Blog Entry

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

Posted on: January 13, 2012 1:37 pm
Edited on: January 13, 2012 7:55 pm
Time for the Friday mailbag. As always, send your questions to me via Twitter at BFeldmanCBS.

From @PatrickSmith45  I keep hearing how good Zach Mettenberger of LSU is. If he was that good wouldn't he have pushed for playing time this past year?

The vibe around LSU right now is really, really intriguing. The Tigers were so close to punctuating one of the great seasons by a team, but then get dominated by Alabama in their own backyard. LSU's offense was atrocious. Before the game, whenever someone asked me where LSU would rank with the all-time great teams, I tempered my answer because for as outstanding as they were on defense and special teams, their QB play was nowhere near that level, and on Monday night, it really showed.
That said, almost everyone I talked to last week sounded convinced the Tigers were in the midst of a great run considering that they have so many key guys in the program who are freshmen and sophomores. They had 16 players on the two-deep, including seven starters who were sophs or younger. People knew they'd likely lose Mo Claiborne, their superb CB, early to the NFL. Both QBs were playing their last game Monday as well, but you have to wonder if that's such a bad thing given how the showing in the BCS title game. Jordan Jefferson looked completely lost and his back-up Jarrett Lee didn't even inspire enough confidence in his coaches to bail them out when things looked so bleak.

No one has ever questioned one-time Georgia QB Zach Mettenberger's arm, and after a season at Butler County CC in Kansas, where he had a 32-4 TD-INT ratio, the expectations around the 6-6, 230-pounder only grew. Many of the people inside the program are sold. 

I spoke to Mettenberger and his teammates a lot a few days ago about how LSU goes forward after the BCS game.  Mettenberger said he'd hoped he could've getting a shot at the starting QB job in 2011, but "Coach Miles didn't see it that way," he said. "It was tough at first but I couldn't get upset as long you're winning."

Mettenberger said he could hardly wait for Tuesday (the day after the BCS title game) because "that's when it's my team.

It's gonna be like getting a Maserati when you turn 16. I really think our offense can be special."

Obviously, the Tigers offense looked anything but special against Alabama the other night. Give a lot of credit to the Tide for that, but also there has been plenty of finger-pointing going on in the state of Louisiana. And, if you follow (former?) LSU WR Russell Shepard on Twitter, you see it's not just fans and media (and parents of Tiger players) doing it. Maybe Mettenberger will instill enough faith in his coaches to change that.

Listening to WR Odell Beckham Jr., one of those gifted young players in the program, that is the hope. "Me and Zach always talk about next year," Beckham said last Friday. "Zach wants to break a lot of records. 

"One of the things I really about him is he's not afraid to take a risk. He also really does have a cannon for an arm."

Mettenberger said he's learned to become more of a passer than just a thrower. "I used to 'juice' everything." He also said he's realized he has to be quicker with his decisions thanks to his time on the Tigers practice field this year. "If you're a split-second too late on a timing route, (Claiborne and Tyrann Mathieu) are gonna jump it."
As for the off-field issues Mettenberger had at Georgia, he said he's "changed my ways of life. You gotta learn to grow up."

We'll see if he is the answer for LSU in 2012. If not, there's dual-threat redshirt freshman Jerrard Randall, who Beckham says has an even stronger arm than Mettenberger, and blue-chip recruit Gunnar Kiel, arguably the No. 1 QB prospect in the country.

From @BruCam87 What can we expect out of Mora and UCLA next year? The talent level seems to be higher than any PAC 12 South team except SC. 

That's been the problem with the Bruins over the past two, three, 10 years or so. The talent "seems" pretty high. They have loaded up on guys who look the part, but they've gotten bogged down by landing too many guys who simply don't love football and aren't as competitive as you need to have an elite program. 

When I visited with Jim Mora a few weeks back he told me he was determined to make this a tougher team. If that's Mission No. 1, that will help right away, but a lot of that also will come back to recruiting and bringing in tougher, hungrier kids. 

What you had in 2011 was a team that was really mediocre on both sides of the ball. I suspect new OC Noel Mazzone will improve the offense because his scheme will be a better fit to the talent than the pistol has been. It'll also help getting back stud LT Xavier Su'a-Filo from the LDS mission after two years away. This program has been so thin on quality O-linemen and Big X is the best that has been on that campus in a decade. And I do agree with you that, given all of the transition in the Pac-12 South, you won't have to be a top 25 team to finish second in that division.

From @hanleyf6 Sal Sunseri has accepted DC job at TN. Why leave Bama? Lots of uncertainty with Dooley's status and major rebuilding job. 

Sunseri's already won BCS titles as an assistant at Bama, and while he's well-regarded as a recruiter, if he can help spark the Vols' resurgence after a dreadful 2011 at a time when that program seems in disarray, his stock will sky-rocket. Even though, there is increasing speculation that if Derek Dooley has another season like he did in 2011 or even close to as bad, he won't be the coach at UT in 2013, keep in mind that Sunseri is getting a reported three-year deal that'll be worth almost $2.5 million. There is stability in that.

On the back side of Sunseri's decision is this: if he stays at Bama, Nick Saban gets most of the credit and Tide DC Kirby Smart gets basically what's left over. By leaving, Sunseri is positioning himself for a much larger spotlight.

From Irishsox05 Is college football ever going to move in the hash marks to match the NFL?  

Interesting question. Never really thought about it. The differing hash marks affect so much of the game in terms of scheming and the kinds of plays people run (wide-side versus boundary). It's also a big consideration for defensive "landmarks" for things such as plotting out coverage areas with the Cover-2, etc. 
  My hunch is the NCAA sticks with what they have because they'd like to keep things as unique for college and traditional as they can, rather than make another stop just to be more like the pros.

From @PaulPabst If we moved to a plus-one or playoff, best case scenario ... which season would it start?

It would start in the 2014 season with the Plus-One (playoff) games taking place in January of 2015.

From @RedKirby What's your prediction for Tx Tech next year? 

My guess is the Red Raiders will make a bowl game in 2012 after missing out this past season. Seth Doege is back at QB. He had an inconsistent year as a first-time starter, but he figures to be better with another year of seasoning. Getting RB Eric Stephens back after missing half the season with a knee injury also will help a bunch. It'll also be interesting to see what they can get from a crew of WRs who didn't play in 2011: Derek Edwards, Tyson Williams and UF transfer Javares McRoy. The O-line did lose some solid players and will see how new coach Sam Pitman can bring them together.

The biggest question is on defense, where the Red Raiders have been among the nation's worst on D for the past two years. They don't lose much to graduation and Tommy Tuberville reshuffled his staff with some more experienced coaches. I expect things to be better on that side of the ball. 

Big picture, this team should get at least seven wins since they have one of the better QBs in the conference and more experience in their top 44.

From @rbode17 Which of Florida's big 3 will have the best 2012 season? 

I'll go with FSU. They finished 2011 with the most momentum, have the QB who is furthest along (E.J. Manuel) and have the best defense. They also have the most stability of the staffs among the Big Three.

From @Kentuckyclem how come the national media does not cover or do an exposé on over signing in the SEC? Seems to be the common denominator...

The national media has covered that topic. A lot. You can Google it and all the times we've talked about it in print. Not to mention all of the times many of us have been asked about it on the radio or on national TV shows.

From @DavidAnderson89 how come u didn't choose the CBS hat off the table when u made "the decision"?

That hat stuff is so 2008. Tweeting it made more sense. ... Better question, how come a man of your stature, didn't do something creative with your decision, like picking a Colorado State ski hat over a Boise State ski hat and a Stanford beret? 

Since: Feb 24, 2007
Posted on: January 14, 2012 3:20 pm

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

USC...Maserati??? More like a Chevy Mailibu with a Earl Shive paint job that's fixing to run out of gas...USC 8-4 next year...count on it. THEN the scholarship limitation hit...back to an als- Pete the Cheat to save your rears this time...just Lame-ass Kitten. Itys alway fun to watch pathetic PAC 10 schools try to compete with the BIG

Since: Feb 24, 2007
Posted on: January 14, 2012 2:39 pm

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

Hey-seed Suckeye:

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA...only in the Big 10. Tattoos for worthless Michigan v OSU pants??? NOW THAT IS FUNNY!!! Cars, wheels, stereos, ipods, drugs, woman...yup, the Big Ten sure knows how to do-it-up-right...especially, the lOSUr State University Suck-eyes.

BUT WAIT...there is sooooo much more to the snot-nosed-elites in the Big 10. There are perverts that populate the Big 10...SHOCK!!! We in the SEC were always told by the "enlightened" Big 10 alum that marrying our cousins was akin to sexual deviancy. We tried to explain that is more myth than fact, but Big 10  refused to listen. NOW WE KNOW WHY!!! It's called tactixcl deception; ONLY in the Big 10...HAHAHAHAHA...would universities think football and a the "repuation" weak as it is...of nasty old man and his buddies is more important than the innocence of a child. Now the POS wants sympathy cause he got cancer. I wish no ill-will on anyone, but I hope he is afforded the same level of empathy/sympathy he gave those young boys. As far as Sandusky---he knows what he needs to do...FOR ONCE, he needs to be a man and end this. 

SEAUX, be shame, Hey-seed shame., just like your pathetic conference.

Since: Oct 21, 2007
Posted on: January 14, 2012 2:05 pm

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

Mettenberger plus Kiel at quarterback will be a huge position improvement.  Beckham and Randle plus several talented freshmen are on board at receiver.  Add Rival 4 star WR Avery Johnson, 4 star WR Travin Dural.  Very good depth at TE and a talented group of running backs that can catch and run and the picture for 2012 looks bright.  Now add a top flight offensive coordinator Les. 

Since: Nov 25, 2010
Posted on: January 14, 2012 2:04 pm

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati


only in the SEC....

can a kid get kicked out of one school for beating a women, and the other schools are pounding at his door and giving him the keys to the progam.

sounds like Cam 2.0

love the article the says les offered him shortly after Georgia kicked him off the team.....

you guys should be so proud of your dominance....




Since: Jul 26, 2011
Posted on: January 14, 2012 12:27 pm

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

If a receiver can step up for the Georgia, they will have a scary offense.  Crowell and Keith Marshall could be straight nasty out of the back field.  Im not to worried about losing Orson, Arthur Lynch and Jay Rome will shine next year.  With the offensive line getting Theus, Murray should be protected well.

Since: Sep 13, 2006
Posted on: January 14, 2012 11:01 am

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

You do realize that "the Bughatti" lost by three touchdowns to a mediocre Arizona State team, right?

Since: Aug 18, 2010
Posted on: January 14, 2012 9:59 am

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

First of all, it's not a Maserati.  Where did you get that concept from?  Maybe a big 18 wheeler?  WHere do they have world class WRs?  They do have really good RBs coming back, but nothing on the outside like maybe....USC.

So, let me say it for you Sir.  The Bughatti is in the garage waiting for Matt Barkley.  I would take a Bughatti vs a Maserati any day.  If there is anyone who dissagrees tell me why, LSUs Offense will be better than Mighty Troy's offense.

1.  Matt Barkley
2.  Robert Woods
3.  Marquise Lee
4.  Randal Telfer (Fred Davis type TE #1)
4.  Xavier Grimble(Fred Davis type TE #2)
5.  Curtis McNeal
6.  Victor Blackwell (next WR to shine)
7.  George Farmer (bigger and probably faster..better than all WRs)
Scarey, huh?


Since: Jul 28, 2007
Posted on: January 14, 2012 2:37 am

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

It would be great if they actually let him throw the forward pass-and not just against inferior competition.

Since: Aug 24, 2009
Posted on: January 13, 2012 11:20 pm

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

No sir, that would be a VW dressed in a million dollar tux, but, nontheless a VW. Alabama will keep the shine bright on the Continental, that's Bentley for you VW driving guys on the left coast.

Roll Tide!

BTW- Shouldn't men, women and boys of troy be concerned about keeping the Crystal Balls they got before they try to start adding anymore?

Since: Nov 22, 2006
Posted on: January 13, 2012 10:29 pm

Friday Mailbag: Mettenberger's Maserati

not really.   i mean, c'mon, u got 4 RBs for LSU that all would be starters if they were all on 4 different teams.   several ( i believe last count was 5) WRs that are really good.   with an O-line returning so many starts next year, the stable of running backs coming back (and probably the #1 blue chip RB in LA) AND the trio of QBs that will be battling for a starting position (and all 3 would be starters if they were all on different teams), i would take LSU over A-SEE (condom university) any day of the week.  hell, arkansas would beat that team you're speaking of.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or