Blog Entry

Top 60 prospects for the 2009 mlb draft

Posted on: February 26, 2009 11:21 am
Edited on: February 26, 2009 12:09 pm

You want some baseball info, fine; I’ll give you some baseball info. Here are the top 60 draft eligible baseball prospects for the 2009 amateur draft. As a disclaimer, I made this list by first creating my top 15 high school pitchers, college pitchers, college bats, and high school bats. Then I ranked those 60 prospects. So, this is not a true big board but, it is certainly a good working list. I do not have capsules on individual players but, I have put them into tiers, and analyzed the groups a little, enjoy. As far as the blog is concerned, I am working on some NBA stuff, and creating an Astros spring training power list… more on that later. As always, comments are much appreciated.

Top 60 2009 MLB Draft Prospects

1. Steven Strasburg RHP San Diego State

He’s the consensus top pick in the 2009 draft. He will become one of the top three pitching prospects when he’s drafted.

2. Alex White RHP North Carolina

3. Grant Green SS Southern California

4. Dustin Ackley 1B/OF North Carolina

These are the next three prospects, all coming out of college. They will likely go between picks two and four in the draft, unless one of the two high school lefties goes ahead of them.

5. Matthew Purke LHP HS Texas

6. Donovan Tate OF HS Georgia

7. Kyle Gibson RHP Missouri

8. Tyler Matzek LHP HS California

9. Aaron Crow RHP Missouri/Independent League

Purke and Matzek are the aforementioned lefties both have low 90s fastballs and advanced breaking balls. Tate has a ton of upside as a five-tooler but, has a strong football commitment to North Carolina. Gibson and Crow are the next group of college pitchers. Crow was picked by the Nationals with the ninth pick last year.

10. Andrew Oliver LHP Oklahoma State

11. Kentrail Davis OF Tennessee

12. Shelby Miller RHP HS Texas

13. Jacob Turner RHP HS Georgia

14. Robbie Shields 2B Florida Southern

15. Mychal Givens RHP/SS HS Florida

16. Matt Davidson 3B HS California

A mixed group here but, any of these seven could go tenth after the top nine are drafted. Givens is an interesting player as he has garnered attention as a possible five-tool shortstop or as a pitcher with a 95 mph heater.

17. Mike Minor LHP Vanderbilt

18. Austin Maddox C HS Florida

19. Luke Bailey C Georgia

20. Zach Wheeler RHP HS Georgia

21. Josh Phegley C Indiana

22. Tanner Scheppers RHP Fresno State/Independent League

23. Kendal Volz RHP Baylor

This group is filled with guys with who there are varying opinions. Minor, Maddox, Scheppers, Phegley, and Volz could all go inside the top 12 picks however; they could also slip to the back end of the first round. Bailey and Wheeler are the exceptions to that rule though, and should go between 18, and 23. Wheeler is currently the guy I am looking at for the Astros with the 21<sup>st</sup> pick.

24. Ben Tootle RHP Jacksonville State

25. Jason Stoffel RHP Arizona

26. Ryan Jackson SS Miami

27. Brian Goodwin OF HS North Carolina

28. Max Stassi C HS California

Tootle and Stoffel are the two best pure relievers in the draft while, the latter three are position players who could be chosen ahead of them. Jackson is a defensive specialist who could jump ahead in the draft – like Jermile Weeks last year – Goodwin is the classic five-tool high school outfielder, and Stassi is the fourth elite catcher in the draft. The order of this group all comes down to taste.

29. AJ Pollock 2B/OF Notre Dame

30. Matt Graham RHP HS Texas

31. Keyvius Sampson RHP HS Florida

32. Robert Stock C Southern California

33. Alex Wilson RHP Texas A&M

34. Chris Jenkins RHP HS New Jersey

35. Jake Marisnick OF HS California

The two college position players here (Stock and Pollock) are both rather polarizing. I know I just said there were only four elite catchers BUT, five could go in the first round, and Stock had a very impressive opening weekend. Pollock isn’t gifted with an abundance of tools but, he has excellent discipline at the plate, has speed, and most importantly delivers. I like him. The high school pitchers are all high upside guys, Sampson could go in the first twenty though, while the others will have to wait till the back end of the first or even supplemental round. Wilson plays for the best college team in the nation, and had a very good opening weekend, like Stock, he is a safe pick.

36. Ryan Wheeler 1B/3B Layola Marymount

37. Ryan Ortiz C/1B Oregon State

38. Daniel Webb RHP Northwest Florida State CC

Nothing too special about this group, if one of them does rise into the first round it may be Webb, who was considered a first round talent last season but, dropped deep into the draft, and went to junior college to try and raise his stock while remaining eligible. Wheeler has some upside but, you can find first basemen with 25 homerun power later on.

Ortiz is very questionable at catcher but, if a team thinks he can stick there, and the above five are gone he could be the sixth catcher in the first round… that would be something.

39. Jonathan Walsh 3B/C HS Texas

40. Beau Wright LHP HS California

41. Sean Black RHP Seton Hall

42. Chris Dominguez 3B Louisville

43. Brett Jackson OF California

44. LeVon Washington OF/2B HS Florida

45. DJ LeMaheiu SS/3B LSU

46. Bobby Borchering 3B HS Florida

A seventh catcher? Maybe, Walsh is a terrific athlete, with a strong arm, and very good hitting ability. I think he is going to be a steal if he is not drafted in the first round. Dominguez has an enormous amount of power and a very strong arm from third but, is probably the biggest strikeout risk in the draft, and that will cause him to slip. Borchering is a switch hitter with good hitting ability from both sides. He is a good defender, with a good arm from third.

47. Devan Marrero SS HS Florida

48. Jared Mitchel OF Louisiana State

49. Blake Smith RHP/OF California

50. Ben Paulsen 1B Clemson

51. Chad Thompson HS California

52. Jiovanni Mier SS HS California

53. Brad Boxberger RHP Southern California

54. Ian Krol LHP HS Illinois

55. Jonathan Singleton 1B HS California

56. Colton Cain 1B/LHP HS Texas

57. Randal Grichuk OF HS Texas

58. Tyler Skaggs LHP HS California

59. Geno Escalante C HS California

60. Byran Berglund RHP HS California

I bunched what would have been the last two groups. It filled with some high upside shortstops, high school lefties, and such. Marrero, Mitchel, Mier, and Boxberger have the best chance of moving up into the first round. Some of the high school pitchers in this group are the types to be taken in the supplemental round.


There’s your top 60.



Category: MLB

Since: Apr 29, 2009
Posted on: April 29, 2009 3:48 pm

Top 60 prospects for the 2009 mlb draft

Real Baseball Intelligence (RBI), a leading resource in the evaluation of amateur baseball talent and draft coverage, is currently taking orders for its 2009 Baseball Draft Guide.  The Guide includes our Top 400 rankings, hundreds of scouting reports, a mock draft and more.  Learn more at

Since: Aug 16, 2006
Posted on: February 27, 2009 9:38 pm

Top 60 prospects for the 2009 mlb draft

I will say that I missed on Mike Leake who outduled Kyle Gibson this week.



Since: Aug 16, 2006
Posted on: February 27, 2009 9:37 pm

Top 60 prospects for the 2009 mlb draft

I have never heard of him before.  How are his secondary pitches?  How is his command?  Does he know how to use his pitches?  The answer to these questions would explain why he hasn't shown up on draft boards.


Since: Feb 27, 2009
Posted on: February 27, 2009 7:50 pm

Top 60 prospects for the 2009 mlb draft

I am surprised that Mike Monster gets over looked in the high school draft lists, he is a bit of an unknown being from BC Canada,but, when he stands 6'3" - 220lbs and was clocked at the Junior World championships at 95 with movement and very intimmidating mound presence and he just recently turned 18.

He will surprise people in the very near future I am sure.

I know his family has been contacted by a number of MLB interested teams but has anybody south of the boarder seen his name on any lists?



The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or