Blog Entry

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Posted on: December 6, 2011 11:09 am
Edited on: December 6, 2011 11:26 am
Coming into the season there was so much optimism at different programs, but fast forward three months and there's been a lot of disappointment. This week's Top 10 list: biggest duds of the 2011 season. (I'm leaving off the BCS, which you could make a strong case for deserving to be on this list every year.)

1. Maryland: Randy Edsall's first season in College Park was a disaster of the highest order. The Terps got off to a nice start, edging a seriously depleted Miami team that was gutted by NCAA suspensions, but then things completely fell apart. They didn't beat another FBS program the rest of the way. They got blown out at home by Temple 38-7. They lost to a bad BC team by 11. They blew a huge second-half lead against NC State. The stunning part in all of this was it's not like Edsall inherited the FAU squad. They were 9-4 last year and had the best young QB in the conference in Danny O'Brien. However, the sophomore quarterback regressed in a big way under Edsall. The team was 111th in passing efficiency. In the final eight games of the season, the Terps managed to scored more than 21 points twice. Somewhere, Ralph Friedgen is probably still laughing at his bosses who ran him out of his alma mater after winning ACC Coach of the Year honors.

2. The State of Florida: The Noles were preseason No. 6 and slogged their way to an 8-4 record where they didn't even make it to the ACC title game. At one point they had a three-game losing streak. In mid-November, they lost at home against unranked UVA. ... The Gators, No. 22 in preseason, fizzled on offense and went 6-6 by dropping six of their last eight games. . . . Miami's hopes were torpedoed on the eve of the season by the Nevin Shapiro mess that would sideline a bunch of key players early. The Canes never recovered, losing six games by eight points or less before opting out of what figured to be a mediocre bowl game in hopes of appeasing the NCAA down the road. Their final game: a home loss to a 3-8 BC team. ... USF got off to a fast start, beating a ranked Notre Dame team on the road, but then Skip Holtz team flopped, losing seven of their final eight. ... UCF, which despite having the No. 11 D in the country, failed to even get bowl eligible, going 5-7. Last year UCF was 11-3. Now there is much uncertainty and who knows if sophomore QB Jeff Godfrey, who had seemed to be the centerpiece of the upstart program, will be back in Orlando in 2012?

3. Texas A&M: The Aggies, preseason No. 8, had way too much firepower to go 6-6. Even 8-4 would've felt like a big let down. Statistically, they were a very hard team to figure out. They were seventh in the country in total offense, first in fewest sacks allowed, first in sacks, 13th in rushing defense but they also were 100th in turnover margin. They blew a ridiculous amount of games in the second half. They ended up losing four of their last five and Mike Sherman lost his job because of it.

4. Ole Miss: A lot of people pegged the Rebels for the bottom of the SEC West, but no one would've expected they'd have the worst season in school history. Houston Nutt's lackluster recruiting at Ole Miss really caught up with him. His team got thumped by Vandy in a way that the Commodores never beat another SEC program. The Rebels also lost by 17 to lowly Kentucky and then get crunched by La. Tech 27-7 at the their homecoming game. The 2-10 season cost Nutt his job and was punctuated with another blowout loss to arch-rival Miss. State, 31-3.

5. Oklahoma: [Note: The Sooners were a bad omit on my part when I initially published this list.] They were preseason No. 1 and sputtered badly in the season half of the season, losing three of their last six. The first loss was home to a four-TD underdog (Texas Tech) that would end up having its worst season in almost 20 years. The Sooners finished off the season getting drilled by rival Oklahoma State, 44-10.

6-UCLA defense:
Few teams look better on the hoof, but the Bruins just never could get it done under Rick Neuheisel. Despite a defensive unit were more than its share of former blue-chippers, the Bruins were 112th in sacks and 96th in scoring defense. They surrendered 38 or more six times this season.

7. Mississippi State: They were a long shot to win the incredibly stacked SEC West, but the Bulldogs were still a preseason top 20 team but they never got much of anything going. They went 6-6. The only team with a winning record they beat was 8-4 La. Tech. Their other four wins over FBS opponents went 12-36 combined.

8. Notre Dame offense: The Irish were ranked a respectable 43rd in scoring, but given the weapons Brian Kelly had (led by WR Michael Floyd) ND should've been a lot more dynamic. They were held to 20 points or less five times this season. They also were brutal when it came to taking care of the football, tying for third-worst in the country in turnover margin.

9. Kansas: Turner Gill was fired after just two seasons because the Jayhawks were so overwhelmed this season. They beat an FCS program and then knocked off the eventual MAC champs (NIU) in Week 2 and it was all downhill from them on as it was one epic blowout loss after another. They ranked 106th in total offense and 120 in total defense. Of their final 10 losses to finish the season, only two were decided by less than double-digits. They lost six games by 30 points or more.

10. Illinois offense: Things set up so well for Ron Zook this season. They had a dynamic young QB (Nate Scheelhaase) and some talented backs and receivers. The Illini jumped out to a 6-0 start and then the bottom drops out. They lose the next six, failing to score more than two TDs in any other game. They managed just seven points against a Minnesota D that was 102nd in scoring defense. They scored 14 on a Michigan, which is 51 points fewer than they scored on the Wolverines on a year ago. The Illini finished 91st in scoring, dropping 59 spots from where they were at mid-season. They also ended up 106th in sacks allowed.


Since: Aug 21, 2006
Posted on: December 6, 2011 9:04 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Oklahoma suffered what most teams do - injuries and lack of depth.   OU has been off the last three years on the recruiting trail but their previous depth masked that.    Their level of talent and continuous assistant turnstile are now starting to catch up to them.   By all measures in reason, they had a good year; but the BCS and Polls being what they are ranked them #1 without really looking at their team as a whole.   Loses on the offensive line were over-looked because Broyles was such an outstanding receiver that it allowed so many other players to step up as solid role players, but with Broyles gone, OU was just an average good team.   

But defensively they lost key role players for specific situations to injury which all but doomed them as the thinned ranks suddenly found out that the Big12 is an offensive monster and you either have a defensive that can make big stops and an offense which can keep you defense off the field and points on the scoreboard - or your defense gets worn out quick - even faster when you don't have depth.    

The Big12 was very experienced this year and it showed.  OU, Texas, Tech, and yes - Texas A&M suffered due to that shift.  Oklahoma State, Kansas State, but probably the biggest change was Baylor; all took advantage of great coaching, player experience, and maybe a little bit of grit in finally having the upper hand on the previously dominant teams in the conference.

Since: Sep 8, 2006
Posted on: December 6, 2011 8:37 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Duds: Nebraska, Maryland and Michigan...
I'm confused by this post... isn't Michigan in a BCS bowl this year?  

Since: Feb 23, 2008
Posted on: December 6, 2011 8:28 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Michigan didn't fire Carr, he retired voluntarily. Also, how does what happened four years ago have any relation to this season, when Michigan made a BCS bowl after being told in the preseason that they would be lucky to finish 7-5?

Since: Oct 2, 2008
Posted on: December 6, 2011 8:08 pm

Duds: Nebraska, Maryland and Michigan...

Those are three programs, Maryland most recently who have really not fully recovered from horrible administrative decisions to get rid of their coaches.  Firing Solich for a 8-4 season in 2004 just because they lost big late to a decent Kansas State team (pressured by the media to do so) and firing Lloyd Carr for going 9-3 in 2007 just because they lost to top-ranked Ohio State after the App. State embarassment at the beginning of the season.

 Sometimes you have to look the other way and see how far these guys have brought you and realize that when you decide to go a different direction it will cost time, personnel and wins for quite a while.  If Mich would have kept Carr they would have been to a Rose Bowl in two years maybe playing for a BCS title in another year or two with the recruits they had coming in who defected when they canned him.  Mich ended up with the spread offense run by guys who were recruited to run the multiple offense and Nebraska brought in a reject coach that even confused Jerry Rice when he played for Callahan in the NFL.

 Friedgen was a QB coach period.  He took a small high school Georgia QB (O'Brien) and made him into an offensive machine in just one year after his great mentoring with GT's QB's under George O'Leary like Joe Hamilton in the late 90's turning him from a running quarterback to one of the better passers in the ACC.  The geniuses at Maryland opted for an untested coach from the weakest Big East in history (2010) and thought that was the right direction.  These still are collegiate programs not NFL franchises but you can't tell the head brass of these schools and many others that.

Since: Jan 15, 2008
Posted on: December 6, 2011 7:40 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

You forgot Arizona State's absolute pancake act in November.

Since: Sep 11, 2006
Posted on: December 6, 2011 7:39 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

The uniforms were fine.  The 2-10 season is the issue.  How can a coach take the nucleus of a 9-4 team and drag it all the way down to 2-10 (wth only one win over a depleted BCS team, Miami)?  Edsall's got to go.

Since: Aug 28, 2006
Posted on: December 6, 2011 7:38 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Just plop Florida and Tennessee down as the whole top ten - they ruined college football this year.  If either of those two teams had been worth a damn, they could have handed a few losses to the other real SEC teams - there were only five of them.  That's what I call top heavy.  Florida and Tennessee caused the LSU/Alabama rematch to happen.

Since: Aug 28, 2006
Posted on: December 6, 2011 7:36 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Who care, they defeated Florida - if Florida had won that game SEC fans would have been pumping Florida and the SEC like there was no tomorrow.

Since: Oct 14, 2010
Posted on: December 6, 2011 7:23 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

I guess Maryland deserves to be #1 on your list of duds when you consider the best thing about the Terps was their ugly designer uniforms.  Yeah, yeah, I get the history and the state flag.  But those unies made them the gayest looking team in the country.  They might as well have called themselves the University of Maryland Marys. 

Since: Aug 24, 2006
Posted on: December 6, 2011 7:16 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Biggest duds of 2011

Why mention the Florida State Seminoles when they were one of the teams that defeated the SEC's Florida?
Because they were ranked so high at the beginning of the season and underachieved.  Now, it is not all their fault, their QB (Manuel) got hurt and missed the 3-game losing streak in the middle of the season, but the loss to Virginia was inexcusible.  My Canes were a maddening team, they lost all 6 games by one point or less, including a 28-24 loss to Kansas St. where they got stopped at the 1 on 4th and goal and a 38-35 loss the Va. Tech where they had the lead late and blew it, but FSU should have done better.  Again, not all their fault w/the QB injury, but not a good season by their standards.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or