Blog Entry

Mediate says Woods problem stems with coaches

Posted on: August 31, 2011 11:41 am
Edited on: August 31, 2011 1:28 pm

NORTON, Mass. -- Rocco Mediate is rarely at a loss for words.

Sometimes, that's not a great thing.

The ever-loquacious PGA Tour veteran weighed in with his opinion on old pal Tiger Woods' travails in the San Francisco Chronicle on Wednesday and effectively trashed the fading former No. 1's last two swing coaches.

"I love the way he plays, but I'm disgusted with what's going on with him because it's sad for our game," Mediate said Tuesday. "A lot of guys are happy Tiger isn't playing well. I'm not. ...

"We need to have Tiger back at the top, because he's the draw. It's fantastic all these other kids are winning, but they're not Tiger Woods."


Mediate believes that Woods' new swing under new coach Sean Foley is putting too much stress on his body. By design, it's supposed to do just the opposite, by the way.

"The physical motion is wrong," Mediate told the newspaper. "To get that stress off his body is a piece of cake -- the guys working with him just don't know. Sean knows some stuff, but what's going on with Tiger is not correct. That's why he keeps breaking and that's why the ball keeps going sideways."

Wow, hard to know where to begin here. Mediate knows more about the golf swing than Foley, whose students include Justin Rose and Hunter Mahan, who both won twice last year? Mediate didn't leave out Hank Haney, Woods' former coach, either.

"Starting with Haney until now, it was a complete and absolute destruction," he said.

As an aside -- Woods was more consistent from week to week under Haney than at any point in his career. Haney has the incontrovertible data to back it up. Woods won 45 percent of his starts in their final three seasons together.

"Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but no one is entitled to their own facts," Haney said in an email Wednesday.

Mediate said that if he was coaching Woods at this point, he might bow out.
"If it was me [as his coach], I would say to Tiger, 'Look, dude, I'm not helping you, you're getting worse. You've broken down three times and you've had 57 knee surgeries. It's not happening,'" Mediate said.

So, the assertion here is that none of Woods' issues are of his own making? Really? Recall that 13 months ago, after Haney quit as his coach, Woods hit rock bottom while flying solo at the Bridgestone Invitational, finishing one spot out of dead last, his worst 72-hole finish ever. He was lost and looking for a lifeline, and began working with Foley a week later.

Then there's the loss of his psychological edge, his crisis of confidence, his frequent and various injuries, the fact that his putting has been frequently ghastly, and that he hasn’t won on the U.S. tour in nearly two years. Woods beat Mediate in a 19-hole playoff to win his most recent major title, at the 2008 U.S. Open. Mediate is the defending champ at the Open, where Woods will make his debut in a second-tier Fall Series event on Oct. 6.

If it were only as simple as the swing coach, Woods might have righted the ship by now.

Mediate lauded Woods' decision to play, although it might have been a condition of being added to the Presidents Cup team as an at-large pick. The U.S. team is captained by Fred Couples, who publicly asked Woods to add a tournament because he is ineligible to play in the current four-week FedEx Cup series.

"It just shows another side of him," Mediate said of Woods' commitment to the Fry's event. "He's trying to get better, trying to figure out his swing problem. When he gets his stuff together, he'll be No. 1 again and everything will be back to normal."

Normalcy and Tiger Woods? That not only would be welcome, it would represent a first.


Since: Jan 19, 2009
Posted on: August 31, 2011 6:42 pm

Mediate says Woods problem stems with coaches

I would be willing to bet that Rocco knows more about the golf swing than Elling or any of you microcephalic cretins who have responded. Judging from your comments, you, like Elling cannot break 100 from the forward tees on an executive course!

Since: Dec 4, 2007
Posted on: August 31, 2011 6:28 pm

Mediate says Woods problem stems with coaches

Maybe he has a man-crush on Tiger or something 

Great line. I don't know why he even felt compelled to educate the general public with his useless analysis.  How does he know one of the young budding superstars on tour won't become "the draw" anyway.  It's one thing for these guys to admire all of Woods' golfing accomplishments and greatness during his prime, which is over.  It's another thing for them to accord him "godlike" status.  Give it a rest, already.

Since: Jun 5, 2011
Posted on: August 31, 2011 5:52 pm

Mediate is right

Golf is a game where coaches teach things that aren't really there and don't really happen.  That's why the average Joe has so much trouble with the game.  The golfers who make it do so in spite of coaching, not because of it.  The best golfers use their natural swings and repeat them over and over.  When they do well, their coaches talk themselves into believing that the student is doing what they teach, but they aren't.    

Slow-motion and stop-action have proven that about 90 percent of traditional golf teaching is incorrect.  The head doesn't stay still.  The clubhead doesn't stay square for more than an inch or two either way.   The left arm is almost never totally straight.  Etc ad nauseum.  Since Tiger's dad died and he got rid of Butch Harmon, Tiger has looked like he is always forcing his body to keep too many muscles rigid during his swing.  That is how you pull muscles, damage ligaments and tendons, and get stress fractures.  
Tiger is suffering from "paralysis by analysis."  Despite that, he still wins a lot of tournaments when he is physically able to compete and has had time to practice his latest swing under pressure.  Hopefully, he and Rocco will talk in private.  And Rocco will give Tiger the best advice anyone could give him, regardless of pedigree: "shut up and hit the bleeping ball."

Since: Aug 18, 2010
Posted on: August 31, 2011 12:25 pm

Mediate says Woods problem stems with coaches

Rocco seems a bit delusional with his comments.  Maybe he has a man-crush on Tiger or something.  If Rocco has all the answers, maybe he should leave the tour and just start coaching.  I don't think Rocco will ever see normal again as Tiger will never again be #1.  Get a grip Rocco, you sound like a little school girl, or some of the posters here. 

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or