Blog Entry

Tuesday Top 10: Best assistant moves

Posted on: February 7, 2012 1:02 pm
As we try and size up the best and worst head coaching hires of the the past few months, I thought it was worth delving into some of the top in-the-trenches guys and staffers who made news but on a much smaller scale during "the silly season" that is the coaching carousel. This week's Top 10: best assistant moves:

1. Oklahoma hiring back Mike Stoops as defensive coordinator: Some Sooner fans have been lamenting the Mike Stoops Jinx for years now noting that OU football hasn't been as tough or as effective, especially in big games since Bob Stoops' fiery brother left for Arizona. On paper, the younger Stoops brother certainly left a mark, coaching OU to the top or near the top in almost every significant defensive statistic. He also sparked OU to a school-best 48 wins over a four-year stretch from 2000-03 that included a BCS national title. During that four-year stretch OU had three top-five finishes and produced 10 All-Americans on defense. In the eight years since he's been out of Norman, the Sooners have only had two top-five finishes and six All-Americans on D. 

2. Washington hires Tosh Lupoi as D-line coach: The Huskies had been atrocious on defense prompting Steve Sarkisian to make some tough changes. One of them meant breaking the bank for the 30-year old former Cal assistant, who helped mentor some really good defensive linemen for the Golden Bears with Cameron Jordan and Tyson Alualu both becoming first-rounders in recent years. However, Lupoi's biggest impact comes off the field, where his departure shook up the recruiting world in the past few months. Five-star DB Shaq Thompson took a late visit up to U-Dub and ended up signing with the Huskies. Lupoi also got long-time USC DE commit Pio Vatuvei to flip to Washington on Signing Day. If Lupoi doesn't bolt for Seattle, Cal probably reels in a Top 10 recruiting class despite the fact that it has a sub .500 record in league play the past three years. But the coach's exit torpedoed that, and yes, it was messy. Expect many more fireworks in the coming year and for U-Dub to be a player nationally on the recruiting scene as long as Lupoi is with the Huskies.

3. Michigan State retains DC Pat Narduzzi: Arguably the most underrated defensive coordinator in college football, Narduzzi was courted by Kevin Sumlin after the new Texas A&M coach arrived at the SEC program, but MSU was able to hang onto the Youngstown product. That's quite a coup for the Spartans. In 2010, Narduzzi led MSU to one of its better defensive seasons in years. But going into last season he had to replace four of the top five tacklers, including star LB Greg Jones. The result: the Spartans played even better. MSU was No. 6 in the country in total defense; No. 10 in scoring; No. 7 in sacks and No. 9 against the run. They won 11 games and finished in the Top 10 for the first time since the Nick Saban days in the late '90s.

4. UNC lands Vic Koenning as its defensive coordinator: One of the best moves Ron Zook made at Illinois was flipping the keys to Koenning to run his defense. Koenning transformed the Illini D from 91st nationally to No. 7 in one year. He also sparked a dramatic improvement in K-State's defense at his previous stop. In his last stint in the ACC, at Clemson, Koenning (pronounced "CONE-ing") did something no other Tiger DC ever could do:  Each of his four defenses from 2005-2008 finished in the top 25 in scoring, total, and pass efficiency defense each season.

5. Urban Meyer reunites with Mickey Marotti as Ohio State gets a new strength coach: A huge key for Meyer in his run at UF was surrounding himself with a great staff. With the possible exception of Charlie Strong, no other assistant was more vital to UF's success in that time than Marotti, who goes back with Meyer to their days in Columbus in the late 80s when both were just beginning their coaching careers. When Meyer talked about his new staff at OSU, Marotti was the one he called his "most important hire." The one-time OSU grad assistant developed 22 All-Americans and eight first-rounders during his seven years in Gainesville.

6. Jim Mora recruits his ace recruiters: The new UCLA head coach had never really worked in college and there was a lot of skepticism about how the NFL lifer would acclimate to things like recruiting. Well, Mora wasted little time getting up to speed by landing a couple of assistants with deep California connections in O-line coach Adrian Klemm and Demetrice Martin, a pair of aggressive young assistants who grew up in the L.A. area. Martin helped snag Ellis McCarthy, perhaps the top defensive lineman on the West Coast, along with touted DE Jeremy Castro, while Klemm nabbed a bunch of other blue-chippers that included CB Ishmael Adams, WR Jordan Payton and OT Lacy Westbrook.

7. Paul Chryst brings O-line coach Bob Bostad to Pitt: The Panthers were beyond brutal up front. They ranked dead last in the NCAA in sacks allowed with an eye-popping 64-- 17 more than the next worst team. You almost never see such wide gaps in the pits of the NCAA ineptitude stats. That figures to get a whole lot better under Chryst and Bostad. The former Badger O-line coach developed four all-Americans in the past two seasons alone (Gabe Carimi, John Moffitt, Kevin Zeitler and Peter Konz) as Wisconsin rushed for over 3,000 yards the past two seasons en route to consecutive Rose Bowl appearances. Bostad's O-line actually allowed two few sacks in the past three seasons combined in 40 games than Pitt surrendered in 2011.

8. Rich Rodriguez finally gets Jeff Casteel back to run his defense: Rodriguez' biggest shortcoming from his time at Michigan was not being able to have his former WVU DC with him to run the Wolverines defense. Casteel has coached defenses that have finished in the top 15 in scoring D in four of the previous seven seasons. In 2010, the Mountaineers were third in the nation in scoring defense. Better still, Casteel is bringing a couple of WVU defensive assistants with him to Tucson who knew exactly what he wants and does. They will have plenty of work ahead of them in the most diverse offensive league as they inherit a team that was 107th in scoring defense and 116th in sacks.

9. Florida goes to Boise for its new OC: Charlie Weis had a very shaky season in Gainesville as the Gators stumbled in their transition season out of the Urban Meyer offense, finishing 105th in the country in total offense. Pease moves south after working with one of the most productive QBs in college history (Kellen Moore). The 47-year-old Pease also had a lot of success in his days at Montana in the 90s and had some good moments leading an undermanned Kentucky offense in the SEC before moving to Boise.

10. Mike Locksley is back at Maryland: No doubt Locksley had a disastrous run as New Mexico's head coach, going 2-26 and being at the center of a few off-field scandals. He signs on with second-year coach Randy Edsall, who had a disastrous beginning with the Terps going 2-10 with only one win over an FBS opponent. But never underestimate the recruiting juice Locksley has, especially in that part of the country.  He will get kids who would never get within sniffing distance of Edsall's program to give the Terps a long, hard look now. And the school made sure to sweeter Locksley's deal on that front. According to the Washington Post, if Maryland is ranked in the top 40 by either or's recruiting rankings on National Signing Day, Locksley will earn $25,000. He'll also get an additional $20,000 if the Terrapins place in the top four of ACC teams in the or's rankings on National Signing Day.

Since: Oct 12, 2011
Posted on: February 8, 2012 9:03 am

Tuesday Top 10: Best assistant moves

Teres Minor - Casteel's decission to stay at WVU instead of heading to Michigan with RR had nothing to do with money.    Casteel (from Uniontown, PA) and especially assistants Bill Kirelawach (has lived in Morgantown for 20+ years) and Dave Lockwood (1989 WVU grad) were all ,essentially, home-town boys and did not want to leave WVU regardless of the dollars thrown at them.  Things changed this time around because of the shotgun wedding nature of Holgerson's hiring as coach in waiting, and Bill Stewart going off the deep end before this season got underway.  It was only a matter of time before things broke down, and to be honest, I think Holgerson has a right to hire who he wants on his staff.  The word on the street in Morgantown is that Kirelawach and Holgerson especially didn't get along.  Holgerson told Casteel that Krelawach and Lockwood would not be returning next year and Casteel decided it was time for him to move on as well.  It's a stroke of luck for RR because I don't think he would have been able to get Casteel to go to Arizona otherwise.

stevephoenix - I'm not going to argue with you because arguing with a moron would only make me look like a moron. 

Since: Aug 7, 2008
Posted on: February 8, 2012 2:38 am

Tuesday Top 10: Best assistant moves

The best assistant move by far is new Arizona HC Rich Rodriguez getting West Virgina DC Jeff Casteel to leave that small unimportant school & fan less base for UA.

Since: Dec 1, 2006
Posted on: February 7, 2012 10:26 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Best assistant moves

Best hire bar none is Paul Haynes at Arkansas as DC. Willy Robinson-the old DC took the Hogs as far as he could take them, but they still didn't defend like you need to be NC. The Razorbacks tackled better in the Cotton Bowl than they did all year and had a solid game plan to stop KSU's running QB. Also, Haynes brought his friend as LB coach. They are both top notch Ohio-Midwest recruiters.

Since: Jun 5, 2011
Posted on: February 7, 2012 8:43 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Best assistant moves

The worst facet of the Rich Rod era at Michigan was that Bill Martin refused to outbid a cesspool like WVU for their DC.  Even with all of Lloyd Carr's sabotage, RR might have been able to make a much better case for himself if Martin had let him hire Casteel and pay him what he was worth.  Michigan's tradition of underpaying coaches was more important to ex-banker Martin than having a fighting chance at being ahead of the curve with the X's and O's for once.

Since: Jul 31, 2010
Posted on: February 7, 2012 8:02 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Best assistant moves

Hey Bruce,

 Being an NC State fan, I have to say that the Wolfpack being able to retain Jon Tenuta  would rank very high in Raleigh! 

Since: Feb 7, 2012
Posted on: February 7, 2012 1:17 pm

Tuesday Top 10: Best assistant moves

While Arkansas quietly made their staff changes, they did make significant changes that should pay off. Brought in two former Ohio State assistant coaches at needed positions, Paul Petrino as OC, promoted Steve Caldwell(formerly of Fulmer's Tennessee staff) to Special Teams co-ordinator, and promoted from within to fill the Defensive Tackles position.

The change in Defensive coordinator and Linebackers coach will have the biggest impact.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or