games of the season, the Terps managed to scored more than 21 points twice. Somewhere, Ralph Friedgen is probably still laughing at his bosses who ran him out of his alma mater after winning ACC Coach of the Year honors.

2. The State of Florida: The Noles were preseason No. 6 and slogged their way to an 8-4 record where they didn't even make it to the ACC title game. At one point they had a three-game losing streak. In mid-November, they lost at home against unranked UVA. ... The Gators, No. 22 in preseason, fizzled on offense and went 6-6 by dropping six of their last eight games. . . . Miami's hopes were torpedoed on the eve of the season by the Nevin Shapiro mess that would sideline a bunch of key players early. The Canes never recovered, losing six games by eight points or less before opting out of what figured to be a mediocre bowl game in hopes of appeasing the NCAA down the road. Their final game: a home loss to a 3-8 BC team. ... USF got off to a fast start, beating a ranked Notre Dame team on the road, but then Skip Holtz team flopped, losing seven of their final eight. ... UCF, which despite having the No. 11 D in the country, failed to even get bowl eligible, going 5-7. Last year UCF was 11-3. Now there is much uncertainty and who knows if sophomore QB Jeff Godfrey, who had seemed to be the centerpiece of the upstart program, will be back in Orlando in 2012?

3. Texas A&M: The Aggies, preseason No. 8, had way too much firepower to go 6-6. Even 8-4 would've felt like a big let down. Statistically, they were a very hard team to figure out. They were seventh in the country in total offense, first in fewest sacks allowed, first in sacks, 13th in rushing defense but they also were 100th in turnover margin. They blew a ridiculous amount of games in the second half. They ended up losing four of their last five and Mike Sherman lost his job because of it.

4. Ole Miss: A lot of people pegged the Rebels for the bottom of the SEC West, but no one would've expected they'd have the worst season in school history. Houston Nutt's lackluster recruiting at Ole Miss really caught up with him. His team got thumped by Vandy in a way that the Commodores never beat another SEC program. The Rebels also lost by 17 to lowly Kentucky and then get crunched by La. Tech 27-7 at the their homecoming game. The 2-10 season cost Nutt his job and was punctuated with another blowout loss to arch-rival Miss. State, 31-3.

5. Oklahoma: [Note: The Sooners were a bad omit on my part when I initially published this list.] They were preseason No. 1 and sputtered badly in the season half of the season, losing three of their last six. The first loss was home to a four-TD underdog (Texas Tech) that would end up having its worst season in almost 20 years. The Sooners finished off the season getting drilled by rival Oklahoma State, 44-10.

6-UCLA defense:
Few teams look better on the hoof, but the Bruins just never could get it done under Rick Neuheisel. Despite a defensive unit were more than its share of former blue-chippers, the Bruins were 112th in sacks and 96th in scoring defense. They surrendered 38 or more six times this season.

7. Mississippi State: They were a long shot to win the incredibly stacked SEC West, but the Bulldogs were still a preseason top 20 team but they never got much of anything going. They went 6-6. The only team with a winning record they beat was 8-4 La. Tech. Their other four wins over FBS opponents went 12-36 combined.

8. Notre Dame offense: The Irish were ranked a respectable 43rd in scoring, but given the weapons Brian Kelly had (led by WR Michael Floyd) ND should've been a lot more dynamic. They were held to 20 points or less five times this season. They also were brutal when it came to taking care of the football, tying for third-worst in the country in turnover margin.

9. Kansas: Turner Gill was fired after just two seasons because the Jayhawks were so overwhelmed this season. They beat an FCS program and then knocked off the eventual MAC champs (NIU) in Week 2 and it was all downhill from them on as it was one epic blowout loss after another. They ranked 106th in total offense and 120 in total defense. Of their final 10 losses to finish the season, only two were decided by less than double-digits. They lost six games by 30 points or more.

10. Illinois offense: Things set up so well for Ron Zook this season. They had a dynamic young QB (Nate Scheelhaase) and some talented backs and receivers. The Illini jumped out to a 6-0 start and then the bottom drops out. They lose the next six, failing to score more than two TDs in any other game. They managed just seven points against a Minnesota D that was 102nd in scoring defense. They scored 14 on a Michigan, which is 51 points fewer than they scored on the Wolverines on a year ago. The Illini finished 91st in scoring, dropping 59 spots from where they were at mid-season. They also ended up 106th in sacks allowed.


Since: Jul 21, 2007
Posted on: December 7, 2011 2:15 am

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

The biggest "Dud" is the person(s) who decided tha the Coaches poll should decide 1/3 of the BCS rankings. How can you have a BCS system where coaches vote to help their own team or conference? Even without a playoff, correct that!

Since: Aug 25, 2011
Posted on: December 7, 2011 2:06 am

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Georgia?...A team that had a losing record last year and had only 5 senior starters this year. Was predicted to finish 3rd in SEC east. You mean that Georgia? Far from DUD. 

Since: Nov 2, 2006
Posted on: December 7, 2011 1:16 am

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

What about BAMA?

Since: Jan 27, 2008
Posted on: December 7, 2011 12:49 am

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

This may be the only time Randy Edsall is number one in anything at UMD. I hope the Prersidednt of Underarmor is proud of himself for getting Fridge fired. The excuse that attendance was down was foolish. The job of promoting sports, hmmm, isn't that the AD's job? If attendance was down at 9-4, I wonder what it'll be like trying to sell tickets after 2-10? Bet they respond by raising prices.

Since: Mar 6, 2011
Posted on: December 6, 2011 10:16 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

The biggest dud of the year was the NCAA.  Cheating, scandals, a broken BCS system (I don't care if we don't have playoffs.....just get rid of the BCS), a beauty pageant for the heisman award.  Every year, the collective sports fans hope things will get better, but they don't.  This year, we had high hopes that Oklahoma would be good and Boise State would go undefeated.   We hoped the Big 10 and Pac 12 would field awesome teams that entertained us week in and week out.  We hoped we would see the top teams playing in bowl games in early January.  We hoped the BCS system would get it right.  

Instead, we get 6-7 UCLA in a bowl game.  Boise State is out of the BCS and Virginia Tech is in.  Ohio State gets a pat on the wrist for their wrong doings and the list goes on and on.   Don't get me started about conference realignment.  The NCAA is taking a back seat and not providing any leadership whatsoever.  Therefore, I vote the NCAA as the #1 bust this season!

Since: Dec 6, 2010
Posted on: December 6, 2011 10:05 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

What about OSU, Georgia and FSU?  The "Noles were supposed to contend for a national title blah, blah, blah.  It has worked out the way it was ordained.  LSU and Alabama are the best in the country and deserve the title game.  They both come from the best conference unfortunately and were a disappointment to no one including the prognosticators.  Now until the BCS comes up with aplayoff system the Stanfords, Oregons and Oklahoma States will have to be content for playing for 3rd, fourth and fifth place. Be mindful Big 10, PAC 10 or whatever number and SWC what you wish for 'Bama and LSU would embarrass you badly!

Since: Mar 20, 2011
Posted on: December 6, 2011 9:52 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Id have to add The ohio state to that. They were lucky to make a bowl game.

Since: Mar 20, 2007
Posted on: December 6, 2011 9:25 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Well, I'm going to add it; the BCS. It would be so simple to include a Pluse One playoff system and end all this controversy. If one had been in place this year, and using the current rankings, LSU would be playing Stanford, while Arkansas would be playing Oklahoma State. The winners would play each other for the National Championship. No controversy. Won on the field. Period.
Where would Alabama be?  Remember, the obstacle to a playoff are the Pac-12 and the Big-10.  The SEC badly wants a playoff and the Big-12 says they do too.

Since: Sep 20, 2009
Posted on: December 6, 2011 9:22 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Only for a program like Oklahoma would a 9-3 season be considered a "dud" with wins over ranked teams and losses to a team ranked #2 and a team with   a heisman QB after losses of some of the top players in the game to injuries(and death in the case of Box) .So by these standards if Oklahoma fails to make a BSC NC game it is a dud season. Most programs would give  almost anything to be a dud like this one.

Since: Aug 13, 2011
Posted on: December 6, 2011 9:11 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Well, I'm going to add it; the BCS. It would be so simple to include a Pluse One playoff system and end all this controversy. If one had been in place this year, and using the current rankings, LSU would be playing Stanford, while Arkansas would be playing Oklahoma State. The winners would play each other for the National Championship. No controversy. Won on the field. Period.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or