Blog Entry

AL Pre-Season Rankings

Posted on: February 14, 2008 12:56 pm

AL East: Once again the AL East will be dominated by the larger-market Yankees and Red Sox, with everyone else trying to compete by getting more out of their players for less money.

Boston - They won the division and the Pennant last year. So why mess with success? They only got rid of guys like Eric Gagne and Matt Clement, that didn't perform for them last year. So their only real addition of back-up 1B Sean Casey should be enough to keep 'em on top. 


N.Y. Yankees - After their bismal start last year, the Yanks came on strong towards the end. The major thing that the Yankess did was dismiss a lot of the distractions and controversies. Joe Torre is gone, and the media has stopped the nonsense about Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez. It will be interesting to see hwo the new managercan handle all the talent and egos on this team. Another key to look out for is the injuries to some of their aging players. Still, no way they don't wind up either 1 or 2 in this division 

Toronto - Typically when teams trade big men it's always going to be a toss-up. As long as Scott Rolen  remains healthy, the combonation of Roloen and David Eckstein has a lot more upside than the loss of Troy Glaus. This will help them edge ever closer to the Red Sox and Yankees, but they've still got a long way to go.


Tampa Bay - The Rays have made some changes... new park, new design... even got rid of the "devil." Troy Percival, Matt Garza, Cliff Floyd are nice pickups in an attempt to get the "devil off their shoulder." In the end these will be the same sub-par expansion team that they have been in the past. They just can't compete with the top of this division.

Baltimore - Minor league prospects are a major part of baseball, especially if a team is looking for longevity. The Diamondbacks and Rockies playing in the NL Championship last year was perfect proof of this. Now the O's have jumped on the band wagon and gave up Erik Bedard Miguel Tejada to do it... I just don't think its a recipe for success in the AL because of the offensive mindset. So either the O's are making the riskiest move in recent baseball history or they've officially gone into "rebuild" status.




AL Central:   There were some good moves, and some unfortunate moves that were inevitable in this division. The parody in the AL just isn't what it is in the NL.... too bad. A few changes in the standings for the AL Central, but unless some young prospects payoff there's not going to be much of a division race here.


Cleveland - For the most part Cleveland stood firm and didn't make a lot of player movements. Outside of adding Japanese pitcher Masahide Kobayashi (I keep thinking of "The Usual Suspects" when I read his name) to their lineup which should bolster their pitching. If C.C. Sabathia can have a repeat year this will be one of the best pitching teams in the AL. They won't be the surprise team they were last year.




 Detroit : In an attempt to keep up with Cleveland the Tigers have finally wrestled Dontrelle Willis away from the Marlins. I expect great things out of him, despite his down year last year. They've also added Edgar Renteria to their lineup while only giving up Sean Casey and  Omar Infante.  They'll be nipping at the heels of the Indians this year.



Chi. White Sox - Their off-season pick-ups of Scott Linebrink, Orlando Cabrera, Octavio Dotel, Nick Swisher, and Carlos Quentin should rocket them past the Twins this year. Many of these players are role players, so despite picking up some solid players the losses of Scott Podsednik and  Darin Erstad will hurt.

Minnesota - Probably the biggest losers in the off season moves this team is going to be a shell of it's mediocre performance from last year. They lost house-hold players Johan Santana, Torii Hunter, and Carlos Silva. They had a few nice pick-ups, but without the masterful pitching of Santana this team is in trouble, especially when you consider that Livan Hernandez is now a starter in the AL (I can only imagine how much is 4.25 carreer ERA in the NL will explode now that he's in the AL).  Their losses far outweight their gains and they'll take a big step backwards this year.


Kansas City - Picking up role players and guys in the twilight of their carreers is not a way to pull yourselves out of the cellar in the AL. I like the pick up of Jose GuillenAlberto Callaspo and  Brett Tomko will have positive roles for the team, but are not going to make a significant difference for this team. I'm curious to see how the pick-up of Japanese relief pitcherYasuhiko Yabuta works out for them. 
They didn't lose an incredible amount, but Jason LaRue, Mike Sweeney and Emil Brown were all consistent players.



AL West: The desparity between the top and the bottom of this division isn't quite as bad as the East or the Central, and it should be tighter than it was last year for this division.

L.A. Angels - They won the division in a landslide last year, and they did a nice job with the few off-season moves they made (similar to most teams at the top of their divisions). They got a great pick-up in Torii Hunter, and Jon Garland will prove to be a solid innings eater to add to their already loaded r. They lost Orlando Cabrera, but I think its more than compensated for by Hunter. They will win the division, but not quite as handily because of the off-season moves that Seattle made.

Seattle - They did a nice job this offseason with the free agency market by picking up Carlos Silva, Brad Wilkerson, and  Erik Bedard. All three of these guys will be instant impact players to go alongside Ichiro. They lost Ben Broussard, Jose Guillen, but they'll be much more consistent and solid than last year. It will be interesting to see how this one pans out.

Texas - They lost Freddy Guzman and Brad Wilkerson, and took some risks to replace them by signing Jason Jennings, Eddie Guardado, Kazuo Fukumori and Milton Bradley. They're going to be in the middle of the pack in the AL, but won't be able to effectively challenge the Mariners or the Angels.

Oakland - If it weren't for the horrible off-season moves by the A's, the Rangers would have this spot. As usual, the A's are known for paying a little and expecting a lot, and their off-season moves showed just that. They picked up a lot of nobody's and prospects in an attempt to replace Jeff DaVanon, Dan Haren, Mark Kotsay, and Nick Swisher. This off-season is going to come back and bite them in the end.


Since: Sep 27, 2007
Posted on: February 18, 2008 9:40 pm

AL Pre-Season Rankings

like i've told everyone before. the sleeper team in the american league is the toronto blue jays. who have better starting pitching then most of the teams you guys rank ahead of them. so, i guess we will have to see. but i like it like that cause when they win i can look back and say i told you guys so. just like i said with the new york football giants.

Since: Sep 20, 2006
Posted on: February 17, 2008 11:29 am

AL Pre-Season Rankings

Sports_fan_3: That's a tough one... I'm typically not one to throw out Chapmionship predictions early in the season because there are typically at least 5 or 6 teams that could be considered "favorites" at the beginning of the year.

I would've said the Red Sox would be a likely chance to repeat, but since the developing situation with Curt Schilling over the past week, they may not even win their division this year, and they certainly won't have the pitching strength to carry them through the playoffs. So I'm going to have to go with the Angels in the American league.

The NL is a bit tougher because there isn't as much seperation in the league as there is in the AL. The Cubs, Braves, Diamondbacks, and Padres all have strong arguments as to why they could wind up there, but there's no logic in predicting "underdogs" until the playoffs are actually upon us several months from now. So, clearly NYM is the favorite, especially with the addition of Johan Santana. They typically do a very good job against AL teams.

So the preseason favorites are the Angels and the Mets. With the Angels winning in 6.

Since: Nov 4, 2006
Posted on: February 17, 2008 7:43 am

AL Pre-Season Rankings

Well done! All I can say is: don't  be surprised to see a four way, neck and neck race to the end in the AL East. I think that the Rays have a fighting chance this year, a lot of their players will be maturing. And the Blue Jays are certainly an improving team. I think that we could see a World Series of the 1998 expansion teams in the near future, especially now that the Rays got the Devil off their backs, that's not a good ally to have :)

Since: Sep 8, 2006
Posted on: February 16, 2008 10:26 pm

AL Pre-Season Rankings

Hey, I just have a quick question for you........Who do you have in the World Series this year, and who do you have winning the World Series. (Sorry if you have already posted this answer because if you have already I didn't catch the answer, THANKS)

Since: Apr 10, 2007
Posted on: February 15, 2008 3:57 pm

AL Pre-Season Rankings

spell check?

Since: Sep 27, 2006
Posted on: February 15, 2008 1:02 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

Since: Jun 8, 2007
Posted on: February 14, 2008 4:04 pm

AL Pre-Season Rankings

Not at all.  I was saying I disagreed with the first author's assertion that the Indians would win.  I absolutely think the Tigers had the best acquisitions of the offseason and are poised to take the Central

Since: Aug 30, 2007
Posted on: February 14, 2008 3:53 pm

AL Pre-Season Rankings

Hey, just wanted to let you know that we gave you a little spotlight on the .

Keep up the good work!

Since: Sep 20, 2006
Posted on: February 14, 2008 3:36 pm

AL Pre-Season Rankings

The Comets: Are you saying the Tigers don't have a chance to take the division? They certainly do, infact I debated quite a bit as to put on top before finally settling on the Indians because of their line-up.  I think the new Japanese pitcher  will help keep the Indians on top. But that pick up of Willis is huge by the Tigers, but it will be interesting to see how he comes off of a bad season in the NL and adapts to the AL....

Since: Jun 8, 2007
Posted on: February 14, 2008 2:45 pm

AL Pre-Season Rankings

I agree with about everything.  I do disagree about the Tigers chances of taking the Central.  You forgot to mention the phenomenal pick up of Miguel Cabrera at 3B.  Also shifting Carlos to 1B should minimize injury and maximize his bat.  I think they have a chance, Sabathia or no.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or